Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Israel's bitter

Socialist Organiser no. 221, 28 March 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 1,610 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

I believe in the state of Israel because of what happened to World War. All of us who were young people in the days of Hitlerism saw what happened to the Jews in Europe, and so at various countries wouldn't take the Jewish refugees in, and should have a state of their own was accepted.

I still, believe that, because I am not against Israel as such, but what the Israeli government have been doing. I'm against the expansion, their attitude to the Palestinians. 1 am The Jewish people in Israel, more than anybody else, should understand, conclusively, the position of people without their own state who have been forced into a diaspora Top. Eric Heffer. Ahove: Lebanese victim of Israeli shelling your attitude to the state of Israel? for a Palestinian state.

all over the world.

But unfortunately, having got a state of their own, it can be turned into a very clearly Jewish state, rather than a state of Israel which could have had as equal citizens the Arab and Palestinian people, as certain people, like Buber, wanted. Over the years the position in Israel has grown from bad to worse.

• Would you support the establishment of a democratic, secular state in Palestine?

I don't think it's on at the moment. What is realistic is that the people who are Palestinians have a right to their state.

Israel has been an expansionist state under the previous government, and if the Labour Party in Israel doesn't fundamentally change their position, there isn't very much difference between them and previous governments. • You say it's not realistic to talk of a democratic, secular state, but many people will say that, like South Africa, it's not possible to solve a problem of apartheid by creating a bantustan.

It's quite different. The overwhelming majority of people in South Africa are Black, but in the old Israeli borders the overwhelming majority are Jewish.

The important thing is to say the Palestinians must have a right to organise a state of their own based on the West Bank, and the Israelis have to withdraw their forces from all those areas, settlements and so on.

If you can get that, you have two states existing side by side, then you have the basis for some sort of federated position in the Middle East.

But at the moment I don't think that is on. Of course you're going to have inside Israel all the reactionary forces who are never going to agree to an integrated state.

• Many would agree that the West Bank and Gaza have been annexed already de facto - if not legally, in order to exclude Palestinians there from the right to vote, etc. If the inte gration of the West Bank and Gaza continues into the Israeli economy, we have to demand civil and political rights for the Palestinians who live there now.

I went to Israel immediately after the Six Day War, and they then said that they were going to use the occupation of the West Bank as a bargaining point. I said then, only six days after the war, that the longer you occupy, voices will develop increasingly in your country which will say: Why should we give it up? Why don't we move the Palestinians out? It's logical.

i think there were people in Israel who genutnely believed it could be used as a bargaining Eric Heffer MP used Now he does not. He this interview. position, and they became an increasing minority. The reactionary forces in Israel have increased over the years, racism increased...

• Do you think that it was an advance that the Labour Party adopted the solution of a secular, democratic state as a longterm solution?

I would hope in the end that one would get that.

But the Labour Party could never, until the last few years, accept even the idea of a Palestinian state, or talk about the right to self-determination. We've moved tremendously because of the Middle East Committee I chaired.

Incidentally, it doesn't exist now. With the new set-up last year all these committees were abandoned. I don't know whether you think that it is significant, but I do.

It means that instead of getting people who really understand these matters at these committees, it's now going to be half from the NEC and half from the Shadow Cabinet and then they will call in experts from time to time. That depends who the experts are... The old committee... had one or two Zionists on it, it was made up of people from all different walks of life - real experts who came together to discuss every conceivable angle of the Middle East, and then you got out of that a very serious policy. You're not going to get that now.

I've been arguing in the Party and NEC that these comthe Jews in the Second the rise of fascism and the end of the war the the idea that the Jews mittees in the international sphere should be resuscitated, so if we wanted to bring your organisation onto the committee, then you'd be brought on. • In 1982 Conference passed policy on the Middle East, a reversal of sixty years' support for Zionism, including support for the PLO. This, however, is something the NEC refuses to acknowledge. It has not even allowed the PLO observer status at Party Conference. Do you agree with the NEC?

Diluted No I don't. I was chair of the Middle East Committee, and the NEC document was based upon the report that came from them. Now the secretary of the committee was Liz Nash, and Liz and I drafted the document which was put to the committee, and it was carried and presented to the NEC. At the NEC it was diluted, changed by Gwynneth Dunwoody and others carrying a majority against us. So we had that carried by Conference.

What those people who say you shouldn't recognise the PLO are doing, is basing their attitude on that.

But equally there were also two resolutions carried which said the opposite, but as you are aware, certain people on the NEC, up till now a majority, base their position on the document rather than on the resolutions carried.

As far as I'm concerned, while I wouldn't go all the way with the resolution on one or two points, my sympathy is 99.9% with them, as against the others.

I think it was wrong that the PLO were not invited, but unfortunately it slipped through the International Committee and it was too late. That was very wrong.

• You left the Labour Friends of Israel two years ago.

-There was a time when the left in the Party was more supportive of Israel than the right. That has probably changed now, with the Frank Chapples and Michael Cocks being the supporters [of Israel], and the Left moving to support the PLO and Palestinian state.

What were the factors involved behind this decision to leave? The government of Israel was pursuing policies of extending the various settlements on the West Bank. There began a movement towards the occupation of the Lebanon and expansionist policy, the fact that inside Israel there is increasing intolerance. Listening to speeches being made by some of the Israeli leaders, who were extremely belligerent, fascist in attitude, I wasn't prepared to give any support whatsoever to that sort of policy.

As long as I remained active in the Labour Friends of Israel, in effect, I was helping to screen what the reality was, and I wasn't prepared to do that.

• Do you see the Labour Friends of Israel as an apologist what Begin doing?

Oh always. There were some Jaguar workers strike over pay. Friday November 2: NCB offers bribe to miners who return to work. Monday November 5: Fourth NUM rec conference. Decides to organise fi strikers' rallies, round the country. I Kinnock is invited, but refuses to speak these rallies.

NOVEMBER-JANUARY: THE LEGAL ASSAULT ON THE UNIONS WIDENS Tuesday November 6: High Court wr against car unions for supporting Aus Rover strike without a ballot. All exa the TGWU will make their peace with 1 court.

arly November: NCB claims a bre through with scabbing in North Der shire. Scab-herding offensive reaches new pitch.

During November also, sequestrat write to unions telling them that mor to miners may be unlawful. Most unic stop the money.

But the pound starts falling shar against the dollar agi Tuesday November 13: At NUM rally Aberafan, a symbolic noose is lower in front of TUC general secretary Norm Willis.

Monday November 19: NCB claims 22 miners returning to work.

Two pits which come under the Yo shire NUM but are geographically Notts - Manton and Shireoaks - ha suffered major back-to-work moves. Tuesday November 20: Austin Rover Co ley plants, abandoned by their un leaders, vote to return to work.

Austin Rover strike collapses. — North Wales area NUM leadership wi draws from the strike.

Monday November 26: High Court fir TGWU €200,000, to be paid by Dece ber 10. Back-to-work drive slows do drastically.

Wednesday November 28: Six accounta publish report criticising NCB's arg ment for pit closures.

Friday November 30: Kinnock speaks support of miners at Stoke-on-Trent. — Taxi driver David Wilkie is killed wh concrete blocks are thrown at his taxi he drives one pit's single scab miner work, escorted by two police cars and motorcycle. - Tory lawyer Herbert Brewer is appoir ed 'receiver' of the NUM's funds. I declares, "I am the NUM"

Sunday December 2: 1500 delegates Mineworkers' Defence Committee ar ference in London.

HUn

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 221

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →