Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The issues behind the Powell Bill Defending whose rights?

Socialist Organiser no. 225, 24 April 1985 · scan p. 3 · about 2,180 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

THE SCOTTISH rail network was brought to a standstill last Wednesday (April 17) by a 24hour NUR strike in opposition to the rundown of the Springburn British Rail Engineering Ltd workshop in Glasgow (the "Caley').

BR is now collecting evidence to sue the union for loss of revenue.

1250 jobs are to be axed at Springburn by the close of the decade. It would then be only a matter of time before complete closure and the loss of the remaining 500 jobs. -Support for the strike was virtually 100%. "Don't dillydally — stop out for the Caley". read the placard outside the Polmadie depot on the other side of the Clyde from Springburn. NUR branch spokesperson Jimmy Barrett told SO: "Support for the strike here is solid. There's no-one going in, and there's nothing moving at all* Ten Only ten trains ran in the whole of Scotland during the day. Six were run by English crews between Carlisle and Dumfries, but the signalmen soon put a stop to that. The other four ran in the West Highlands.

ASLEF members abided by union instructions not to cross picket lines. Members of the clerical union TSSA did cross picket lines: unfortunately, there's nothing new about that.

The NUR had drawn up rotas for 24-hour picketing of all depots, workshops and main railway stations. But no pickets were stationed at the Ravenscraig steelworks in Motherwell. Lorry convoys have continued to bring in coal there since the end of the miners' strike, and their size was increased on the NUR day of action.

As NUR West of Scotland organiser Charlie Wynd pointed out at a press conference: "BSC says it has large coal supplies stockpiled at Ravenscraig. So why do they need to bring in more hauliers because of a 24 hour strike? This is obviously provocative"

Pickets talked about further one-day strike to contine the campaign. At the NUR press conference Charlie Wynd was non-committal.

At the Springburn workshops, consistent and vigorous campaigning will be required to prevent the kind of large-scale voluntary redundancies which have undermined previous attempts to fight job losses there.

The NUR will also need to win active support from outside its own ranks, both to save jobs and to defeat BR's use of the Tory anti-strike laws.

Gerry AT first thought it feels rather strange that after years of fighting for free abortion and contraception, the issues should suddenly be turned on their head and we have to assert the rights of women to have children. In fact, working class women have always had to defend that right, against forced sterilisation and "enlightened" population-controllers. Black women, in the not very distant past, have had their children stolen or sold, literally, into slavery. Working class and slave women were forced to desert their own children and become wet-nurse, carer and surrogate mother to the children of the white ruling class.

It has become an issue again now because of advances in the techniques of (artificial) reproduction, the Warnock Report and the panic reaction to it. Two Bills, one government-sponsored to outlaw "commercial surrogacy"*, the other, the Powell Bill, banning experimentation on human embryos, are wending their way through the legislative process. Powell's may well fall this time for lack of Parliamentary time, but will not go away altogether.

Reaction The whole area is an emotive one, and rightly so. Both Bills gained a big impetus from "instinctive" public reaction. But precisely because they raise fundamental questions, there is all the more need for initial emotional reaction to be superceded by rational examination oi the issues. Iwo Iv programmes shown last Monday (thankfully, not simultaneously) set out to do this: World in Action, on commercial surrogacy, and | Panorama on the Powell Bill.

Of the two, World in Action was by far the more rivetting television, but probably less edifying. (It may just be that the issue is less clear-cut and therefore 1 could not reasonably be expected to be convinced of one side or the other). Its centrepiece was the case of a baby born brain-damaged, whose prospective buyer-parent rejected the child and demanded his money back. We saw heartwrenching shots of a tiny baby (not the actual child who is now two in intensive care, bandaged, surrounded by tubes, with a gaping hole in its chest, presumably from surgery. Then we saw the two lots of parents and their lawyers slugging itout on nationwide TV. It was horribly compelling viewing, like Family Fortunes crossed with Dallas and the News. You could certainly tell the goodies, the stolid natural parents who cared for the damaged child (it turned out anyway that the child was genetically the husband's and not the buyer-father's) from the baddie who even had an evil little moustache. What made the whole experience rather nauseous was the realisation that these were real people not characters from a soap opera.

There might have been more justification if that sequence had illuminated the issues. It dramatised, and how!, the issue of who is responsible if things go wrong, but that isn't the central question in surrogacy. Every birth carries the risk that the child may be born damaged in some way and while this creates paintul dilemmas for those involved, nobody would argue that we therefore ban motherhood.

The central issue which was touched on but not satisfactorily it seems to me is whether commercial surrogacy is so repugnant that it shold be criminalised. It seems to be generally accepted that a woman who, out of altruism, is prepared to carry a child for an infertile woman should be allowed (even encouraged) to do so. It is when she gets paid for her pains that the problem arises. Now there is something peculiarly hypocritical about capitalist politicians condemning the commercial aspect of the transaction. Commercial surrogacy is arguably the XXXXX of capitalist relations. The woman sells her labour power! She is a free agent, the only constraints on her are economic. As socialists these economic constrints concern us. In reality, it will be working class and oppressed *Third World" women who will be selling and white middle class women who will be buying. But that is capitalism. And the only way of removing this inequality is by getting rid of capitalism. There are cultures, e.g. the Masai, where women willingly bear children for other childless women. In this society, if women are willing to do that why shouldn't they be adequately compensated for the labour involved? Isn't it more exploitative that they be expected to do it for nothing? The problem for socialists seems to lie at the other end of the transaction: that only economically privileged childless women will have the option open to them. Should we then be demanding that this service be provided by the weltare state! Leaving aside the question ot the current state of health and social services, priorities, elc. would that be a bad thing in principle? I don't know the answer and I'm afraid World in Action didn't persuade me. I am convinced, though, that the government's Bill won't help and is a further infringement of civil liberties.

Balance Panorama on the Powell Bill was much more enlightening. It didn't seem to conform to the BBC's usual notion of balance - presenting the supporters of the Bill as religious fundamentalists, seasoned and cynical campaigners like "Life", emotional but misinformed public opinion and the dangerous Mr Powell himself. The opponents came over as better informed, with the weight of the medical establishment behind them, personally sincere, often desperate, like the childless women, or parents of handicapped or genetically damaged children. I think it is entirely laudable that the spurious "balance" was abandoned. If one side is ignorant and the other well-reasoned, then they should be seen to be so.

DaL Over a million people signed a petition in favour of legislation to outlaw human embryo experimentation and in opinion polls the majority of those questioned were in favour of such a ban. I'm all for majority rule but it should be on the basis of informed rational argument, and things are not quite what they seem. In the same poll, when the question was put that if embryo experimentation was to help eliminate genetic defects/ the majority was then in favour of such experiments.

The architect himself and some of Powell's supporters know exactly what is entailed in the Bill and are using, either cynically or through religious conviction or both, public emotion to stampede it through. There are those who believe that a human being exists from the moment of conception and are therefore opposed to embryo research, abortion and postcoital contraception.

The title of the Bill, for the Protection of the Unborn Child is designed to appeal to this constituency, although as Powell himselt pointed out there is no mention anywhere else in the Bill of the "unborn child" These are the people who take their political instruction from the pulpit. But they are a small (and thanks to the campaigns for women's choice, increasingly beleaguered) minority. In order to gain mass support they have to rely on generating a wider public hysteria.

It is probably entirely coincidental that this debate coincided with revelations about the Nazi doctor Mengele, but having been handed such a gift, the SPUC/LIFE have played it for all it's worth. It is worth examining the implied argument here because it haunts much of public debate. SPUC/LIFE argue quite explicitly that there is a slippery slope leading from the denial of the humanity of the embryo/ foetus to the ultimate pinnacle of inhumanity — the Nazi holocaust.

If you vote for abortion today, you'll be fuelling the gas chambers tomorrow. This is both historically and logically back to front. What made Mengele's atrocities possible was that the Nazis had established politically and militarily that it was OK to treat Jews and other minorities as non-human. Law had nothing to do with it: they had the political-military power to do what they liked. It is right that we are still haunted by the memory of Nazi genocide, but the way LEC ensure it is never repeated is fight every manifestation racism/anti-semitism/homophobia including those sanc tioned by law and state. We should not forget how Powel first made a name for himself!

The Powell Bill also plays or the anxieties of women that technologies of reproduction are getting out of control Many women are unhappy that childbirth seems to have become mechanised and worry that the process will be pushed a stage further by the mechanisation of conception. But we shouldn't confuse the appearance (technology) with the real problem -oppressive social reitions. What oppresses us is not the machine but the man. Pregnancy and childbirth have become alienating because the power to make decisions, and be informed is increasingly in the hands of an alien class (and race and sex). To oppose artificial methods of conception implicitly glorifies "natural" conception, as if it does not take place within oppressive social relationships!

Behind it lurks the heterosexst assumption that non-reproluctive sexuality is "unnatur il". The separation of sexuality ind reproduction has been a najor liberating gain for women ind we should welcome its extension.

The final part of the Pano rama programme was a debati between Enoch Powell ane Kenneth Clarke, the Healti Minister, who opposes the Bill It wasn't the most exciting con frontation in the history of tele vision. Although opposed on this issue, Powell and Clarke share a common ideology. The Tory Cabinet is split on the Bill, sc Clarke was wary of throwing his ministerial weight around. If he hadn't bottled out, he would anyway have shown himself a lightweight against his intellectual superior. It was terribly lowkey stuff. What made it compulsive (and repulsive) was Powell himself, like watching a very self-assured cobra. He can still send a chill down your spine.

Tribal Powell combines ice-col logic, a pendant's precision witl a nose for the bloody subter ranean side of the public con science' . From racist rivers-of blood, to Ulster Unionist triba politics to protection of th "unborn". , he knows how t from the hypocrisy over the "unborn child" mentioner previously, Powell revealed tha his Bill would not outlaw the screening of embryos for genetic defects. In religious fundamen talist terms, he is in favour of killing defective unborn chil dren. How many of his support ers know this? He treads a fine line between the reed to mobil ise these people with the prag matic desire to frame his Bill in such a way that it is acceptable to the majority.

The programme alarmed me! Even if it falls for lack of time. Powell and his Bill are not dead. Undead, perhaps?

*Note: I have used the term "surrogate mother" throughout because that's the common usage and I can't think of a substitute. However, I think it's offensive since the woman who bears the child is its actual natural mother. and it implies property rights are the overriding thing.

----- pull-quotes -----

calculate the exact pressure or collective nerve-endings. Apar

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 225

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →