After the miners' strike
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
The labour movement and the left are still trying to come to terms with the miners' strike - attempting to assess both the causes of the defeat and what An entire swathe of the so-called Left, including the Communist Party and the soft Left of the Labour Party, is inclined to blame on Arthur Scargill and draw defeatist conclusions.
In the following speech made to the recent Socialist Organiser delegate meeting, John O'Mahony argued that the pessimists and defeatists have got it all wrong. Despite the inevitably depressing effects of the miners' terrible defeat, he argued, the miners' strike was a positive NAGARFACENİT THE MINERS were right to fight, but the tragedy of the miners' strike was that it came very late in the day.
Socialist Organiser advocated full-scale industrial attack on the Tories back in 1980.
.. If the labour movement had had any sort of coherent leadership and strategy, OI any serious perspective for replacing the Tories with something better, then the movement would have taken on the Tories at the beginning of the cycle that has thrown millions of workers out of the factories, creating some four million unemployed.
That did not happen. The showdown came very late in the day, after the slump had weakened the morale and the fibre of the working class, and it took the form of a limited, sectional challenge to the Tories by an NUM which was itself split.
We suffered a serious defeat after 1979. But it was not a defeat in which there were dramatic confrontations. It was a cold, slow, protracted, cumulative defeat. It took the form of a consistent running before the Tory onslaught by the TUC The la bour movement proved unable to produce any coherent alternative to Thatcherism. And Thatcherism, in its turn, had developed on the basis of the failure of the Labour governments in the 1970s and 1960s - the inability of the old consensus ways to deal with the crisis of British capitalism.
It is in this perspective that we must look at the defeat of the miners. If you compare the miners' defeat with the defeat that the whole labour movement suffered without a decisive battle in 1979-84, then you can see that the miners' defeat is a limited defeat.
If there has to be a defeat, this is the best sort of defeat to suffer defeat after a fight in which tens of thousands of workers felt their own strength.
This was a battle will be for the labour movement.
experience for the labour movement.
enthused miners and made the majority feel that they could fight back. It was a battle that showed the working class what it is capable of.
Unlike workers who suffered the earlier defeats, without a fight, the miners can first of all point to specific causes of their defeat - the lack of support from the we could do, we fought the police to a standstill at Orgreave" and so on.
So if you contrast the two defeats, it answers all the sceptics, all the wise-after-theevent people.
What the working class needed above all at this time was to fight. And it was not a foregone conclusion that 12 would lose. It was not at all impossible that the conflagration would spread - as it did briefly from the mines to the docks.
Lessons So what are the lessons? won't belabour the obvious points- the lack of a coherent strategy, the lack of a fighting leadership in the labour movement as a whole, the limited nature of the battle in unfavourable circumstances, the sabotage al the leaders of the official movement.
Allowing for the fact that sections of the rank and file failed to respond, because the morale of the class working has suffered since badly 1979 still the role of the traitors in the Labour Party and the TUC was massive. It certainly made the difference between an isolated miners' strike and a broader working-class challenge to the government. involving other workers, like example dockers, at certain key points in the strike.
It probably made the difference between victory and These are the immer iate lessons of the episodes Dver the last year.
There is an obvious contrast between 1974 and 1984. The miners won in 1974 but the fact that they had to fight again ten years later shows what we have all been saying ism is not enough You need an alternative to the capitalist system, and in 1974 the only alternative to the Tories on offer was Harold Wilson.
Wilson's government demobilised the working class, undercut it, cut real living standards in the mid70s, started the cuts in the welfare state, and pioneered monetarist policies.
The experience of the 1974-9 Labour government -which was the product of a great wave of working class militancy disillusioned many militants, and thus prepared the ground for the passive acceptance of the effects of the slump and the anti-working-class policies of the Tory government after 1979 ever aga The struggle in the Labour Party, focused on the questions of democracy and accountability, which exploded after the Callaghan government was defeated, was a struggle by the labour movement to remake itself, partly in response to the hopelessness of putting in a Labour or pink Tory government, like Wilson's and Callaghan's.
The slogan 'Never Again" referred to the entire experience of the reformist' Wilson/Callaghan governments, which in fact took away from the working class and gave to the rich, instead its consequences rich and redistributing to the working class.
The political wing of the labour movement was - gropingly - trying to remake itself. We have not done that.
Instead we now have a political labour movement dominated by the soft lett, as bereft of a serious working-class alternative to Toryism as ever Wilson, Callaghan - or Ramsay MacDonald - were.
Kinnock did miserably in the miners' strike. Any of his recent predecessors would have done much worse, but his performance in the miners' strike provides us with a true measure of what Neil Kinnock is. The political labour movement has been improved, perhaps, but it has not been decisively transformed.
We still need to remake labour movement.
So where do after the defeat of strike?
In terms of the economy, the Tories are making all sorts of claims. But the level of unemployment is not going to go down. The general economic disruption will continue for the foreseeable future.
The political system is in serious crisis. It is undergoing considerable changes. We have seen the creation of a national police force. They tell us it has been disbanded but in reality a major step has been taken towards creating a much stronger state.
We have seen the development of systematic strikebreaking - a new departure for British industrial struggles over the last forty years.
If the Post Office workers had taken strike action, the government planned to coordinate attempts to break that strike too.
We have witnessed a serious worsening of the entire political atmosphere. We have entered a period of naked class struggle. One of the most important things about the miners' strike was that it was open, naked class struggle.
Violence The violence of the language - Thatcher comparing the miners to the Argentinians, "the enemv within" in its own way prefigures an intensification of the level of conflict in any future class struggles.
To a extent, the political system has been changed into something else.
Unless the working class suffers a crushing, disabling defeat, this shift towards more open class struggle will probably continue. to teach the working class some lessons in class struggle..
We talk about the need for a revolutionary socialist party that would function in the class struggle as the memory of the class. But a revolutionary party does not communicate that memory to the whole of the class. It conveys it in a limited way to some of the advanced sections of the class.
Moreover, such a party, of an adequate size, scope, and implantation in the basic organisations of the working class does not exist. If it had existed in 1979 and after, then recent British history would have gone very differently.
In the absence of a serious revolutionary party, the Tories - who had planned for this strike for 12 years - have forced many miners to relearn some of the key lessons of working-class history. They have given us good lessons in naked class struggle over the last year.
If the British labour movement does not learn those lessons, then the Tories will give us shaiper lessons in class struggle - and force us to pay an even higher price than the miners and the working class have paid in 1984 and early 1985.
In no sense can the strike be written off as a generally negative experience, despite the defeat. Tens of thousands of workers have learned from it. Tens of thousands of workers will have been politicised by this strike.
Contrast 1974. There was victory and a Labour government was put into power. But there was a demobilisation in the class, a feeling among militant miners that they could simply relax. As a consequence they had to fight again ten years later, worse conditions, and they lost.
Class struggle is a school for socialism, and paradoxically, workers can sometimes learn more from defeats than they can from victories, providing they are not unalterable, irreversible defeats.
Build!
Victory preferable to defeat! But we must make the best of things as they are.
For example, it was the lessons of the defeats in the engineering industry in the early '20s that turned militants, led at that time by the Communist Party, to the work of building the Minority Movement within a few years after the defeat. And the Minority Movement's affiliated strength was soon one quarter of the whole TUC.
So, the whole climate is changing towards one of class struggle, and it is that climate which allows the revolutionary left to grow and develop - so that next time round the working class will have a better chance of winning. TUs and However, the signs are that the trade unions have been seriously softened up.
The Tories" anti-union laws are going to force the
Scan page 7
* What next?
BATTLE F WOR YOU WON with the impasse of the old reformism. But the rebellion was on a very primitive level. And thus the setbacks.
So there are problems for the Left in the Labour Party. But there too whole layers of people have been made militant by the miners strike. They've also had it shown to them how central industrial struggle is.
Many of these people particularly under the schoolmastership of the Communist Party and the Labour Coordinating Committee and so on - are likely now to draw the conclusion that we shouldn't have fought. But I think there is going to be tremendous scope in the Labour Party for us to draw out the lessons. Many will draw the proper lessons from the experience, and we must help them to do that.
We must point out that one of the great lessons of the previous period of struggle in the Labour Party is that the Labour Party and the trade unions are inseparable - the fact that the setbacks for the Labour Left were organised Led raight to WE lave had.
Kinnock
So. there have been setbacks for the Left in the Labour Party. I can't see the prospect of overturning the lead ership at the moment. If Labour wins the next election it most certainly will not be a workers' government in even the most minimal sense. They have already largely (though not quite entirely) drawn the teeth of reselection. A Kinnock government will be like the last Labour government, but worse.
But all these developments will not be just a repetition of last time round. There are lots and lots of militants now inside the Labour Party who will fight like the devil against a Kinnock government. They have learned lessons that the militants in the "70s had not learned, and they are more numerous.
So here again I do not common property o many tens of thousands of But that has not been crystallised into a coherent revolutionary party.
The inadequacies organised groups - li ke Militant, the SWP, etc increasingly cleat.
The Finally, I want broader view.
25 years ago, the TOC general secretary of the time, George Woodcock, boasted that the TUC had come in off the streets and moved into the corridors of power. The labour movement was co-opted by the system. It was neutered, made incapable of providing any alternative to the system even when it could bring down governments, as it did in 1974.
----- pull-quotes -----
Organiser SMARVEL BATTERED, DEFIANT
say or example Than out, we showed them what
Special issue THE 1984+5 STRIKE
for a very long time, that even victorious gut syndical-
of taking the profits of the experience of the
Politica crisis
Tory lessons The ruling class has begun
TOU MAY THE BUT