After troops out, then what?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
50p. Number 2 March/April ORGANISED! FOR MANY years now — since about 1972 - there has been a solid majority in opinion polls for British withdrawal from Ireland.
Some ruling-class opinion favours withdrawal. Despite all the efforts by successive governments to doctor the media, enough evidence about the day-to-day repression of Catholics by British troops in Ireland has come out to make sure that a majority of constituency delegates at each Labour Party conference are willing to vote for Labour- is officially committed to a united Ireland.
Yet despite all this we seem caught in a stalemate. Campaigning on Ireland in the British labour movement is not at a high level. Labour 1s not committed to 'troops out' until a majority of Northern Ireland's population want a united Ireland, and recently Neil Kinnock Published by Socialist Orgeniser Ireland 50p plus postage from SO 14 Sickert Court,
Gerry Bates reviews
"Socialist Forum' no.2, just published by Socialist Organiser has been showing signs of wantto retreat even from Labour's very limited commitment. A Kinnock Labour government would do nothing much different from the Wilson/ Callaghan government - or the present Tory government.
One reason for this, of course, is that the Labour leadership are protected from constituency opinion by the trade union block votes, tied to the status quo by their Protestant memberships in Northern Ireland. Another, surely, is that the Left has not been able to propose a convincing comprehensive alternative to the status quo.
Why Militant and IRSP are twins Editorial: Dialogue yes, ventriloquism no!
Militant's record on Ireland...
..and ours James Connolly For a federal united Ireland!
16 years of conflict Over the 1970s we managed to convince Labour activists - and many other people too that the troops are doing no good in Ireland. But the sticking point still remains for most people that they can see no immediate alternative to the troops but bloody chaos.
It is not, as some over-emotional sectarians allege, because of 'anti-Irish racism' that the labour movement continues to condone a British presence but because of honest concern to avoid bloody civil war.
A parallel problem exists in Ireland. Sinn Fein has moved left: but its whole strategy is based on the Northern Catholic community, with little grip on the Southern working class and no opening at all towards the Protestant majority of the Northern working class.
Side by side with its left turn, in fact, has come an attitude to the Protestant workers that rules out even a remote possibility of them being conciliated. The long-time Sinn Fein/Provisional IRA policy of a federal Ireland has been dropped; and the distinct Protestant Irish community is now defined as a political entity, just a 'pro-imperialist' group. -The IRA is thus locked into a war of attrition. Its strategists reckon that this war of attrition could continue for decades. It is not at all clear how it will bring a united — let alone a socialist — Ireland nearer.
The logical development, if the current Catholic/Protestant conflict were to develop into the next stage of open civil war, would inescapably lead to a very bloody repartition and the end - for decades at least - of any prospect of a united Ireland.
Much of the Irish left are either political satellites of the Provisionals — or blankly hostile to both the Provisionals and the just revolt of the Northern Catholics (Workers' Party, 'Militant').
This pamphlet suggests some ideas to help cut through this double stalemate.
The crucial stumbling-block to all progress in Ireland is the fact that a major section of the working class — the Northern Protestants - have been rallied round a programme of die-hard bigotry.
Many socialists try to evade this obstacle. 'Militant', for example, takes its stand on breadand-butter trade-union unity. From such unity, it claims, socialist politics can be developed, dealing with the national question in passing.
Other groups focus on the national question. Intensified national struggle, in their view, will 'grow over' into socialism - and create working-class unity in passing. This approach is the mirror-image of 'Militant' But a serious socialist policy in Ireland - so this pamphlet argues - must combine a search for working-class unity at whatever level possible with a consistently democratic programme on the national and communal issues.
It calls for a federal united Ireland - for self-determination for the people of Ireland as a whole, but within that for the maximum autonomy for Protestant-majority areas compatible with the rights of the majority.
This suggestion, the pamphlet emphasises, is not a cure-all, or a recommendation to be sent to Thatcher and Fitzgerald to help them at their next meeting. But it might be a basis on which socialists, in Britain and in Ireland. could begin to organise forces capable of cutting through the stalemate.
The pamphlet also includes a concise but vivid account of the last 16 years in Northern Ireland | - "for working-class Marxists", it stresses, "the facts, not fantasies and wishes, are the necessary starting-point" — and a summary of the ideas of the British Isles' greatest Marxist, James Connolly.
Labour Committee on Annual General Meeting Sunday April 14 1985 County Hall, London SE1.
legist. £1.50 (50p unwagec o join or affiliate to the LC write to BM Box 5355, London WC1N 3XX. £5 waged or affiliations, E1 unwaged. Get Name .
Address Send N12 contribution from supporters.
I want to become a Socialist Organiser supporter/1 want mi information.
to: licke
Scan page 11
Industrial news