Non-zionist jews
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Reader request 5 Nov 2026 (the Sunderland Poly and UJS articles): a letter, signed Robert Rosenthal, University of London Institute of Education Union; transcribed from the scan for its paragraphs and italics. "paramount important" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
THE NATIONAL Union of Students conference decision to suspend Sunderland Polytechnic Students Union marks a set-back for Middle East peace and reconciliation; for this NUS leadership are responsible.
At the centre of the issue is the failure to distinguish Judaism — a religious, cultural and ethnic identity — from Zionism — the political philosophy and practice of Israeli nationalism.
Zionism emerged in the 1880s as one response to persecution. But Jewish people were divided between Zionists and others who argued the need to fight for their legitimate equal rights in the land of their birth. Jews are still divided. The Union of Jewish Students (UJS) represent the pro-Zionist view.
The UJS have made much of claiming their right to define their Jewish identity; yet by integrating Zionism and Judaism in the name of Jewishness, they have effectively defined for all Jews that to be Jewish one must be a Zionist, and if a Jew is an anti-Zionist s/he is not a 'real Jew'.
More dangerously, the UJS thereby define to the non-Jewish world that all Jews comply with policies of Zionism, to oppose Zionism is anti-semitic, and that to be a real anti-racist one must support their right to promote Zionism.
Because Zionists hold Zionism to be integral to Judaism, they feel threatened by anti-Zionism. Any attack on Zionism is an attack on them as Jews. This bonding of the issues has always served as an ideological justification for the Israeli state, and as a means of ensuring support from the Jewish people.
But for Jews who disagree with Zionism it is of paramount important to distinguish the two, for the bonding implicitly encourages anti-semitism: if Jews fail to draw the clear distinction, how do they expect non Jews to do so? As public opinion reacts to the ongoing atrocities of the Israeli state, Jews become the obvious targets of blame.
Sunderland Poly Students Union did not deny the UJS the 'right to define their identity', it simply recognised and enforced the distinction between Judaism and Zionism. While refusing to ratify a pro-Zionist society, it did ratify another non-Zionist Jewish society. They did not act anti-semitically. They upheld the rights of non-Zionist Jews to define themselves free of the taint of Zionism.
The tragedy of this debate is that it will generate anti-semitism, particularly with the suspension of Sunderland Poly Students Union, because the Conference and National Executive have repeated the failure to distinguish the two.
By so doing they have endorsed the Zionist position and given implicit support to UJS.
Palestinian aspirations and Zionism are totally irreconcilable since each depends on the negation of the other. Zionism is the cause of the Palestinian diaspora which NUS purports to condemn.
A fierce debate is raging amongst Jews about Zionism. It must continue.
However the NUS Executive and conference, far from defending the right to that debate through suspension of Sunderland Poly Students Union, have actually taken sides in it in support of Zionist Judaism, and in betrayal of the hopes of Palestinians and anti-Zionist Jews struggling for reconciliation. NUS has made that struggle even harder.