Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Fight to Save Jobs

Socialist Organiser no. 225, 24 April 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 501 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

in 1972. This time, however, the ruling class won", The miners slogged on for another nine months, but eventually they crumbled.

All is not lost, however. Trade union strength can be rebuilt as one small but concrete issues"" as militants concentrate The problem is "the belief of militant trade unionists that by electing left-wing officials they can avoid future betrayals" (p.241) and that "many of those munities are quoted very sparsely; in fact, apart from one sentence in the introduction, the role of women in the struggle is not mentioned at all outside 4 sketchy pages (pp.178-83).

The notion that real working class politics is about fighting hard at workplace level on small issues had possessed the swE before the strike, and it made them unable to assess it or appreciate it properly.

By early April 1984 Socialist Worker was saying that the him from the election for NUM president! (The last time they had anyone put up for a national union position - in USDAW a few years ago — they withdrew him after he got the Broad Left nomination, on the grounds that rank and file activity was not sufficient to justity running tor positions).

Yet Scargill's leadership did make a difference. More and better Scargills in the TUC leadership, or even just in the NUM leadership, could have made the difference between defeat and victory.

Despite the SWP's philosophy about this being an epoch of "building sectional strength" on "small but concrete issues" the miners. strike was a general class confrontation on a big and fairly abstract issue - jobs, communities, livelihoods versus capitalist economics. ted in the 1920s.

Chris Harman summed up the whole philosophy in Socialist Worker last November, arguing against the call for a general strike.

"We have at this point stress demands that enable the militant minority to win over the majority in the workplaces to active solidarity (for example, support committees, collections, twinning), rather than those which assume the base already exists for such solidarity (for strikes). Calls example for general Calls for a general strike like contests for union leadership, like parliamentary activity. like Labour Party activity in general - are presented as alternatives to nuts-and-bolts workplace activity, rather than complementary to it and the means of generalising. integrating and developing workplace activity into working class politics. And the result is to eave the SWP without general political answers (except - very ike Militant, in fact - on the most abstract level of the need for socialist revolution).

Time and again Callinicos and Simons say that the mistake in 1984-5 was not to adopt the rank-and-file-based tactics of 1972. But this is at best quartertue.

More centralised organisation was imposed on the miners by the facts of the situation: the length of the strike, the scale of the police operation, the depressing effect of the slump on solidarity. The same facts imposed on the miners a greater need for official support from other Rank and file Those facts cannot be evaded

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 225

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →