Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Embryo research

Socialist Organiser no. 226, 1 May 1985 · scan p. 6 · about 1,500 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

A recent announcement from medical researchers tells of a welcome breakthrough in detecting inherited diseases in human embryos.

Hitherto, a technique called amniocentesis has been available for detecting a few diseases such as spina bifida and Down's Syndrome, but only at 18-20 weeks of pregnancy, when abortion may be more traumatic.

Now, a new technique known as chorionic villus sampling (CVS) is being introduced. This can be used at only 8-10 weeks of pregnancy, when the embryo is only some 2 cm long.

It involves inserting a thin plastic tube through the neck of the womb and taking a sample of cells from the chorionic villi, while guided by ultra-sound scanners. The samples are then screened with "genetic probes" - biochemicals which "recog nise" faulty genes and stick to them, alerting researchers to their presence.

The CV are finger-like extensions of the placenta that stick into the side of the womb. They allow food, oxygen and wastes to pass between mother and embryo. The CV actually originate from the fertilised eggs and have identical genes to the embryo.

CVS is already being used to detect the inherited blood diseases thalassaemia and sickle cell anaemia. it has recently been used to detect haemophilia and should soon be able to detect such fatal ailments as cystic fibrosis (the most common genetic disease in Britain) and Huntington's chorea, a degenerative brain disease that strikes in middle-age, usually after the victim has had children who may harbour the faulty gene themselves.

CVS unfortunately carries a 3% risk of causing a spontaneous miscarriage so would not be used for routine screening. However, when a serious genetic disease is likely, the risk will often be thought worthwhile, since otherwise carriers of such diseases will often deny themselves children to avoid passing on such genes.

Some 6000 babies with severe genetic handicaps are born each vear and 40% of all childhood deaths occur in this group. A great number of children's hospital beds are occupied by such cases. Anything that can he p to lessen this human tragedy is a great boon.

The Guardian reported last week that the Animal Liberation Front had taken 200 mice from St. George's Hospital, Tooting, as a protest over the conditions in which animals for experiments are kept. The Guardian's statement that the mice were from the Pubic Health Laboratory (rather than Public) made the story somewhat more ludicrous than it might otherwise have been — a case of pubic mice, perhaps?

In fact, the mice are used in tests for toxoplasmosis parasite. This frequently intects cats and humans (especially children) can pick it up through contamination with cat shit.

Inside the body, the parasite multiplies until attacked by the immune system when it forms cysts. These contain hundreds of cells, shielded from attack.

When cysts break open, a hypersensitivity reaction occurs, and the surrounding tissues get inflamed. If the cysts are lodged in the retina, this can cause blindness.

Since the liberated mice are infected with toxoplasmosis, any kindhearted ALF supporter harbouring them risks infection.

These mice are obviously being used only to alleviate human suffering and in fact the Public Health Lab says they are on the verge of replacing the test mice with cell cultures.

These several facts seem to make the ALF action a bit of an "own goal" , but perhaps the movement for animal rights is still performing a valuable function in forcing experimenters to justify their actions, and in encouraging development of methods that do no involve animals and may actually be more reliable).

THE SPRING issue of*New Ground, the quarterly magazine of the Socialist Environment and Resources Association, is just out, price 60p, and it contains several articles of interest to SO readers.

The major theme is that of the chemical industry and the pollution, poisoning and disasters it causes. THE Provisional IRA appears to be on the verge of a split that could change the political landscape of Northern Ireland.

Reports in the Sunday Times and the Irish Times add up to à picture of an organisation whose internal contradictions are close to explosion point.

Four leading activists in Belfast, two of them former Belfast commanders, have been expelled by a narrow vote of the IRA's eight man Executive. The central figure in the grouping is Ivor Bell who was expelled because he expressed "no confidence" in the leadership around West. Belfast MP Gerry Adams and because he was agitating for an IRA Army Convention to meet and reassess Adams" "electoral strategy"

The dissidents have been threatened with death if they continue agitating. if they form a new movement or if they join the rival Irish National Liberation Army But they are far from isolated, having a strong following in the ranks of the IRA.

They continue to agitate and to organise. Significantly they are allied with former IRA chief of staff David O'Connell and other veterans like Joe Cahill, Seamus Twomey and Jimmy Drumm, who founded the Provisional IRA in 1969/70 but have been ousted or pushed aside in the last three or four years.

The political dispute appears to be about the same issue that split the Republican movement in 1969/70: legal political activity versus the gun and guerrilla warfare. There may also be underlying Left versus Right tensions and the old leadership was bitterly opposed to the dropping of the proposal for a federal united Ireland from Sinn Fein's Constitution.

Dissidents The dissidents are not against politics' but they want politics subor testifies that it cannot work like that for long.

You cannot for any length of time keep conventional legal, electoral activity in balance with a serious military campaign. One activity must dominate and reduce the other to its auxiliary There are hard choices to be made about which activity scarce money goes to. There are also inevitable conflicts over the allocation of people and over how to integrate and interrelate the very different types of organisation needed for electoral activity on the one hand and for guerilla warfare by an underground army on the other.

The traditional Republican rule is that the military wing dominates completely. But what happens when the political side of the movement expands and the military struggle has for a dozen years been in stalemate, occasionally lit up (but not basically shifted) by spectacular coups? turn is encouraged by success, as Sinn Fein's political turn has been since the hunger strikes of 1981, the balance inevitably shifts against the military faction.

Compromise becomes difficult because the political opportunities imperatively demand commitment from the whole movement for their realisation; money must be found Or redirected.

If you take the political movement seriousiy, you must devote the necessary resources to it, restrain the militarists and make sure they don't do politically embarrassing things at delicate moments.

The militarists are subiect to the heavy repression of the state, unlike the politicians. and this further tips the balance in favour of 'politics'.

The military people may have gone along with the 'political' turn, as some of the dissidents did, placated by the promise that the hand that would be free from the ballot box would continue to hold a rifle. But now they realise that the balance has shifted, threatening to turn quent breakaway, INLA.

The reported - narrowness of the vote for expulsion on the IRA Executive combined with the leadership's apparent fear to call an IRA Convention (though considerations of security must weigh with them here suggest that the conflicting groups are pretty evenly balanced.

Reports say that two of the old leaders, one of them David O'Connell, have been taken back on to the army council. Two of the Belfast expelled are appealing against expulsion. There is a ferment of discussion in the ranks.

Highly significant for the likely course of events is that the dissidents now accuse the leadership of informing on them to the RUC and the British Army. This doesn't look like a dispute that will be resolved by votes and formal majorities.

A split will render both the militarists and the politicos much less effective. The militarists could probably step up the military campaign but they cannot possibly break the military stalemate. In the short term, Adams" politicos would probably lose most in a split, especially since it is unlikely to be a peaceful split.

A very important question is how would the political faction develop politically after the split?

Officials In the last 60 years a number of Irish' nationalist political formations including De Valera's Fianna Fail, the main party of the Irish bourgeoisie for the last half century, have gone into politics having broken with the physical force dogma - and quickly ceased to be any sort of revolutionaries. It is improbable that the Adams faction will simply follow in the footprints of the last group of Republicans to do this, the Officials.

But it is surely not ruled out that once the Adams group were freed from the

----- pull-quotes -----

SINN PRAI By John O'Mahony

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 226

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →