Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

A full coverage

Socialist Organiser no. 225, 24 April 1985 · scan pp. 5–8 · about 3,398 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

MAGNIFICENT full account and analysis of the miners' strike. 75p postage from SO, 214 Sickert Court, London N1 The first plus 22p 2SY. STARVED. BATTERED, DEFIANT THE 1984-5 STRIKE Albert Bowns, Kiveton Park NUM delegate (writing in a personal capacity), reviews the Socialist Organiser pamphlet Magnificent THE pamphlet gave comprehensive coverage the strike, and I particularly enjoyed reading the boxed comments from past issues of Socialist Organiser.

This brought the specifics back to mind which each chapter was covering.

There were also many photos which I had either missed in issues of SO or which had been newly included, and the excellence of the SO photographers of being in the right place at the right time was evident by their clarity.

An important section covering the facts and figures of the strike was included. Statistics showing the cost of the strike, such as coal imports, are important as an indication of the lengths the government will be willing to go to in future actions.

One criticism I do have is that I would have liked to have seen an account of the Ridley Report as an introduction to the strike. This report, and its full implementation by the government, had a larger impact on the conduct of the strike by the government than it has been given credit for.

This pamphlet is well documented, easy to read and cheap to buy and would make an ideal education document for schools. Obviously that will not happen, because that is what the strike was about and until such a victory is won, this pamphlet will not be used fully in the way it deserves. ation, but there is not much they can do about it. I don't think much will happen about Notts until after the NUM annual conference.

The branches in Notts have continued to meet and as at Bevercotes, former strikers have been expelled meetings have been closed down and the whole situation is chaotic throughout the coalfield. Minutes of meetings haven't been taken, votes haven't been taken. Some branches let them stay in and vote, others didn't and it seems every branch has got a different interpretation of what they can and can't do.

One breakthrough has been the reinstatement of a sacked miner from Welbeck with no loss of service or ORGANISER each door by post.

Name.

Address Please st To: Soc

Scan page 6

word war Britain has fought many, many wars. Almost all have b wars of subjugation against overseas peoples. One war different: the 1939-45 war in which Britain fought Nazi But why were strikers jailed in wartime Britain? Why were miners who struck at Betteshanger, Kent, witch-hunted? Wh was so much of Britain's war concerned with defending not Britain, but Britain's control of the Suez Canal?

For sure the Nazis had to be fought. But what was TAm. n finhtina for Martin Thomao Innke IN the coming weeks, official commemorations of World War 2 will reach a peak of self-congratulation.

And parts of the Left will join in the acclamation for Britain's and the US's "war for democracy against fascism" • The Morning Star is organising a special festival to mark the anniversary of the victory over Germany.

On the face of it, this makes sense. Wasn't it the united democratic forces, behind Churchill and Roosevelt, which rid the world of the Hitlerite menace? Wasn't that war the sort of crusade of democracy against fascism Which we need today?

In reality, the policy of the workers' movement sinking itself into a general campaign of "democracy against fascism" helped the rise of fascism and the unleashing of World War 2.

In Germany the strongest workers' party, the Social Democrats, kept calling on the police to deal with Hitler's thugs. They advised the workers not to fight the fascists on the streets, and to support Field Marshal Hindenburg for President instead of splitting the anti-fascist Hindenburg was elected and in due course he called Hitler to power!

In Spain not only the Socialists but also the Communist Party called on the workers to support the Republican bourgeoisie in the name of the struggle against fascism. In the name of unity they suppressed factory occupations and land seizures, refused to support independence for Morocco and shot down Trotskyists, Anarchists and left-wing Socialists. The result was Franco's victory.

Stooge

France was the other great country of the People's Front against fascism. There, the Parliament elected in 1936 with a People's Front majority ended up, in June 1940, voting full powers to the Nazi stooge Petain!

In the last analysis, both fascism and parliamentary democracy are methods of the same exploiting class -the capitalists - in order to control the working class. Germany.

Parliamentary democracy controls the working class by drawing the labour bureaucrats into an alliance with the 'state; Tascism, which becomes serious force in times of crisis when the capitalists can no longer afford to bribe the labour bureaucrats with small concessions, mobilises desperate *little men' to crush the workers' organisations.

If middle class democrats at any time do actually fight against fascism, then course socialists will fight alongside them. So revolutionary socialists fought against Franco in the Spanish Civil War - while at the same time fighting for the workers to take power out of the hands of the liberal-Stalinist Republican government.

But the Second World War wasn't about democracy and fascism.

After Germany was defeated in the First World War, the British, French and US left it ransacked, bled dry, and stripped of its colonies. As a result, capitalism developed in Germany with even more severe crises than elsewhere, which drove the German bourgeoisie first into fascism and then into war, to gain new territories and new markets.

It was joined by Japan, the latest-developing great capitalist power, which wanted to challenge the USEuropean monopoly of colonies and spheres of influence in the Far East.

The biggest imperialist powers, Britain and the USA, were not prepared to let Germany and Japan expand at their expense.

The Second World War was about the rival economic interests of the big international exploiters, not democratic or fascist ideology. Britain went to war to detend the military dictatorship in Poland, not Czech democracy.

Among the Allies were Chiang Kai Shek's China and Vargas Brazil, both extreme right wing regimes. he governments-in-exile supported by the Allies were also often very right wing: for example, the Greeks, the Yugoslavs, and the Poles.

too, was on the supposedly side.

Italian fascism was courted by the British and Americans - "even when the issue of the war became certain" wrote Churchill, "Mussolini would have been welcomed by the Allies" - and the US made agreements with the Petain government and worked with the Petain administration in the French colonies in North Africa.

Desertion

Under the Darlan and Giraud regimes in North Africa, anti-Semitic laws were kept on the books, and (as local US army chiefs complained) "Fascist organisations continued their activities and victimise our former French sympathisers some of whom have not yet yet been released from prison French soldiers [were] being punished for desertion because they tried to support the Allied forces during the landing."

All this time, Britain was maintaining regimes of more or less open racist military dictatorship over hundreds of millions of people in its own colonies.

The Allies denounced the Britain at the Nazis' slaughter of the Jews. Yet they themselves refused to admit Jewish refugees.

The war was not mainly a battle between democratic and fascist powers. The USA kept out of it until Japan attacked its bases in the Pacific in December 1941; both Britain and the USA refused to open a 'Second Front' until June 1944.

Up to 1943 Britain did no more than defend itself against bombing and defend its interests in North Africa and Asia - and watch with secret glee as the German army despoiled and decimated the Soviet Union.

The Nazi forces were sometimes welcomed when they first entered the USSR. Workers, peasants, oppressed nationalities, battered and famished by Stalin's dictatorship, reckoned that the Nazis could not be worse.

The Nazis' wholesale racist massacres of civilians - in the first place Jews, but also others - changed that. The USSR's resistance became bitter and stubborn.

20 million Russians including seven million soldiers - died in the war. American and British casualties were much smaller: 405,000 American and 375,000 British soldiers killed From 1943 it became clear that Germany would lose the war - mainly as a result of the heroic resistance of the people of the USSR. Britain and American became interested in a more aggressive strategy - not so much to defeat fascism, or even to defeat Germany, as to gain themselves a good share of the spoils of victory and suppress the danger of revolutions following on the war.

The first example of this policy was Italy. In July 1943 the Fascist Grand Council and officers led by Marshal Badoglio overthrew Mussolini. Badoglio bargained for terms with both Germany and the Allies. He reached agreement with the Allies, but meanwhile the German army had seized most of Italy.

In the Allied-Badoglio controlled areas, all publications, meetings and political activity were banned. Resistance partisans were disarmed and often imprisoned; the north, where the Resistance was strongest, was left in the hands of the German army.

In Germany, too, after the Anglo-American victory, a fascist government was initially kept in power under Doenitz. The Doenitz government was soon disposed of for the sake of appearances, but 700,000 German troops were kept in military formation by the British for possible use against Russian forces.

In many parts of Germany the British and Americans found that spontaneouslycreated workers' councils had taken over as Hitler's power collapsed. The councils were dissolved, trade union organisations were suppressed, and a total ban was imposed on political activity.

There was the same sort of clash between the Anglo-American armies and working class anti-fascists in Belgium. In November 1944, the Belgian Resistance, defying their Stalinist leaders, refused to obey orders from the occupying forces to hand in their arms. The Resistance leaders re-established their control only after Belgian police, supported by British troops, had shot down demonstrators in the streets of Brussels.

In Italy, too, the working class resistance had been disarmed mainly through the efforts of the Communist Party - whose preaching of *anti-fascist unity" gained weight from the prestige of the USSR. After Italian CP leader Palmiro Togliatti returned to Italy from Moscow in April 1944, the CP gave tuil support to Badoglio and the monarchy.

In Greece, the CP was less directly under Moscow control - and the clash between the armed anti-fascist workers and peasants and the Allied armies reached the point of open war, despite all Stalin's efforts to sabotage the Resistance.

In October 1944, 23,000 British troops entered Greece. They came not to fight the German army, which was rapidly leaving Greece, but to suppress the ELAS Resistance militians which had effective control of the country. The British ordered ELAS to disarm. Under CP influence, ELAS said it would disarm -t only right wing groups, like the 'Mountain Brigade" were also disarmed.

The British were unyielding. In December 1944 they killed 24 and wounded 150 when they shot on a demonstration in Athens protesting against the disarmament order. Open war then broke out.

ELAS asked for a truce -but after it was agreed, in January 1945, the British launched a terror campaign

Scan page 7

against the Left. Resistance tax collectors were charged with looting; Resistance militants who had executed profascists were charged with murder.

Martial law was proclaimed, trade unions were suppressed, 50,000 leftists were imprisoned, and meanwhile pro-fascists were assigned to leading positions.

The result was renewed war.

In France, when the people of Paris launched a general strike and uprising in August 1944 against the German occupation, the Allied armies' main concern was to prevent any revolutionary outcome. The French CP suppressed any revolutionary stirrings by all-out insistence on 'anti-fascist' unity and support for de Gaulle.

Then, in 194/, when under the pressure of a Trotskyist-led strike at Renault and the developing Cold War the CP turned left, de Gaulle, the hero of 'democracy" became the leader of a fascist movement! His 'Rassemblement du Peuple Francais' had 16,000 armed thugs, who made it their business to break up CP and other left wing meetings.

The RPF did not seize power; France did not go fascist. And parliamentary democracies were set up in Germany and Italy. The wartime restrictions on strikes and other democratic rights in Britain and the US were eventually removed - though Order 1305, banning strikes in Britain, was not lifted until 1949, under pressure of a dockers' strike.

But this setback for fascism owed nothing to the democratic good intentions of Churchill, Roosevelt and Truman. Its causes were the partial refusal by the working class to be duped into 'antifascist' or anti-German unity with their bosses - and the economic recovery of capitalism.

No crisis of capitalism is ever 'final': so long as capitalism survives, the crisis will eventually lay the basis for a new boom. The massive destruction and suffering of World War 2 allowed the emergence after it of a restructured world capitalist system which was a framework for renewed expansion.

The US became superdominant. Under the Pax Americana, free trade and free movement of capital was extended. US capital flooded into Western Europe, to fuel (and profit from) a boom there.

New techniques developed during the war were put into production. The driving-down of working class living standards helped the boom.

meet In the 1930s. the world had been divided into rival trading blocs - empires or spheres of influence. The US sought to replace this set-up with a free-trade world under its domination. And in any case - as the British and French ruling classes discovered to their cost - the drive for freedom of the colonial peoples had become too powerful to be suppressed Despite Winston Churchill's vow that he would not preside over the dissolution empires tion the war had been fought did dissolve, over the next 20 or 30 years.

But direct and bloody repression of the workers and the colonial peoples always remained a weapon in their armoury - as the people of Vietnam learned in the course of 30 years attempts to put them down by British, French and then American troops from 1945 to 1975.

The war policy of Britain and the US interacted with that of the conservative bureaucracy in the USSR' For the degenerated workers' state in the USSk, the war was not one of imperialist competition, but of seltdefence against the efforts of the German capitalists to overthrow the nationalised and planned economy and turn the Soviet Union into a new field for their profitgrabbing. The British-USUSSR alliance was held together only by a common interest in preserving the world status quo, Between September 1939 and July 1941 the USSR had allied with Hitler: and Britain and the US, in a different diplomatic reshuffling, would have been quite willing to ally with Hitler against Stalin. In seeking allies, all the powers looked not for democracy but for material advantage.

Dissolved

To reassure his allies, Stalin dissolved the Communist International in 1943 and assured them, repeatedly and sincerely, that he did not seek the overthrow of capitalism outside the USSR.

Stalin provided vital aid to Britain and the US in stifling all social revolutionary movements throughout Europe In return, the Kremlin bureaucracy were allowed to grab new territories, revenues and power in Eastern Europe.

The Stalinists' suppression of democracy and working class organisations in Eastern Europe did not worry Britain and the US. What did worry them was the curbs on capitalist enterprise there.

In Yugoslavia the CP escaped from Moscow control even more than the Greeks had; and by the late 1940s the Russian occupying power found itself forced to destroy capitalism in the other East European states, on pain of seeing them transformed into outposts of US capital. Thus began the Cold War - which led in 1950 to the American invasion of Korea. A great victory for democracy!

Some British socialists still say that it was, for all that, a better outcome than the victory of Hitler would have been.

"British workers would have taken invading England. But they Tories for that;

found most of tr Tories and the officer caste But the victory of Hitler over the Anglo-American armies would not necessarily mean his assured victory over the working class. Hitler was no more able to suppress the laws of class conflict than anyone else, and the more he expanded his conquests, the greater the threat to him became from the real antifascist fighters: the working class resistance movements in the occupied territories.

Armed

British workers would have taken up arms - and rightly so - against a German army invading England. But they would not need to support Churchill and the Tories for that; on the contrary, they would have found most of the Tories and the officer caste collaborating with. the Nazis.

The view that the BritishUS victory was a 'lesser evil" is also narrowly nationalist: it's not at all evident that Britain's defeat would be a worse outcome from the viewpoint of the people of Ireland, India, or the other British colonies, Most fundamentally, though, it is a cravenly servile attitude.

Hitler's regime was more brutal than Roosevelt's. If you can see no options beyond Hitler's domination of the world or Roosevelt's domination of the world, then maybe it makes sense to opt for Roosevelt. But the revolutionary socialists active during the war - the Trotskyists - did see another option: the revolutionary overthrow of all the imperialist robbers.

They fought for the overthrow of Roosevelt by the American workers, of Churchill by the British workers, and of Hitler by the German workers.

They argued that the potentially progressive nationalised property relations in the USSR should be defended - but there too they fought for the overthrow of the established regime and for a workers democracy.

Lesser evils

They pointed out that those who opt for the apparent "lesser evils' within capitalism usually end up enduring not only those 'lesser evils' but also the 'greater evils' - as the French workers suffered first the betrayals of the Popular Front, then the repression of the Nazis and Petain.

The Trotskyists earned themselves the hatred of all the imperialist powers and of the Stalinists too. But they were the only people who fought for a policy which could have saved humanity from the 35 years of wars, poverty for two-thirds of the world, and the threat of nuclear annihilation, which we have faced since then.

Their policy was simple: willingness to join any real fight against reaction, but complete political indepen dence of the working class, and resolute insistence on workers' power as the only way out from the crises of capitalism. It is the same policy as we need against fascism and racism todav.

Catch 22

Joseph Heller's book "Catch 22" describes an American soldier facing his officers:

*These three men who hated him spoke his language and wore his uniform, but he saw their loveless faces set immutably into cramped, mean lines of hostility and understood instantly that nowhere in the world, not in all the fascist tanks or planes or submarines, not in the bunkers behind the machine guns or mortars or behind the blowing flame throwers, not even among all the expert gunners of the crack Hermann Goering Anti-aircraft Division or among the grisly connivers in all the beer halls in Munich and everywhere else, were there men who hated him more."

And that's true for as all. Our 'own' ruling class is our deadly enemy, just as much so as British fascists and more so than fascists of other nationalities. Every form of nationalist poison - including anti-German nationalism masquerading as anti-Nazism -only diverts us from the fight against that class and helps the growth of racism and fascism.

Scan page 8

Socialist Organiser no. 225 April

----- pull-quotes -----

Stalin, Roosevelt and Churchill

together to divide up the world. Yalta 1945.

up arms - and rightly so against a German army

would not need to support Chul chill and the

on the contrary. they would have

collaborating with the Nazis'

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 225

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →