Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Has Socialism a Future? Socialism a Future

Socialist Organiser no. 221, 28 March 1985 · scan pp. 10–11 · about 941 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

GLASGOW UNIVERSITY: ADAM SMITH BUILDING Conference Theme: European Social Democratic attempts to regulate market economy within the world division of labour to the advantage of the working-class seem to have exhausted their promise and potential. Do the 1983 election results of Britain and Germany represent popular recognition of this? The USSR is widely regarded, domestically and abroad, as representing no 'model' of socialism. Third World countries calling themselves 'socialist' can arguably be said to represent merely efforts by national elites to secure a more favourable bargaining position for their countries within the world division of labour. If this is all true does it vindicate the Mises-Hayek thesis that socialism is impossible? Or on the other hand, does it vindicate the thesis of Marx that between the market and the society of freely There will be 10 panels including the following:

For further details and registration form please write to: Conference Organiser, Centre for Sor Theory & Movements, c/o Philosophy Dept., Glasgow University, Glasgow G12 8QQ, UK. ment, demanding a debate on the miners strike. Neil Kinnock condemns them.

move at Kiveton Park, South Yorkshire.

NCB claims 1847 returns to work nationally.

charges begin to come up for trial.

and Smith (NCB) apparently lays basis for new talks.

associated producers there is no third way? talks unless NUM first agrees to economic pit closures. NACODS starts talking about possible industrial action to safeguard its deal. Socialist Political Strategy LEO PANITCH attempt by NUM to get talks, NCB re- IMMANUAL WALLERSTEIN peats the message — no talks unless the BERTELL OLLMAN NUM first surrenders. NIGEL HARRIS Transition from Market NUM delegate conference demands to Socialist Society recall TUC congress. ISTVAN MESZAROS ERNEST MANDEL returns to work. HILLEL TICKTIN MILTON FISK industrial relations, publicly attacks NCE intransigence.

South Wales area NUM research officer 8 - 12 APRIL 1985 Nature of Socialist Society MICHAEL BARRATT BROWN MICHAEL LÖWY G.A.E. SMITH Socialist Society the Market RICHARD B. DAY ALEX CALLINICOS SIMON MOHUN DIANE ELSON Philosophy of Socialism CHRIS ARTHUR ANDREW GAMBLE TED NINNIS SCOTT MEIKLE risis of Social Democ SIMON CLARKE A. GUNDER FRANK GEOFF PILLING JAMES PETRAS

Scan page 11

zionists Thursday February 7: NUM and NACODS semitic Saturday February 9: Second Mineworkers' The ban on the Jewish student society at land Polytechnic, which has now become major issue within the National Union of ents (see report page 3), has implications beyond student politics. John O'Mahony unravels the issues.

ist Jews as if they were racists is both unjust and itself ineviSunde Studway - for tactical or better reasons - ban Jewish student societies, share the of Christian society for two millennia has been saturated with the Bible's myth about who killed Christ.

If hypocrisy is a tribute paid by vice to virtue, mental dishonesty here is a device to keep the left from facing up to the implications of its attitudes. But the implications are there, under the surface. And sometimes they show through - as in the ravings of Newsline about the *Zionist world conspiracy or the crude drawings of Zionists' in the style of traditional anti-semitic caricatures of Jews published in the early Labour Herald. That these people are tolerated on the Left as part of the anti-Zionist common front tells its own story.

We should try to be logical - because that is the only way to be honest.

Abhorrent

In face of the crimes of the Israeli state, perhaps we should say that the old antithe Left naturally find it unpalatable — is that antisemitism of various sorts has more than once found a home in the organisations of the working class and of the Left.

In the late 19th century many anti-semites identified Jews with money-grubbing capitalism, though most Jews were terribly poor. Areas of the labour movement became tainted with the sort of 'well-intentioned' anti-semitism which Marxists denounced as 'the socialism of idiots'. Even the Austrian Marxists, faced with a powerful Catholic anti-semitism ostentatiously declared themselves 'neither anti-semitic nor philo-semitic.

For many decades - and still to this day - anti-semitism has been rampant in the USSR and in most of the East European Stalinist states. For example, in 1968-9 there was a thoroughgoing antisemitic purge in Poland.

In the later '40s and early '50s, a virulent anti-semitism, in terms of national conflicts, national confrontations, national causes and national -not class - solutions. They see progressive and reactionary peoples, 'good' and "bad' nations. It is a small step from all this to the idea of good and bad peoples.

Memories of fascist antisemitism stop such ideas from developing clearly, so the logic of such "Third-Worldism' remains just under the surface.

Another root of 'left-wing" anti-semitism is the fact that many of the vociferous antiZionists' do not accept that the Palestinian Jews have any rights in Palestine. To put it at its weakest, it is usually not at all clear what positive alternative much of the Left is advocating when it denounces Israel and the crimes of its governments. All too often the implication → certainly the logical and emotional implication - is "Zionists out of the Middle East' (with the escape clause that this is nothing against Jews, because anti-Zionist Jews can work without an agreement. — Military police and 1500 Royal eers evict Molesworth peace camp.

make joint appeal for new negotiations.

NCB insists again — no talks unless NUM first accepts 'economic' pit closures.

Defence Committee conference. Calls for recall TUC congress and general strike, but a poor attendances Monday February 11: Day shire/Humberside and regional TUCs have mobilise. of action in YorkLondon. Patchy:

done little to

----- pull-quotes -----

ocialis Organiser Wits crawis tol Thatcher

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 221

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →