Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Jobs Keeps the Workinn

Socialist Organiser no. 225, 24 April 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 607 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

on that question, let alone public tion the ballot box is so active in the strike will be drawn towards the Labour Party" (p.249). In these ways militants can be pulled into the bureaucracy and into Parliament.

Therefore a revolutionary party is needed - the SWP. -which will keep militants focused on the "small but concrete issues" Out of the struggle on those issues, some cas, Somehow, will come working the capitalist system.

The book does give a competent narrative. On some points it is very interesting: the description of how the first flying pickets to Notts were organised despite attempts by the Yorkshire leadership to restrain them; of how the Yorkshire leadership, again, dragged its feet over Orgreave; or of how the CP-oriented 'soft left' finished off the strike in February 1985.

But it communicates very little of the living experience of the strike. Page 252 does mention that: "The experience of the strike transformed...men/ and women" - but you would not have guessed that from the previous 251 pages.

When miners are quoted, it is always to discuss the details of WHY i was there so little miners' strike was almost a lost cause - "an extreme example of what we in the SWP have called the 'downturn' of the movement"

In early June, again, they were crying woe. "The chance was lost to rejuvenate a strike which has been drifting towards a 'compromise' settlement"

Then at the end of January 1985 while the majority of miners were still locked in epic battle with the NCB and the government, they ran a twopage feature which assumed the Strike was already lost and asked "who is to blame?"

The book is less than honest about examining such errors, or acknowledging aspects of the struggle which refuted the SWP's stereotype ideas.

It applauds the miners" support committees — "a great movement of solidarity" - but does not mention that the SWP dismissed these committees as "left-wing Oxfam" until October. It mentions the Labour Left's role in that movement, but claims, quite untruly (p.250) that even the 'hard' Labour Left refused to challenge Kinnock or criticise the TUC. It says something basic about the politics of the SWP that it tells downright the horse".

In Notts: "Perhaps if we'd lies to back up its campaign to stop militant miners joining or staying in the Labour Party.

Trying to dissuade miners and activists from joining the Labour Party, the book claims that "even the most radical and militant Labour Party member" believes in the parliamentary road to socialism (untrue: SO supporters and, in fact, many others don't). It also claims that parliamentary activity and workers' struggles cannot be combined.

In fact Marxists ever since Marx, without seeing parliament as the vehicle for socialism, have tried to use the parliamentary platform to assist workers' struggles. Dennis Skinner did it pretty well during the on that question, opinion"

But the SWP's drive to define away everything that falls outside the ambit of what they see as real working class politics -local economic struggle — also affects their assessment of the NUM leadership.

Dennis Skinner argued that a national strike would never have taken off without brave and competent leadership from the national NUM officials. Probably he was right. Callinicos and Simons, while devoting most space to mostly justified) criticisms of the NUM area officials, pay tribute to Arthur Scargill' "determination, courage and tactical skill"

But here there is a problem for the SWP. If Arthur Scargill had been a member of the SWP. then they would have withdrawn tion the ballot box is so important... You elect or defeat the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 225

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →