Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Coriolanus and class war

Socialist Organiser no. 221, 28 March 1985 · scan p. 8 · about 1,178 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

Shakespeare's 'Coriolanus' is usually portrayed as a haughty hero, contemptous of the masses but brave. Paula Watson reviews a different interpretation at the BERTOLD BRECHT was a critical Stalinist, much of whose work was meant as propaganda for socialism. Thi extract from 'St Joan of the Stockyards', a play set in the Chicago slaughterhouses, is not too far from being a description of what has happened to the jailed and sackSecond Man: The unjust man may cross the street in Second Man: Although they work for low wages and Struck down and trampled on and heaped with First Man: Why don't we ever hear about them?

Second Man: If you read in the papers that certai Shot or thrown into prison, they are the ones.

National Theatre. PROBABLY the most revolutionary play now running in London is the National Theatre's production of Coriolanus. It is certainly the one containing the starkest truths and most relevant lessons for all who like to think of themselves as Socialists.

Why? Coriolanus has always been an interesting play for the politically committed since it deals with class war in a hierarchical society. But usually the issues are presented in a "balanced' way.

The hero's vitriolic class hatred of the proletariat is offset by the unscrupulous manoeuvring of the two tribunes, who manipulate, for their own ends, the people they are supposed to be representing. Coriolanus is represented as the 'right' and the tribunes as the 'left' and both are rejected in favour of the middle way of consensus.

Revolutionary

The current production presents a different and far more revolutionary interpretation. I do not think the director, Peter Hall, intended the play to come out this way, but he has used three ingredients which, possibly without his realising it, have produced something quite different from the usual plea for balance and moderation.

The first of these is the brilliantly subversive playing of the title role by lan McKellan. Coriolanus is usually presented as a brilliant war leader, whose arrogance and contempt for all outside his own class is redeemed by courage and honesty.

In a recent notable interpretation of the role by Alan Howard for the Royal Shakespeare Company, he showed a man who, for all his shortcomings, was yet true to his own code, unattractive as that code might be, and to his own concept of honour, refusing to compromise even to save his life.

McKellan will have this. His Coriolanus is a posturing fake, a man in love with his own image of himself. His first appearance wearing a dazzling white suit, with a sword slung arrogantly over his shoulder sets the tone for the whole performance. Even his much-vaunted courage is shown as the gratuitous heroics of an essentially immature man.

His inability to flatter the people when soliciting their votes arises not from revulsion against hypocrisy but from an invincible sense of his own superiority and that of the class he represents. For him the need to submit to any form of democratic election is in itself degrading. The ruling class should rule.

Symptom

Such a conviction of inherent superiority is seen as the symptom of an immaturity which is itself the product of the philosophy of militarism inculcated into him by his mother, Volumnia. Irene Worth conveys both the obscene absurdity of Volumnia's sentiments, together with her belief in their rightness.

Even Coriolanus's final choice of death before dishonour is treated in McKellan's performance as just another gesture by a posturing adolescent. Hence his insane rage in Aulius. He can had from Aufidius. He can face death, but not the truth.

The second element making up this interesting reading of the play is the treatment of the crowd. The people of Rome have an important part to play and are usually seen as cowardly, inconsistent and easily manipulated. This works all right when the crowd is played by actors, and the audience, sitting safely in their seats, can feel complacently smug and superior. At other performances I have even heard delighted laughter at the confusion and distress caused by the news of Coriolanus's return at the head of the Volscian army.

But this time the crowd played by a part of the audience, those members of the public who bought the seats actually on the stage. This alters our Suddenly these confused, often frightened people are no longer a foolish Roman mob, they are people just like us -they are us.

They are confused because they have been reared on a diet of lies. The aristocratic ruling class consistently deceives them, hiding their contempt behind smooth old world courtesy. The only difference between Coriolanus and the rest of his class is that he cannot hide his hatred; the others both can and do.

Their objections to his viol ent outbursts are not to his sentiments, which they share, but to the inexpediency of letting those sentiments be known. But at the Olivier their contempt, and Coriolanus's denunciations, are falling not on a bunch of actors, but on us, the audience.

And as we watch these people milling awkwardly about on the unfamiliar stage, we understand the panic at the approach of their old enemy at the head of the Volscian army. They should have been armed and trained to defend themselves. The tribunes failed to do this.

The treatment of these two characters makes up the third element socialising the play. If Hall had wanted to attack the left, he should have presented them as Lenin and Trotsky, or Scargill and Benn. Instead they are presented as a couple of scheming, social-democratic careerists. One is a pipesmoking Harold Wilson figure, the other a compromising Clive Jenkins.

Hate They hate Coriolanus, not because he is an embryonic fascist, but because he represents a threat to their own position. They do not wish to overthrow the existing order, simply to secure their own comfortable place within it.

Having persuaded the people to call for Coriolanus's death, they back down at the crucial moment and acquiesce in his banishment. Rid of Coriolanus they do mething 'o persuade the people of the need to overthrow the existing order. They reach an accommodation with the patricians, leaving the status quo unchanged.

Their failure is the failure of social democracy, not of revolued miners in the British coalfield today First Man: Who are those people? Second Man: Not one of them Cared only for himself They ran without rest To get bread for strangers.

First Man: Why without bread?

But the just man hides.

First Man: What's being done to them?

to - many Not one of them lives the years of his life Eats his bread, dies contented And is honourably buried, but They end before their time have been First Man: Will it always be like that? Second Man: No.

St Joan of the tionary socialism.

For Socialists the message is clear - destroy our enemies before they destroy us.

• Coriolanus will be performed at 7.15pm on March 29 and 30.

----- pull-quotes -----

Songs of liberty rebelli‹

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 221

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →