Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The Left needs class politics

Socialist Organiser no. 223, 10 April 1985 · scan p. 10 · about 1,360 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 10

Tional IRA and its political partner Sinn Fein was one of hostility and blank incomprehension. 'Sectarian murderers' was the common basic comment.

Today everything is changed. Wide layers of the labour movement, and especially the local government Left, say they want a 'dialogue' with Sinn Fein.

So far, so good: but in fact many on the Left are uncritical mouthpieces for the Sinn Fein view on Irish politics, on Irish history, and on possible solutions to the conflict in Northern Ireland. They function as ventriloquist's dummies rather than independent partners in a dialogue.

On balance the whole situa tion is better than the way things were in the '70s, but it is a long way from working-class politics.

There are two reasons for the change. Many of those now prominent in the Labour Left, and especially in the local government Lett, were educated during the '70s in what was then the minority view of Sinn Fein, the IRA, and the war in Ireland. That's the good reason - some knowledge and understanding, together with sympathy for the oppressed Catholics of Northern Ireland and rejection of the lying and self-serving Establishment account of the conflict in Northern Ireland.

The bad reason is that the Irish vote is very important. One person in six in London is said to be Irish. In places like Brent and Islington the Irish vote is massive.

Ethnic politics has given much to the sudden mushrooming of support for Ireland and for 'dialogue with Sinn Fein'. . Many - though not all - of the Labour Left are interested less in a dialogue with Sinn Fein than in profitably picking up and espousing the lowest-commondenominator Irish nationalism of the Irish community in Britain.

Sections of the powerful Labour local government Left of the '80s also mirror the populist, Third-Worldist attitude to Ireland which was the dominant strain on the pro-Irish left in the '70s (and still is today in, for example, Socialist Action).

Most of the Left simply do not have the minimum required for a dialogue with Sinn Fein = or anyone else — on Ireland: a worked-out opinion of their own.

Take as an example the much-publicised speech by Ken Livingstone in which he said that Britain had done the equivalent of Hitler's holocaust against the Jews during the Irish potato famine of the 1840s. Good Irish nationalist headline-grabbing stuff. But it's bad history. More than that, and worse, it is middle-class Catholic-nationalist During the potato famine grain was exported from Ireland that could have kept the people alive. Who exported it? Catholic Irish middlemen!

One of the worst consequences of the famine was the 'clearances' from the land of 'unwanted' surplus tenants. Who cleared them? In many cases it was wealthy Catholics who had bought out the old landlords after the Encumbered Estates Act of 1849.

The best you can say is that if there had been a national Irish legislature in Dublin it would have done better than the 'United Kingdom' administration. Perhaps. The facts of later 19th and of 20th century Irish life don't bear this supposition out. The Irish capitalists bitterly opposed the early welfare state.

Ruling classes, especially weak ruling classes, are not normally more concerned for or necessarily more merciful towards their co-nationals or co-religionists. On the contrary.

The whole notion that the famine was 'English' is Catholic Irish middle-class propaganda. Listen to the sober assessment made by the working-class socialist James Connolly 75 years ago. Having bitterly described how Irish middle-class "revolutionary' leaders like William Smith O'Brien defended the landlords' right to private property in grain though the peasants were starving, Connolly goes on:

"Had Socialist principles been applied to Ireland in those days not one person need have died of hunger, and not one cent of charity need have been subscribed to leave a smirch upon the Irish name. But all except a few men elevated landlord property and capitalist political economy to a fetish to be worshipped, and upon the altar of that fetish Ireland perished.

*At the lowest computation 1,225,000 persons died of absolute hunger; all of these were sacrificed upon the altar of capitalist thought.

"Early in the course of the famine the English Premier, Lord John Russell, declared that nothing must be done to interfere with private enterprise or the regular course of trade, and this was the settled policy of the Government from first to last... In all the Acts establishing relief works, it was stipulated that all the labour must be entirely unproductive, so as not to prevent capitalists making a profit either then or in the future... In 1845 a Commissariat Relief Department was organised to bring in Indian Corn for sale in Ireland, but none was to be sold until all private stores were sold out...

*In 1846, England, hitherto a Protectionist country, adopted Free Trade, ostensibly in order to permit corn to come freely and cheaply to the starving Irish. In reality, as Ireland was a corn and grain exporting country, the measure brought Continental agricultural produce to England in competition with that of Ireland, and hence, by lowering agricultural prices, still further intensified the misery of the Irish producing classes.

*The real meaning of the measure was that England, being a manufacturing nation, desired to cheapen food in order that its wage-slaves might remain content with low wages, and indeed one of the most immediate results of free trade in England was a wholesale reduction of the wages of the manufacturing proletariat. where characterises the class in its public acts, used the misery of the Irish as a means to conquer the opposition of the English landlord class to free trade in grains, but in this, as in every other measure of the famine years, they acted consistently upon the lines of capitalist political economy.

'Within the limits of that social system and its theories their acts are unassailable and unimpeachable; it is only when we reject that system, and the intellectual and social fetters it imposes, that we really acquire the right to denounce the English administration of Ireland during the famine as a colossal crime against the human race.

*The non-socialist Irish man or woman who fumes against that administration is in the illogical position of denouncing an effect of whose cause he is a supporter. That cause was the system of capitalist property"

In Britain the Irish workers. need class politics - not warmed-up Irish middle-class nationalist politics in the service of short-sightedly ambitious Labour Party local government politicians.

We are for a dialogue with Sinn Fein. But for the Labour Left to mimic the politics of Sinn Fein - inadequate, sectional, narrowly nationalist as they are, with no pretence of either appealing to the Protestant workers or offering them anything other than incorporation as a minority into a Catholic Ireland - can do nobody any good.

Least of all can it do good to the Irish workers in Britain, whose special need is to be emancipated from the traditional 26-County Fianna-Failtype nationalism, a radical version of which is promoted by Sinn Fein.

Fools Habitual fools and fantasists like the publishers of Socialist Action can go on about Sinn Fein being a working-class or - so they sometimes seem to say — a Marxist party. The reality is that Sinn Fein is a Catholic communal organisation, confined to the Catholic community; its socialism is diffuse and ill-defined; its attitude to the majority of the Northern Ireland working class is hostile; its notions of socialist transformation of society are elitist and militarist.

Against this the sociological fact that they have a working-class membership is not decisive. Politically, whatever their good intentions, they are in no sense a working-class organisation.

A dialogue presupposes a viewpoint on each side, and, as we have said, the problem with the British Left is that it does not have an independent working-class viewpoint. It needs to develop one.

We want to open a discussion in the British labour movement on Ireland. We invite contributions.

Become a supporter of the Socialist Organiser Alliance - groups are estab lished in most large towns. We ask £5 a month minimum (£1 unwaged)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 223

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →