Socialist FORUM
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-05-01Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
50p Number 2 March/April 1985 Ireland from Editorial: Dialogue yes.
ventriloquism no!
Militant's record on Ireland...
• and ours James Connolly For a federal united Ireland!
16 years of conflict 14 Sickert Court, London dinated to the military acti ities, and designed only to serve and boost the military campaign not to replace it or marginalise it.
They charge that the Adams leadership has downgraded the military side of the movement and that legal political activity has become their central concern. They say this devours too much money and other resources and that the military campaign is subordinated and increasingly sacrificed to The leadership say they want both politics and the gun, in roughly the present balance.
On one level it is a straight forward struggle over the allocation of scarce resources, of the sort most organisations experience in one form or another. But it goes deeper than that, to the root contradiction in the strategy of the Adams leadership.
Their idea that the Republican movement could develop "with an Armalite in one hand and a ballot paper in the other" is fundamentally mistaken., The entire history of the Republican movement The different activities may flatly contradict each other. Will this or that military action help or hinder the political wing of the movement at this time. If it hinders it, which is more important?
While the •organisation only dabbles in politics as an auxiliary activity to drum up support for the army, then a sort of balance is kept and everything seems clear. The military struggle remains central.
Traditional republicanism has been distinguished making physical force, in all conditions where the movement is strong enough to wage it, a matter of principle, and a dogma that can't be questioned without splits, expulsions and, sometimes, mutual slaughter.
It is a hierarchical movement with control of everything that matters in the hands of the military leadership and the political movement no more than their front.
A radically increased emphasis on legal polities inevitably disrupts this system. When the political the 'armed struggle into a mere auxiliary of politics. The movement is being stood on its head.
They begin to resist, to pull for resources, to refuse to subordinate to politics (one of the pelled dissidents is said to have had an alleged petty crook, Jimmy Campbell, murdered in a West Belfast club last year so as to embarrass Sinn Fein's local election campaign.
Sinn Fein's turn to politics would have been impossible without the full agreement of the military leadership. It can only be maintained when tensions develop if the politicos keep control of the IRA Army Council. Controlling the Council, they can submit dissidents to the IRA's harsh military discipline, whose sanctions include death.
There is little ground between submission (or going into inactivity) and all-out opposition. Serious opposition is only possible as open gun warfare of the sort that erupted when the Provos were horn in the split off from the Official IRA at the beginning of the 1970s and at various times since in the Official IRA and its subseiron matrix of physicalforce-on-principle they would, if they continued to dispose of a sizeable chunk of the Catholic vote, get drawn into SDLP-type manoeuvrings within the 6 County State.
The level of Provo socialism has been grossly exaggerated and misrepresented on the British left by the mindless enthusiasm of journals like Socialist Action and Brieting. But many Provos are socialists in a general way and they can develop towards working class socialism as they try to come to terms with the Provo experience.
The worst consequence of a Provo split would most likely be to take the pressure off Britain and the 26 County government to go on seeking dialogue and discussion about a solution to the Northern Ireland conflict. Provo militarism has often been counterproductive. But the existence of this powerful and growing movement has exerted a tremendous pressure on the British and Irish governments to seek a political solution.
Reduce that pressure and they will find the status quo livable again.
Scan page 7
Socialist Organiser no. 226. May 1 1985 Page 7 GERRY BYRNE'S
----- pull-quotes -----
Why Militant and MIRSP are twins