More vicars, less pickets?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
mass picketing in Scotland during the miners' strike?
Why was the Scottish NUM apparently more concerned with vicars and 'public opinion' than with working-class mobilisations? Why did the Scottish NUM publicly denounce calls for a general strike?
The answers to these questions are to be found in the current issue of 'Marxism Today' (monthly magazine of the Eurocommunist wing of the Communist Party), which contains an interview with Scottish NUM vice-president George Bolton.
Bolton is chair of the CP, and, like Scottish NUM president Mick McGahey, he belongs to the CP Eurocommunist faction.
He says that mass pickets were pretty useless. "We hadn't learnt the lesson of Grunwick and how the police have been trained to handle mass picketing... And if you hadn't learned the lesson at Grunwick, the police certainly rammed it home at Warrington with the NGA... with the boot, the baton, with tried mass meetings, rather than mass picketing, we might have got a different result"
The whole argument is equivalent to saying that workers should no longer go on strike because managers have received such in-depth training to cope with industrial conflict. The real answer is not to drop mass pickets, but to organise them better, and to form workers' defence squads to beat off the police.
But Bolton is more impressed by *the importance of the churches... and more generally public opinion... Maybe we were very well intentioned, maybe we were trying to talk to the public, but we were very unsuccessful *They (the NUM) certainly didn't have a strategy for capturing it (public opinion)... Our people on national platforms were not always saying the best thing, or the right thing in the best way.
*I can remember hearing speeches early on saying 'and we will defeat this government' You were causing confusion among the miners themselves The government made it quite clear that it was out to defeat the labour movement - but, according to Bolton, the miners should have played the injured innocent and said they had no intention of defeating the government!
Bolton also attacks the call for a general strike.
*Take Dennis Skinner. He was shouting general strike when his pit, Bolsover, was working. Tony Benn was shouting general strike, and in Derbyshire 80% were working. It's a reflection of a range of thinkThatcherism, and the state of British politics But the miners' strike was not a fight about conditions in the coal industry, but about the fate of the labour movement. It demanded labour-movement-wide action, and that meant a general strike.
Bolton insists on the sacredness of the ballot box, deploring ... all that connotation, of industrial action to defeat the ballot box. In the British condigovernments and local authorities with the ballot box"
But the Tories are not using the ballot box to defeat ratecapped local authorities. And the army officers who considered intervention in the crisis of 1974 — at the heart of which were the miners themselves -were certainly not planning on using the ballot box either. So why should the labour movement be tied down by a limited interpretation (excluding popular resistance) of the limited democracy of the bourgeois parliamentary system?
Bolton concludes with a cryptic comment: "It seems to me you're going back to do a whole number of things - popular fronts revisited indeed"
The popular fronts' in the 1930s were bodies of class collaboration, tying and subordinating labour movement organisations to the organisations and interests of the capitalist class. They led to terrible defeats.
That same popular-front philosophy, guiding the Scottish NUM, helped bring about the defeat of the miners' strike.
The SWP did not have a policy for the labour movement in this confrontation. At best they had a policy for a small minority -join the SWP; if you are a miner, organise more picketing: if you are not a miner, organise collections.
The major turning-point of the strike (in our view) passes almost without comment in the book: the month between the seizure of the South Wales NUM funds and the TUC.
Miners' leaders called for a general strike. Ron Todd of the TGWU mumbled about a big bang'. The NUM put a motion to the TUC for. "industrial action involving all unions"; FTAT called for a one-day general strike. But the TUC leaders escaped without committing themselves solidly at all.
Farcical All this drama passes almost without comment in the book, as if it were all a matter of course. No wonder: at the time the SWP's searching for the "small and concrete" reached almost farcical levels. In response to the seizure of the miners' funds their main proposal was: "The trade union leaders. should now launch a campaign to make sure the two Read firms [small haulage companies which had brought the court casel are com by one million repetitions of the words "rank and file". The only answer is to fight to change the policy, structure and leadership of the unions.
And not just of the unions. For the story of 1972 did not end with the Wilberforce Report. Within two years the wage gains had been etched away and the miners were on strike again They won again. Indeed, they pushed the Heath government into an election that it lost.
The miners routed the Tories. And then, as the fruits of their victory, they got a Labou government which curber wages, executed IMF-imposed cuts, imposed the area incentive schemes on the NUM, preside over rising unemployment and paved the way for Thatcher In 1984-5 there was a large element of victory in defeat; anc in 1972-4 there was a large ele ment of defeat in victory. Ful victory will require not only goo workplace organisation but also better organisation and aware ness on the political front.
That is why the fight inside the Labour Party is so impor tant. By abstaining from tha fight, and by adopting a sort o politics which leaves a grea vacuum between the small and concrete" immediate issues an the ultimate goal of socialism the SWP has given itself tunne vision.
Scan page 10
225 April
----- pull-quotes -----
ing in the movement that's not caught up with. Thatcher and