Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Keep our unions the TGWU!

Socialist Organiser no. 224, 17 April 1985 · scan p. 12 · about 1,169 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 12

organiser

t-rigeing in the TGWU is 15 drivers in WITHOUT doubt, much of HOUT doubt, much of the outcry over allegations of rutcry over allegations of ballot-rigging in the TGWU is pure hypocrisy. Fleet Street is not so much concerned with democratic principles (they happily ignore the way right wing union leaders trample on the rights of their members) as with discrediting trade unionism in general and internal union decision-making processes in particular:

It fits in very nicely with Tebbit's laws forcing secret ballots before strikes and for the election of union officers. It also comes just prior to the period of balloting on the political levy.

It would be wrong to dismiss the whole business as just another exercise in Tory anti-union propaganda. Ballot rigging (euphemistically referred to within the union as "block voting") is rife within the TGWU and rank and file members are quite right to be angry about it.

The current crop of allegations happen to involve supporters of the left wing general secretary-elect Ron Todd.

But in the past the right wing have shown themselves quite willing to engage in "block voting" , and there is no reason to believe that in the general secretary election the practice was confined to supporters of Todd.

Quite simply, what "block voting" means is that instead of distributing ballot papers to the members, branch secretaries and other members find it more convenient to fill them in themselves - "on behalf of" the members, so to speak.

Alone

The TGWU's election procedures are wide open to abuse. Ballot forms and stubs are not numbered. Ballot boxes are flimsy cardboard affairs. Officials are left alone with the ballot boxes for long periods of time, during and after the vote.

An inquiry by the TGWU Region 3 committee into to two expulsions (of a Regional Committee member and of a full-time official and to the branch secretary being banned from office for life.

The focus of attention has now shifted to Northern Ireland (Region 11) where an unusually high turn-out in the lection was recorded. ficwhen I realised I was done out of my vote that I lost my rag."

Both men appear to be sincere rank and file trade unionists, reluctant to criticise the union in public and not out to make a fast buck by fuelling any anti-union campaign.

This is by no means the first time that allegations of this kind have been made within the TGWU, although up till now, scandals have been fairly successfully hushed up by the union bureaucracy. In November 1977 Alan | Law, full time 1977 Ala! officer fc officer for road haulage drivers in the Midlands, and secretary of the 5/35 Bir mingham branch, was caught ballot-rigging. He had personally filled in almost all the 4,500 ballot papers issued to the branch for three electtions: national trade group committee, regional committee and general executive When this was revealed the branch returns were disqualified but no further action was taken at that time against Law. Indeed, the Region 5 secretary, Brian Mathers, (who is still in office) systematically covered up for Law and the Regional Committee refused rank and file demands for an inquiry.

It was only when two angry but misguided left-wingers made a formal complaint to the police that the Regional Committee decided to remove Law as branch secretary and persuaded him to retire at 60 a year or so later.

Deafness

Even then, the official reason was given as being Law's deafness (!).

At the time of the Alan Law scandal it was the far left that campaigned to expose ballot-rigging and it has been the far left who have fought for years to democratise the union by tightening up voting procedures, opposing block voting and introducing regular elections for all full-time officials.

Our distaste for the way the media is using the present "scandal" as an excuse for union-bashing, and our suspicions about the real motives of those within the union who are demanding a re-run of the election should not lead us into making excuses for "block voting" or into letting up in the fight for democratic reforms.

If the left does not champion the cause of trade union democracy, then the right wing will have a clear run to capitalise on the justified outrage of the membership.

The end result of that could well be the TGWU following the EETPU and the AUEW and accepting government money for secret ballots. If we are to defend active democracy based upon mass meetings and workplace ballots, then the left must take the lead in rooting out the ballot-rigging. THE Tory-imposed tes on whether or unions should have funds must be held The most important task the labour movement faces in the next year is to win a yes vote in these ballots. A no vote in any major union would throw the labour movement backwards and badly weaken the Labour PartyThe chance of defeat is a real one in some unions. Therefore we must organise a powerful campaign in every union to explain the advantages of a political fund and the need for a politically active labour movement.

The tragic NUM vote not to levy 50p for sacked and jailed miners was in part a result of the failure of the area NUM leaderships to campaign for a yes vote.

Every section and every level of the labour movement must campaign vigorously in favour of the political levy. The NUR is setting a good example to the labour movement here.

Rob Dawber reports on how the NUR is gearing istel itself up for the ballot. THE campaign in the NUR for a yes vote in the Toryimposed ballot on whether or not the union should have a political fund is being pursued quite energetically and with a clear determination to win.

Weekend schools and day schools have been and are being organised, both locally and nationally. Lost wages are paid by the union, to encourage participation. The schools are meant to train a network of 'activists' in the basic arguments for a political fund. The intention is to have an "activist' in every workplace who can persuade their workmates to vote 'yes' A network of 'activists" who are in direct contact with the campaign unit at the NUR's head office will give vigour to the campaign and ensure that it is not just something extra piled onto the branch secretaries. This in itself allows the campaign to tap energies rather than be just pushed to one side.

A regular newsletter goes out to all activists giving information and seeking ideas. Those who are heading the campaign are encouraging members to send in ideas for posters, leaflets and so on and also encouraging local leaflets Continued on p.11 Join the Labour Party Write to: The Labour Party, 150 Walworth Road, London SE17 IT.

Subser iption is £7 per year, f 2 unwaged, 50p OAPs.

----- pull-quotes -----

off the TGWU! box there. It was just that

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 224

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →