Why banning zionists is anti-semitic
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-03-28Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): transcribed from the scan; the machine reading had run in other pieces on the page; the article runs across pp. 10-11, and its p. 11 half had been filed as a separate item. The bold standfirst, printed on p. 11, is given first. Photograph captioned "Cable Street 1936. Jewish community and labour movement fought the fascists". "Beirut" (for Bierut) as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 10
The ban on the Jewish student society at Sunderland Polytechnic, which has now become a major issue within the National Union of Students (see report page 3), has implications way beyond student politics. John O'Mahony unravels the issues.
ISRAEL IS a racist state, and Israeli atrocities such as its savage reprisals against Arab men, women and children in Lebanon are crimes against humanity.
Should anti-racists therefore treat Zionists — or all those who support the right of the Israeli state to exist — as racists? Sunderland Polytechnic's ban on the Union of Jewish Students has placed this issue at the centre of student politics. The issue goes way beyond student politics.
For almost all Jews — apart from revolutionary socialists and some religious zealots — are Zionists (at least in a broad sense), and therefore what is at issue here is whether or not socialists, and anti-racists, should politically persecute Jews.
The Sunderland student union ban was not the work of an unrepresentative minority. Over 1000 students attended its General Meeting last month which endorsed the ban on the Union of Jewish Students on the grounds that the UJS is racist because it is avowedly Zionist.
Nor is the majority attitude at Sunderland untypical of the Left.
Lenin and Trotsky never dreamed of 'banning Zionists' — though such a ban would have been a much less drastic matter in their day, when only an ideological minority of Jews were Zionists. They opposed Zionism politically; but, for example, the Poale Zion (Workers of Zion) movement continued to publish its paper in the USSR until 1927, the year the Left Opposition was outlawed.
Yet many today who consider themselves Leninists or Trotskyists support a ban on Zionists.
The intention of the Sunderland Poly students is to show the sharpest possible intolerance and hostility towards what they consider to be racism — and that is good.
What they have done, however, looks more like racism than the anti-racism they intend. They have targeted a community which for something like 1500 years has been the victim of Europe's ingrained, traditional Christian anti-Jewish racism. The greatest racist crime in recorded history was done not by Jews but against Jews.
Israel exploits that fact, and uses the Nazi holocaust of six million Jews for self-justification and moral blackmail. But the holocaust does not thereby become something we can forget about or regard as an event of ancient history.
One of the tragedies of Israel, conceived as a refuge against anti-semitism, is that its activities now combine with the effect in the West of the increased power and wealth of the Arab states to generate anti-semitism dressed up in the garb of anti-Zionism.
Today the rump National Front has turned 'left' and denounces 'finance capitalism', which it says is 'Jewish capitalism'. They are poking around in the old vomit of the Nazis, who tried to appeal to workers by scapegoating the Jews for the crimes of capitalism. The new NF even denounces Israel and Zionism for their ill-treatment of the Palestinians.
Intentions
The drive, motives and intentions of even the most confused left-wing anti-Zionist are of course radically different. Yet today justified hostility to Israel has pushed much of the revolutionary left to the edge of a new anti-semitism, and some so-called leftists ('Newsline') over the edge.
It is not that they are supporters of Hitlerite racial mumbo-jumbo, or anything like that. But whatever the good intentions, there is no way that a ban like that at Sunderland Poly can avoid being anti-semitic.
Zionism is part of the identity that modern history — centrally, Hitler's massacres, and the callous attitude of the big powers to those massacres and their survivors — has stamped on Jews. To differentiate between banning Zionists and banning Jews is no more than a thin fiction when the vast majority of Jews today identify with Israel and are supporters — active or passive, callous or guilty, blinkered and happy or deeply troubled supporters — of the existing Jewish state. This is part of their identity as Jews, not easily detachable. The ban on Zionists is akin to the old proselytising Christian anti-semitism which wanted to convert the Jews, rather than, like Hitler and the racists, to kill them, but was bitterly hostile to those who refused to change and be converted.
Jewish identification with Israel has its roots and motives not in anti-Arab racism, nor even in a thought-out commitment to displace the Palestinian Arabs, but in the Jews' experience of racist persecution, culminating in the Nazi slaughter.
It was only during and after the Third Reich's 'Final Solution', the terrible paroxysm of anti-semitism that slaughtered six million Jews, that Zionism gained general acceptance in the European and US Jewish communities. Before then the Zionist project to colonise Palestine had been a minority creed among Jews.
The identification with the Zionist colony, and later with the Israeli state, was identification with a Jewish state that seemed to offer a guarantee that the age-old persecution of the Jews would now cease.
Far from being conscious racists, most Jewish Zionists in Britain are not even conscious of the racist basis of the state of Israel.
They are not motivated by race-hatred, but by a wrong and misguided response to anti-Jewish racism.
Of course Zionist Jews are responsible for themselves. Those who support the state of Israel are supporters of a racist state even if they refuse to acknowledge the less acceptable facts about Israel's origins and its mode of operation over the past 40 years.
As Zionists they are our political and ideological opponents.
That is quite a long way, however, from being the same as the National Front or other groups formed around fascist programmes and fuelled by race hatred.
The attempt to treat Zionists as if they were racists is both unjust and itself inevitably productive of racist attitudes, albeit wrapped up in good intentions.
Scan page 11
Listen to the usefully crass 'Newsline' editorialising in support of the Sunderland decision. Benevolently they conclude:
"We reject the spurious premise that all Jews are and must be Zionists, or that anti-Zionism is anti-semitism. Sunderland Poly students are right to take a stand. We would support the formation of a Jewish Society which anti-Zionist Jews would be eligible to join. But a Zionist society is not acceptable."
Repeat: "We would support the formation of a Jewish Society which anti-Zionist Jews would be eligible to join". 'Newsline' of course goes in for childish pretences and denies that most Jews are Zionists. But its 'benevolence' shows how closely the attitudes of sections of the Left now parallel traditional anti-semitism — in this case, the Christian anti-semitism that wanted to convert the Jews.
One of the blocks to rational discussion of this question on the Left today is that things are rarely spelled out. Even many who would not — for tactical or better reasons — ban Jewish student societies, share the notion that Zionists should — more or less — be treated as racists. Translated, that means that most Jews — those who cannot be persuaded to stop believing that Israel, or some version of Israel, has a right to exist — should be persecuted.
Some people define away the problem by pretending that anti-semitism must be defined as Hitlerism or bigoted Christianity (and therefore cannot include them).
As if there haven't been many anti-semitisms in history! Hitler's anti-semitism was very different from the Catholic anti-semitism to be found in old Austro-Hungary or Poland; different again was the anti-semitism in Poland in the '50s and '60s in which hatred of a Jewish Stalinist terrorist like party boss Beirut blended with the older Catholic strain. It was a section of a Stalinist bureaucracy, not an old ruling class, which offered its Jewish Beiruts (like Rothschilds in pre-war Europe) as scapegoats to deflect popular hatred.
Jews — rich and poor alike — have been the universal scapegoat. The basic culture of Christian society for two millennia has been saturated with the Bible's myth about who killed Christ.
If hypocrisy is a tribute paid by vice to virtue, mental dishonesty here is a device to keep the left from facing up to the implications of its attitudes. But the implications are there, under the surface. And sometimes they show through — as in the ravings of Newsline about the 'Zionist world conspiracy' or the crude drawings of 'Zionists' in the style of traditional anti-semitic caricatures of Jews published in the early Labour Herald. That these people are tolerated on the Left as part of the anti-Zionist common front tells its own story.
We should try to be logical — because that is the only way to be honest.
Abhorrent
In face of the crimes of the Israeli state, perhaps we should say that the old anti-semites had something after all? That is an abhorrent idea for almost everybody on the Left. Yet it is the right way to pose the question, because it honestly sums up what is implicit in the attitude that 'all Zionists are racists'.
After all, if the ban on the Jewish student society at Sunderland Poly is right, then we should not stop there. Other Jewish societies should be banned. Jewish community organisations like the Board of Deputies should be outlawed. Mainstream Jewish newspapers should be proscribed. And then what about the synagogues? Centres in each area of organised Zionist support for Israel? Why should they be allowed freely to meet like that?
If it is right to ban a Jewish student society, then it makes no sense to tolerate synagogues (unless they adhere to those small Jewish religious sects who reject the state of Israel).
It is, of course, this horrible logic that keeps sections of the Left from recognising the implications of their position. They also do not recognise the antecedents.
The truth — and many on the Left naturally find it unpalatable — is that anti-semitism of various sorts has more than once found a home in the organisations of the working class and of the Left.
In the late 19th century many anti-semites identified Jews with money-grubbing capitalism, though most Jews were terribly poor. Areas of the labour movement became tainted with the sort of 'well-intentioned' anti-semitism which Marxists denounced as 'the socialism of idiots'. Even the Austrian Marxists, faced with a powerful Catholic anti-semitism ostentatiously declared themselves 'neither anti-semitic nor philo-semitic'.
For many decades — and still to this day — anti-semitism has been rampant in the USSR and in most of the East European Stalinist states. For example, in 1968-9 there was a thoroughgoing anti-semitic purge in Poland.
In the later '40s and early '50s, a virulent anti-semitism, thinly disguised as anti-Zionism, was poured out by the propaganda machine of the Stalinist governments and by the western CPs.
On the eve of his death in 1953, Stalin was about to stage an anti-semitic show trial (of the 'Jewish doctors in the Kremlin'). Most likely this would have been the start of Stalin's version of Hitler's 'final solution' — mass deportation and slaughter for the surviving Jews of the USSR and Eastern Europe.
Today, overwhelming revulsion at the crimes of the Israeli state and sympathy with the Palestinian Arabs provide the emotional drive for the sort of 'anti-Zionism' which has anti-semitic implications.
Some of the most fervent and confused left-wing 'anti-Zionists' are 'Third Worldists' or 'socialist bloc'-ists, seeing the world not in terms of class struggle but of 'progressive' and reactionary national blocs, and of a division of the world into 'imperialism' and 'anti-imperialism'. In one way or another, they think in terms of national conflicts, national confrontations, national causes and national — not class — solutions. They see progressive and reactionary peoples, 'good' and 'bad' nations. It is a small step from all this to the idea of good and bad peoples.
Memories of fascist anti-semitism stop such ideas from developing clearly, so the logic of such 'Third-Worldism' remains just under the surface.
Another root of 'left-wing' anti-semitism is the fact that many of the vociferous 'anti-Zionists' do not accept that the Palestinian Jews have any rights in Palestine. To put it at its weakest, it is usually not at all clear what positive alternative much of the Left is advocating when it denounces Israel and the crimes of its governments. All too often the implication — certainly the logical and emotional implication — is 'Zionists out of the Middle East' (with the escape clause that this is nothing against Jews, because anti-Zionist Jews can remain). Many left-wing anti-Zionists operate not on class politics but on Palestinian or pan-Arab nationalism.
SO believes that the solution to the Jewish-Arab conflict is the creation of a secular democratic state for Palestinian Jews and Arabs, with guaranteed rights for the Jewish nation in Palestine. (A small minority of SO supporters think that the only practicable solution is some rearrangement in two states, Jewish and Arab). The idea of the democratic secular state is widely accepted. But that part of it which says that the Jewish nation, too, has rights, is often downplayed. SO accepts it and means it.
We should denounce the crimes of the Israeli state. We should defend the Palestinian victims of that state and champion their rights. But we must do so as working class socialists, not as Third Worldists or vicarious Arab chauvinists. We must not, mumbling about our fine anti-racist intentions, fall ourselves into a variant of the oldest racism in history.