Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[AS a member of the Labour Committee on…]

Socialist Organiser no. 225, 24 April 1985 · scan p. 4 · about 448 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

AS a member of the Labour Committee on Ireland and a regular reader of Socialist Organiser, I was very disappointed in the two articles on Ireland in SO 223.

Your attack on the "local government left" who have taken up the Irish question is cynical. There is no basis to your allegations of electoral populism. Opponents of the LCI see a principled stand on Ireland as an electoral liability. Those in the labour movement who have taken that stand are subjected to campaigns of vilification not only from the Tory press and right, but also from pseudoleft wingers in the Labour Party.

It appears that you only dabble in Irish politics to snipe at other groups and individuals active on the issue.

Your analysis of Sinn Fein rivals that of Militant in its distortions and mis-representation. You accuse Sinn Fein of being "militarist" - when Republicans are engaged in armed struggle against British militarism and imperialism.

You say that Sinn Fein is "sectional because they have failed to recruit Protestant workers. Perhaps you regard the ANC or UDF as racist because they have failed to win over working class whites in South Africa.

You denigrate the working class credentials of the only mass socialist party in Ireland (the Irish Labour Party cannot be described as socialist). You claim to be in favour of a 'dialogue' with Sinn Fein, yet you echo the dis-information campaign of the tabloid press.

It seems that every political sect must have its fetishes. SO has adopted federalism. Militant makes abstract calls for workers' unity and backs it up with economist slogans. SO makes the same abstract calls but backs it up with a demand for a federal constitution.

You have the audacity to call this "class politics" . You contend that the British Left should "propose a convincing comprehensive alternative to the status quo" in Northern Ireland. That is the tasks of Irish socialists, not patronising chauvinists in the British labour movement.

Your federal alternative appears as a plausible, diberal solution to the division of Ireland. Yet that division is maintained by an artificial, loyalist state - kept in existence by British troops and sectarian paramilitary forces (e.g. the RUC, UDR, UDA and UVF). Your solution is to fossilise that sectarian state in a federal Ireland; to perpetuate the division of the working class under a bogus unity. Your plausible slogans hide a lack of serious analysis.

The task of British socialists is to build the movement for British withdrawal from Ireland; not to pontificate about a future Irish constitution. SO has an important part to play in building that movement. The LCI needs your active support.

Yours fraternally, PAUL WOZNY Southampton

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 225

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →