Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

GLC fiasco

Socialist Organiser no. 221, 28 March 1985 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 1,566 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Mick O'Sullivan (vice-chair, London Bridge, writing in a personal capacity) looks at the chain of events which led to the GLC adopting a Tory/right-wing Labour budget IT HAD been plain for some months that the metropolitan authorities, including the Greater London Council (GLC), were likely to break Labour Party policy and submit to the Rates Act.

Financially, they were able to get through the year 1985-6 within the government limits, without redundancies and possibly even without cuts. Legally, unlike the lower tier authorities (such as London boroughs),, they were explicitly bound to set a rate by a certain date.

Arithmetic

On the GLC the arithmetic was quite simple. With a Labour majority of four, it only needed five abstentions, or three voting with the Tories, to defeat a confrontation strategy. And in fact the centre-right has always had a substantial majority in the GLC Labour group, though the Left fronts for it.

The complexities of legal advice, and the persistence of ten GLC Labour councillors, led to a messier outcome than first foreseen - and forced through, probably for good, a realignment in GLC Labour -Possibunty On Friday March 1 a possibility of the GLC being able to 'go illegal' and defy the Rates Act unexpectedly opened up. Everyone had assumed that the Tories, so as not to risk surcharge, would have to vote for a legal budget. A majority within the GLC Labour group for defying the •Rates Act would have no chance (or risk) of being able to put that policy into practice, since some Labour rightwingers were bound to vote against such a Labour grouppolicy.

But the that the might not charge if plausible abstained defeated.

With the a majority taking a would be illegal.

For all group of legal advice said Tory councillors be liable to surthey presented a budget and then after that was : Tories abstaining, of the Labour group principled stand enough to *go the faults of the councillors round John McDonnell, the simple fact is that they, and they alone, took this possibility seriously - put their money where Ken Livingstone's mouth had been, and consistently fought for a 'fix no rate' policy.

Livingstone, and those round him, actually tried to frustrate this fix no rate' policy, though in words they were committed to it. The fight over the budget has accelerated to lightning speed the transformation of Livingstone and his associates into a new outer-perimeter wall in Kinnock's attempt to build a no-struggle Labour Party. An open breach developed at the London Labour Party regional conference on March 2 and 3. John McDonnell and Lambeth council leader Ted Knight criticised Livingstone for retreating from the fix no rate' position; Livingstone attacked Knight on the grounds that the boroughs (apart from Haçkney) were carefully wording their 'fix no rate' resolutions for March 7 so that they left an escapehatch and did not take the councils into illegality.

The crucial meeting following week was the GLC Labour group on Monday March 4. As the debate progressed, it became more and more obvious to the observers - about 30 from different Constituency Labour Parties - that it might as well have been the Labour group of 10 years or 30 years ago. The struggle for accountability -for delegates rather than politicians - had washed over the GLC. The Constituency Labour Parties were marginal to what the councillors did.

Livingstone opened the budget debate.- His speech effectively sunk the no-rate option, while formally supporting it.

He pointed out that the Tories might abstain, and that therefore a no-rate policy might actually go through. He also stressed legal advice that the chair of the GLC, Illtyd Harrington, could not take a no-rate resolution, because to do so would make Harrington personally liable for an illegal act.

Despite all this, said Livingstone, he would still be supporting 'no rate' . John Carr and Valerie Wise made similar speeches.

This method of operation has already been described by John Carvel in his book about Livingstone, 'Citizen Ken' Livingstone would put forward an 'outrageous' position, angling so that it would not get votes, and then turn to the gallery and play the hero by voting for it himself. "Sometimes", writes Carvel, •he did it so blatantly that in speaking to a motion he would say: 1 fully appreciate that there may well be members here who cannot support the motion' ... He was more or less saying, for heaven's sake don't vote for this"

The speech had the desired effect. Mike Ward moved an amendment deleting the 'no-rate' option. This was carried by 24 votes to 18, with Livingstone voting against.

So even before it got to the council, the Labour group policy was one of capitulation. The argument over who told whom what about which budget when cannot obscure the fact that this decision was taken for one reason, and one reason only - that there was a slim, but real, chance of an actually going through the Meanwhile, a meeting of the Association of London Authorities (i.e. Labour borough councils) supported McDonnell. It sent a letter, written by Islington chief whip Alan Clinton, to the GLC Labour group: "If Ken Livingstone, or anyone else, claims to have been unaware of what the lower-tier authorities planned for 7 March or of the different position of those in the upper tier, then they are deluding themselves or others. Furthermore, they are causing unnecessary division at a time when we are launching a new vital stage in defence of local services and all the achievements of our movement' The GLC met on Friday 8th. The day before, March 7, the boroughs had had mass demonstrations in defence of jobs and services - but the - Transport unions agree to boycott not press were able to ignore this, only coal but also oil movements to carrying instead stories of power stations. how the GLC Labour group was about to fall apart, based Notts, agrees to follow this policy, after on attacks by Livingstone on they are addressed by union leaders Ray John McDonnell. Buckton and Jimmy Knapp. There was an immediate anti-climax at the GLC. The - Third NUM-NCB talks. meeting could if necessary go Tuesday June 12: Day of action in Wales. on over the weekend - the - South Wales NUM announces that it legal deadline for fixing a will continue to allow full coke supplies to rate being 8pm Sunday. Llanwern.

NCB talks break down. Scargill sets out McDonnell moved the expanded demands for the strike, includ. budget, attacking Livingstone on the grounds that he was ing a four day week. MacGregor threatTens a ballot over the heads of the NUM. going to sell out. Livingstone then attacked McDonnell.

This set the scene for the rest picket line at Ferrybridge, Yorkshire. of the weekend. Anger mounted among those in the suspended (but, as it turns out, only temporarily). Arthur Scargill injured on gallery.

By lam Saturday morning the picket line. ISTC having refused to the meeting had fought itself make any compromise agreement with to a standstill. The Tories had the miners, NUM plans a blockade of all proposed their budget, which coal and iron ore to steelworks. South was voted down. The Labour Wales NUM supports this blockade. budget, with rate-fixing, was voted down by a combination JUNE-JULY: THE TORIES of the Tories and the Labour COUNTER-OFFENSIVE FAILS Left. The 10 Left councillors were voting against everything in an attempt to carry the 'no-rate' programme. all miners urging a return to work.

On Saturday Greenwich Constituency Labour Party's deliveries to Llanwern steelworks. AGM passed a resolution, with only one abstention, strike immediately alongside the miners. supporting McDonnell. - NCB claims 829 returns to work.

nery says that an 'inexorable march toWhen the council reconvened on Sunday, the Labour wards a general strike is now under group was plainly split into way" three sections. Livingstone Wednesday June 27: South East region asked the McDonnell group, TUC day of action - railworkers and and a right-wing group led others strike, 50,000 demonstrate. in different rooms, and Liv- deliveries to Ravenscraig - but steelingstone supporters then works convenor Tommy Brennan says he started running errands will work with scab deliveries by road. between the two groups. The national Labour Party mach- huge convoys of scab trucks with iron ore ine also intervened. from Port Talbot to Llanwern. In July By the end of the afternoon TGWU expels 14 drivers for taking part in the Labour right wing, wary this. South Wales NUM mounts pickets, of the 8pm deadline, said but not comparable to Orgreave. Trucks that if there was no solution keep Scunthorpe, Ravenscraig, and Llanthey would vote with the Tories to get a legal budget. wern supplied, through usually small In the end Barry Stead, a picket lines.

Labour right-winger, proposto cooperate with NUM. Walker and ed a budget slightly below the Brittan make speeches denouncing Scarmain Labour budget (but still, it was said, with no cuts) and gill and NUM. the Tories backed it. 15 of the 18 right-wing Labour NCB talks begins. councillors voted for this budget, while the - 10 left- ers march in Birmingham. wingers were joined by the 20 other members of the Labour loading of iron ore for BSC Scunthorpe group in voting against. at Immingham. Tories talk of using

Scan page 6

Wednesday-Thursday July 11-12: Highly mine troops.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 221

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →