Popular fronts
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-04-24Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
A letter. Transcribed from the scan (5 Nov 2026); the machine reading had run it into Like NF?. "Neither centrism or left" as printed.
Proofed text: read against the scan word by word; spelling, punctuation and wording are as printed.
Scan page 4
THE article "Should we 'celebrate' Popular Fronts?" in Socialist Organiser, April 3, gives the impression, without saying so precisely, that Andres Nin was pursuing a correct policy over popular fronts. And it talks about what "the left" were in favour of without making a clear distinction between what left reformists and centrists on the one hand and Trotskyists on the other advocated.
Trotsky's writings on Spain in "The Spanish Revolution 1931-9" (Pathfinder, 1973) deserve close study on these questions.
For instance Trotsky observes (p.351): "In the heat of revolutionary war between the classes Nin entered a bourgeois government [in 1936] whose goal it was to destroy the workers' committees, the foundation of proletarian government. When this goal was reached, Nin was driven out of the bourgeois government. Instead of recognising after this the colossal error committed, Nin's party [the POUM] demanded the reestablishment of the coalition with the bourgeoisie."
And (p.346): "If the POUM had not marched at the heels of the Anarchists and had not fraternised with the 'Popular Front', if it had conducted an intransigent revolutionary policy, then, at the moment of the May 1937 insurrection and most likely much sooner, it would naturally have found itself at the head of the masses and would have assured the victory. The POUM was not a revolutionary party but a centrist party..."
Neither centrism or left reformism can assure victory: on the contrary they hinder its attainment. It is essential to build a revolutionary, a Trotskyist party.