Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Fi of naked class struggle d of naked…]

Socialist Organiser no. 224, 17 April 1985 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,280 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Fi of naked class struggle d of naked class struggle en, naked class struggle' unions to transform the way they do things. For example, for decades it has been taken for granted that the unions were affiliated to the Labour Party. For decades - it has changed a little recently -the right wing of the Labour Party could rely the unions as solid rotten boroughs, with millions of block votes, to control the party.

If we lose the plebiscites enforced by the Tories on the political levy, it could be a grievous blow for the movement. We don't have to lose. We must go in there and fight for the Labour Party link.

The fact that whole layers of Labour Party people are going to have to turn to a fight in the unions is going to force Labour Party members in the unions to become a political force, such as they have not been tor decades.

Every blow the Tories strike at us should be resisted. But everything they are doing to us - the whole Tory school of class struggle -does in fact have another aspect to it. It forces the working class to turn to class struggle too.

There is a long way to go before we arrive at the situation where we have leaders on our side of the calibre and combativity that the Thatchers have for their side.

The situation in the Labour Party is more complicated. In themselves - and we pointed this out repeatedly at the time = the various proposals for democracy and accountability fought for after 1979 were not revolutionary. Most of them are the norm in continental social-democratic parties. They have not made those parties other than social-democratic parties, in many cases worse than the Labour Party.

But at the time they were a direct challenge to the status quo.

The limits of that whole movement lay in this: that to a large extent the democracy struggle was separated from political questions. The energy that led people to fight around democratising the Labour Party was political energy, but the fight remained one-dimensional, org anisational.

So the demands could be co-opted by the soft left and even by the right wing. In the last period we have seen a quite serious retreat of the Left in the Labour Party.

As I argued above, the struggle in the Labour Party was really part of a process in which the working class movement was trying to renew itself. We were faced by the trade union barons.

We must talk to the new layers of militants about the need to link the struggles for democracy in the Labour Party and in the unions, and the need above all to have a political alternative to Toryism which Kinnock does not have.

Within the overall framework of setbacks for the Left, I think there are prospects for seriously regrouping quite large layers of the Labour Left.

nm Lefts One aspect of this is has happened with the local government Left.

Six years ago Socialist Organiser had the hope that we could be quite close to the centre of a broad organised Labour left wing based on a roughly adequate class-struggle programme. That was not an unreasonable perspective. There were masses of people reacting against the last Labour government.

What happened to them? That lett wing split, and we were left relatively isolated. It split along the lines of attitudes to local government.

The major forces, and the major public figures, turned towards becoming administrators of the local state, with policies like high rate rises which were fundamentally untenable, even in the medium term, as an answer to the Tory attacks.

Instead of preparing to confront the government, they chose to weave and duck and evade the conflict.

We should fight for the lessons of this fiasco in local government to be brought home. We can point out, and we should point out, that it was not just a matter of John McDonnell not consulting Ken Livingstone, or Ken Livingstone losing his nerve at the end - the whole trajectory for five or six years draw pessimistic conclusions.

I also do not expect a full-scale witch-hunt. If Labour's leaders want to win the next election, then they cannot have a full-scale purge against Militant. If they have a full-scale purge against Militant, they will wreck the party and lose the election. All the signs are that they know this and they are not going to do it.

Of course there will be people picked off locally, but that's not the same.

What is the state of Left?

The broad left of the labour movement has been going to school for five or six years to local government politics - reformist politics.

People like Ken Livingstone and Ted Knight have educated layers of the movement into reformism. And the arguments they use to make people toe the line within local government options also apply, every one of them, to a future Kinnockite government operating i within capitalist options. Livingstone Livingstone talks far left -but actually Livingstone has been doing the sort of alliance-building across the classes, all the way to Edward Heath, that the right wing of "Marxism Today' want.

But that is only one part of the Left.

The Communist Party is visibly breaking up. That is bad news for us because it is going to strengthen the right wing of the 'Left' in the Labour Party. But maybe, in the medium term, after we have dealt with that problem, Marxists will reap the advantages of having a clearer field on the Left.

The revolutionary Left? Over the past 15 or 20 years the revolutionary Left has grown, Its ideas have become So now, side by side with the decline in TUC membership, there are advances. A class-struggle atmosphere has been developed.

There is no guarantee that the Tory blows will not drive the labour movement down and backwards, that basic damage won't be done. It's our job to fight back. But the Tory attacks open up a great Pandora's Box for the ruling class.

The movement, despite weaknesses, despite blows, is in a far better state than 25 years ago - if we see it not as a stable, corporate partner in British capitalism, but as a force which must remake society.

The Hobsbawmites, echoed on the left by the SWP, talk about the labour movement being in terrible decline. Something very like that was said after the 1959 general election. Mark Abrams and others argued that the working class had become bourgeoisified. The right wing of the Labour Party argued against class politics in very much the same terms as used by Marxism Today and Hobsbawm now.

Then, too, if you look at the press of the SWP (then IS), you will see that they reflected it, for example articles by the well-known academic Alistair McIntyre, who was a central figure in the SWP at that time, Obviously things are not exactly the same now as then. But the notion that setbacks should lead us to abandon the programme of the movement being able to recreate itself as revolutionary socialist ment is as invalid now as then.

Organiser

For ourselves, what concl asions follow from all this?

In the next period we have to tighten ourselves up. winning new supporters for After all, for 62 years Trotskyism has been right at all the major turning points. But it is not enough to be right. You have to have a force to intervene, a lever to move things,

Scan page 8

Socialist Organiser no. 224

----- pull-quotes -----

The Labou party

The loca gover

Revolutionary left

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 224

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →