The future ofthe eft
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 4
In the aftermath of the miners' strike, a new centre-left is regrouping in the Labour Party. Groups like the Labour Coordinating Committee, and figures like Ken Livingstone, Frances Morrell, Michael Meacher and Tom Sawyer, have cut loose from the class struggle left and John McDonnell led the fight on the GLC for the London Labour Party's 'no rate" policy and for his pair has been dumped from his position as deputy leader of the council. He talked to John Bloxam about the prospects for regrouping the Left. The second part of the interview (next week) discusses the call for regroupment made by Lambeth council leader Ted Knight's 'LabourHerald, with which McDonnell has associated himself.
John McDonnell: 'discard those elements who are reformist! innock: 'convinced socialism won't win a majority : Photo: John Harris. There have been a number of articles in the Left press recently - one in Labour Herald which you put your name to, calling for a realignment of the Left, and others in Marxism Today and New Socialist. Is there a realignment taking place on the Left? How do you see it?
It has come about because of the miners' struggle and the ratecapping struggle. These struggles have brought the class struggle to a pitch of intensity where the labour movement has divided on traditional, historic lines between those who are genuinely revolutionary and those who are reformist.
What has happened in the Labour Party is a triple process. First of all the attempt by Kinnock and Hattersley to introduce a whole series of policy statements prior to conference, jobs and industry, education, social security, to bounce the Party into basically social democratic policies, take the Party back down the road of Wilson and Callaghan and into social democracy.
The second part of that process has been the launch of the Employment Institute which is an attempt to establish some form of pact or coalition if the Labour Party does not have an overall majority at the next general election. It looks like Kinnock has been reading Hobsbawm and has been completely convinced that straightforward, firm socialism won't obtain an overall majority, and therefore he will have to do deals with the SDP, the Liberals and the Tory "wets"
In addition to this there is a third process which is an attempt by the right wing at national level to embrace the soft left and centre elements that came into an alliance on the broad left around the struggle over the programme for the 1983 election and around Benn's deputy leadership campaign.
In the struggle around the miners and rate-capping, that soft left element has peeled off because they couldn't face up to the threats that were coming from the central capitalist state, and they have been embraced warmly now by the centre-right coalition, based around Kinnock and Hattersley.
Every excuse has been dragged out for that reneging on Party policy and betrayal of the struggle - that they were unsure of the ground, or that they thought it would be better to fall back on some accommodation with particular reforms, rather than the prospect of a heavy defeat, and in recent articles y Livingstone in Marxism Today and Morrell in New Statesman, the spurious attempt to take on board some of the best develonments in the left over recer like the mass participatory struggle that has been developing round ratecapping and the miners' strike, and seeking to use and abuse the trend of feminism that has been developed by socialists and try to isolate and marginalise those comrades on left who have stood firm. moved towards Kinnock.
That is the triple process that has been going on and what is needed now is for those comrades who are clearly of the Left and who have stood firm throughout those struggles to come together and regroup and develop first of all a clear programme of policies and ideology that can be seen quite clearly to be socialist and that people can associate themselves with.
It is also necessary to develop an organisational forum in which those policies can be discussed and in which we can agree on tactical interventions in immediate struggles, particularly the range of industrial disputes that are going to occur. Livingrtone in his Marxism Today article describes the split in the left as being between the vanguardists, the McDonnellites, the Tankies [hard-line Stalinists] on the one side and the Euro-communists, the participatory left, the soft left, presumdemoralised and undermined by those people who have supported setting a rate, although those workers are now coming back to organise against cuts in jobs and services that might be brought about by the cuts budget that has gone through.
The soft left say that the tide is turning their way. They cite for example the re-selection process in which very few people have been de-selected and argue that in general people are following them. Do you think that those wishing to stand firm are now in a much weaker position?
ably the Livingstoneites, on the categorised as between revolutionary other. How useful do you think that and reformist. It is the same division categorisation is? that occurred in the German Social It is an attempt to categorise Democracy at the turn of the centhose people who stood firm in the tury. It is the same division that struggles both on the miners and on occurred in the Labour Party in the rate-capping in a way which deni- 1920s and again in the 1950s. It is grates them. It has been the organis- between those people who genuineation around the miners' struggle ly want to bring about a revolutionthrough the leadership of Scargill and ary transformation in our communothers who have stood firm. It's an ity and those people who are willing attempt to disassociate the left from to accommodate to certain reforms the developments they have aroused which may ameliorate the condition within the movement because the of the working class in the short term mass participatory struggle has gone but in the long term result in the on through the miners and rate- return of an economic crisis and cuts. capping and have been developed in şervices and the undermining and by the leadership of those people who stood firm throughout. ing people have struggled for, and Far from consolidating that mass also results in a demoralisation and participation, the people who have a destruction of credibility of the capitulated both in the miners' struggle and the rate-capping, have bring together those people who brought about a demoralisation which is undermining that mass are genuinely revolutionary, discard The best example of that is the who because of their firm allianc GLC where for the first time in with Kinnock, Hattersley and th London we have had a rank and file right wing are clearly protecting th trade union action through the right.
Democracy for London campaign It is true that in the reselectio and London Bridge who were organ- process we are not getting th ised to take industrial action once we changes that will be sending revol refused to set a rate and any jobs utionary socialists to Parliament. bu were threatened That has been that is only a short-term gain, The reformists are making th same basic failure in analysis tha Kinnock did. Kinnock sees the objec tive of gaining office as everything rather than gaining power. Reform The division needs to be clearly destruction of basic rights that workWhat we are seeking to do is to Wingstone: "capitulated in rate-ca ping
Scan page 5
YOU MAY 226.
----- pull-quotes -----
those elements that are reformist participatory struggle,