Peter Tatchell's latest book A defence policy for labour ?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-17Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
SHE FALKLAND SI EXPE Conventional or nuclear, we must ask: who do these weapons defend? Martin Thomas reviews 'Democratic Defence' by Peter Tatchell (GMP/ Heretic, £3.95)
PETER Tatchell has written a patchy book about an important subject.
The Labour leadership, and increasingly CND too, are going for a heavy 'conventional' arms drive within NAlU as an alternative to nuclear weapons. At the other end of the debate, many on the Left think that even to talk about "alternative defence" is a sell-out: we should simply denounce all and every military project of imperialist Britain.
Yet as long as nation-states exist, so also will national armed forces. Not even the socialist revolution will immediately do away with them. And in the meantime it cannot be a matter of indifference to us what sort of armed forces Britain (or other countries) have.
The Marxist Left needs a policy which does more than argue with the Tories about the techniques of weaponry, but which also can rally the vast majority of working class people who can be convinced about the horrors of nuclear war and the crimes of British imperialism but do not want to see their country defenceless.
The earlier chapters of Peter Tatchell's book contain quite a lot that is encouraging. He documents the horrors of nuclear war; the fact that the British army has been continuously at war ever since 1945, trying to uphold imperialist interests overseas; the use of the armed forces as instruments of class war inside Britain, and the plans of the military top brass for their more drastic use; and the regime of brutality and mindless obedience cultivated in the armed forces.
he cites Marx, Engels, Blanqui, Bebel and Jaures on people's militias as an alternative to standing armies; and an interesting chapter chronicles mutinies and soldiers' rights movements in the British armed forces.
Swings Then he swings off, through appreciative descriptions of the Swedish, Swiss and Yugoslav armed forces, to a blueprint for 'democratic defence' which actually has a bigger UK-based regular army than now! He concludes by praising the 1984 Labour Party conference document - the document in which the Kinnock leadership cut loose from Labour's previous commitment drastically to reduce military spending - as "the most imaginative and radical defence policy adopted by any party since the war"
He discussed opposed to 'aggressive' weaponry. I think this distinction is a real one.
Anti-tank missiles, anti-aircraft guns, short-range interceptor fighter-planes, etc., are not very useful for invading other countries. At the other end of the spectrum, nuclear bombs can 'defend' a country only by wiping out the population of its opponent (and, very probably, through the subsequent disturbances to the atmosphere and climate, of the world).
The main problem with the book, I think, is that its arguments do not develop logically, but rather according to classic Labour Party methods. A general (good) sentiment is expressed, and then every proposal or argument tending in that broad direction is indiscriminately supported, regardless ot logical incoherence.
The Swedish and Swiss systems (non-nuclear, with a much higher territorial/militia element than Britain, and in Sweden's case with extensive trade union and democratic rights for soldiers) are undoubtedly, all else being equal, lesser evils than Britain's.
But by this point in the book Peter Tatchell is abstracting his discussion of military systems completely from class relationships (which he does mention in earlier chapters). He makes no attempt to analyse why Sweden or Switzerland have different systems from Britain: he writes as if this were a matter of political choice as simple as different patterns for national flags or tunes for national anthems.
Capital
In fact Sweden and Switzerland are among the world's foremost imperialist powers in respect of export of capital. Only they are able to rely on US military might to underpin the world system which permits their huge and profitable exploitation of foreign labour.
In return for renouncing any aspirations to an independent role in world diplomacy and power-politics, and accepting a framework set by such powers as the US, these smaller advanced capitalist countries are able to economise on military expenditure.
But such military renunciation is not an option for the system as a whole. To advocate naively that the major capitalist states follow the example of Sweden or Switzerland is to obscure the basic reasons for capitalist militarism. earlier chapters Peter Tatchell explains well enough why we only in terms of one country against another. The people of each country also, and indeed especially, need defence against their own ruling class.
By the later chapters it is as if he has torgotten this. Feter Tatchell's blueprint for democratic defence' includes, for example, the SAS remaining intact, on the grounds that it would be "especially valuable for guerrilla-style operations behind enemy lines"!
Peter Tatchell finds a valuable precedent for popular detence in the Home Guard formed during World War 2. I'm not sure, but I think his vision here is clouded by his notion that World War 2 was "a just war of self-defence" on Britain's part.
The usual justification for World War 2 — that it was a war of "democracy against fascism" - is thin enough. The British ruling class were not fighting for democracy, but for their Empire.
The argument that it was about self-defence is even thinner. Britain was not threatened with invasion when it went to war in 1939, nor after 1940; even in those months of 1940 when a German invasion of TRY MOB THE NEW OR THE AR!
Britain was a real possibility, primarily Britain was trying to stop Germany acquiring predominance in continental Europe and threatening the Middle East, then the lynchpin of the British Empire.
Peter Tatchell describes World War 2 as a "momentary aberration" by the British ruling class! Would it not be more reasonable to conclude that the British ruling class during World War 2 were exactly what they had been for centuries before and have been for decades since - in Peter Tatchell's own phrase, "paperthin patriots who would rather. defend their wealth than defend their country, its people and its liberties"
Yes, it was necessary to fight Hitler. But that did not have to mean, and should not have meant, suspending the fight against British imperialism.
Proletarian
The Trotskyist movement. in the run-up to and during World War 2, developed what it called the profetarian military policy* - nationalisation without compensation and under workers' control of the war industries; trade-union control over military training and especially officers' training; a people's militia, based on workplaces and communities, in place of the standing army.
Such a policy would be a better starting point for discussing "democratic defence' than the Swedish armed forces. Still - Peter Tatchell's book opens an important debate. Read it, and try to get your Labour Party and trade union to discuss it.
Democratic Defence, by Peter Tatchell, GMP/Heretic, E3.95
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no.224 April 17 1985 Page 10