Rail union leaders back down again
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-10Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 11 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 11
Sheffield and Chesterfield District Council NUR (in a personal capacity). 4.85 PER CENT is rubbish. For the second year in a row, the rail unions ASLEF and NUR formulated a pay claim of around 30%, plus an extra week's holiday, a 35 hour week, and a minimum enhanceable wage.
For the second year in a row they have sold out for no good reason.
Last year, of course, the miners were out. This year have just lost.
Last year the excuse was that BR had suddenly dropped their demands for productivity deals as a condition of a rise. It emerged later that the government had told BR to make concessions in. order to prevent a second front.
This year the excuse is that after what has happened to the miners there is no feeling for a fight on the railways.
To the extent that this is true, it is only half the story. Though the NUR and ASLEF emerged from the NUM dispute smelling of roses in the noses of most militants, the leadership of our unions shares a large part of the blame for what happened to the NUM. Not willing to fight? NUR/ASLEF p By calling off action repeatedly - on our pay claim last April; over closures and loss of jobs last September; and over victimisation last October, the rail unions helped to keep the NUM isolated.
And now they use the NUM's defeat to justify capitulating on our pay packets.
In any case it was not so clear icket Coalville. Photo: John Harris (IFL) that the members were not interested in a fight. There was no consultation of the membership. The press tells me that local officials reported no appetite for industrial action. I didn't report it.
There was very little propaganda for the claim itself — only a very good leaflet saying we would not accept productivity deals.
And while the end of the miners' strike' has had some demoralising effect on trade unionists, is the ruling-class that rock-solid? Why did British Rail shift so rapidly from saying on February 26 that there was no money for a pay deal, that 30% cuts had to be made in the freight sector, and that they wanted agreement on Driver Only Operation within four weeks to offering 4.85% without strings at the end of March.
Clearly the reduction in coal stocks at the power stations has them worried. And while coal production is nowhere near back to normal, they can't afford the coal trains being stopped just now.
There was clearly plenty of room for the rail union leaders to push for more money.
They'll say we did well. Once again guards and 'second men' still have their jobs.
But British Rail management will be emboldened. Already they have said that they want to extend Driver Only Operation to the Kings Cross/Moorgate North London and Hertfordshire line by August. And this settlement, far from making guards' jobs safe, will endanger them.
One of the strengths of the rail unions recently has been the unity between ASLEF and NUR since former NUR general secretary Sid Weighell got his comeuppance. But all this while BR have been dangling £35 per week before drivers (ASLEF members) to cooperate with Driver Only Operation, i.e. getting rid of guards (NUR members).
Now that the union leaders have once again accepted an 'offer' below 5%, that £35 is going to look very enticing.