Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Regrouping the left?

Socialist Organiser no. 226, 1 May 1985 · scan p. 3 · about 1,285 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 3 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 3

Two jailed miners are released: Garry Hopper (right) is greeted by his father, and Dave Richardson (right) by his brother. But between 150 and 200 miners are still in jail. Photo: John Harris;

ydeside anarchists tried in Argentina for his part in Galtieri's 'anti-imperialism'. In civilian gover wingers and trade unionists that Argentina has long been a Isn't there powerful sub-imperialist power "bending und council was, of course, the military dic- multinationals, and in South America - with its own imperialist ar tator who invaded the Falklands imperial ambitions. in 1982. Thev forgot that the Arsen- Arpentine lea IN 1983, soon after the Tories' general election victory, Ken Livingstone spoke at a meeting called to discuss the election results.

Decrying the defeatist notion that the Thatcherites were an irresistible new force, he argued that the real new force in British politics was the radical Labour Left.

Less than two years later that Left is disintegrating in a spectacular way.

Ken Livingstone has ratted on the fight against rate-caping and made his peace with Kinnock. This week Neil Kinnock welcomed Livingstone's selection as Labour candidate for Brent East.

Today Ken Livingstone aligns himself with the same sort of ideas - presented by "Marxism Today' - as he attacked in 1983. He, and many others, present the division as between a new politics of 'broad alliances' and outdated "fundamentalism', In truth there is nothing new about the policy of broad alliances' and popular tronts.

The serious Left needs to get its own picture of the divisions, and dig down to the roots of failures like the GLC debacle and the labour movement's inadequate solidarity with the miners.

Three weeks ago Labour Herald published an appeal for left regroupment. It was signed by Lambeth council leader Ted Knight, by John McDonnell, and by Matthew Warburton, Labour Herald was started by Knight in collaboration with Livingstone, and now expresses Knight's views., Many things said in the article are true and important: but it calls for the Left to unite around Labour Herald Labour Briefing has replied, rightly:

*We strongly agree with this sentiment and the call for left unity. We feel however that it would be wrong for any one group or campaign to pretend that it alone can be the sole vehicle for such unity.

We are therefore calling on all socialist groups and currents within the left wing of the party to meet to discuss how to work together over the coming period. We would ask all those organisations... to bring proposals for action?

Labour Herald is particularly unsuitable as an axis for the left to unite around, as it has no democratic structure. The lavish 16-page weekly exists without any visible network of organised support, apparently thanks to favourable arrangements with the WRP printworks, where it is produced.

Moreover, Ted Knight is not the best person to analyse the roots of the GLC's collapse.

Today he talks of absolute defiance' in Lambeth. Yet he knows that there is practically no chance that his Labour group will hold its slim majority when it comes to the crunch.

As early as 1979 he proposed cuts in Lambeth, and since then he has implementhem.

The publicity campaign against rate-capping displaying portraits of Ted Heath and Francis Pym, in best Marxism Today popularfront style - bore the signatture of Lambeth as well as the GLC.

In fact the GLC fiasco nad been prepared for over four years by the way that the local government left After a three-day trial, eleven Clydeside Anarchists have been found guilty of breach of the peace and malicious damage to property, for their occupation of the offices of Price Waterhouse in Glasgow — after the firm had taken charge of the sequestration of the South Wales NUM funds during the miners' strike.

Save one, who was already remanded in prison, the anarchists were freed on bail pending social work reports. They reGeneral Galtieri is now being General Galtieri is now being tried in Argentina for his part the great massacre of left-wingers and trade unionists during the military regime. during the military regime.

General Leopoldo Galtieri General Leopoldo Galtieri was, of course, the military dictator who invaded the Falklands in 1982 Galtieri was hailed by large sections of the British and international left in 1982 as a fighter against imperialism. Some erstwhile supporters of Socialist Organiser (who now produce *Socialist Viewpoint') said that military-ruled Argentina had, under Galtieri's leadership, Knight as well as Livingstone - reacted to the Tory offensive.

Labour Herald and Briefing, too - have tor years pushed ideas and strategies which paved the way for the collapse.

The Labour new. left' took control of a number of Town and County Halls just before or during the high tide of Thatcherism. They had a choice: to be fighters, or administrators.

They tried to evade the choice and buy time' with rate rises. This was wrong and utterly short-sighted. appear in court in May for sentencing, and face the threat of priste anarenists, occupation of the Price Waterhouse offices was an act of solidarity with the miners. The case is therefore obviously political. But the Glas gow labour movement has failed to take up the issue, and for two reasons.

One is sectarian prejudice rowards the anarchists and their activities. While the anarchists"

ardent in their support for ardent in their support for Galtieri's 'anti-imperialism'. their enthusiasm they forgot their enthusiasm they forgot that Argentina has long been a powerful sub-imperialist power in South America — with its owi multinationals, and imperial ambitions.

They forgot that the Argentine military had been the major force behind the Bolivian military coup of 1980, and that Argentine troops were in El Salvador, supporting the government.

In their enthusiasm, Socialist Action published excerpts from the speech of Argentine foreign Rate rises cut into working class living standards. As time was "bought', and a confrontation with the Tories was postponed again and again. the rate rises also demobilised the local community.

The miners' strike showed that the trade unions should have mobilised and fought back against the Tories in 1980, before the slump and unemployment had bitten so deep into the labour movement. The same is true of the local government left.

Right from the beginning they should have conducted themselves as people determined to fight, doing every: ining to prepare tor controntation. Instead they fantasised about their local 'power" they manoeuvred, and... they. ran before the Tories.

The open collapse of the GLC was the culmination of the whole strategy of the local government left over five or six years.

The Left does need to regroup, to pick up the pieces and draw out the lessons of this experience. First of all, and most important, we need a full and open discussion not just on the personal fate of Ken Livingstone, but the whole record of the local government Left, At the same time we need the greatest unity of action on specific issues wherever it is possible. sometimes outlandish and inaccurate attacks on the Labour Party and unions might account for this, it certainly does not justify it.

Another is the failure of the NUM in Scotland to campaign about the class "justice' inflicted on sacked and jailed miners. It has not even publicised the fact that a Solsgirth miner is now serving a four-month prison sentence. the left's solidarity against the the left's soli civilian government as he was to their support against Britain. their support Isn't there an element of "bending under the pressure of imperialist and bourgeois public opinion' , comrades, in your tall- opinion', com ure to speak up for the one ure to speak t Argentine leader prepared to "fight imperialism'?

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 226

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →