Lesbian, gay model motion
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-05-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
From the Labour Campaign for Lesbian and Gay 50p Number 2 March/April 1985 AFTER THE experience of last year's Labour party conference, where a vote for a debate on lesbian and gay rights was almost won, with the support of most Constituency Labour Parties and the of the NUM, the Labour Campaign for Gay Rights decided to make campaigning for a debate at this year's conference its number one priorityThe party's existing policy is inadequate — two lines in the 1983 party manifesto — and discriminatory, particularly over the male gay age of consent, and has no specific reference to lesbians. In particular it contains no pledge to defend the rights of lesbian mothers to keep their children in custody cases.
Since there has never been a debate at the conference, and because the last year has been such a momentous year for the lesbian and gay movements -with the threat of AIDS and related hysteria, the victory at Rugby and most of all the massive success of Lesbians Against Pit Closures and Lesbians and Gays Support the Miners - LCGR is not just asking that the left of the party makes its resolutions a priority this year, but is demanding that it does.
Rights We are also asking 'straight" party members to stand aside and let lesbians and gays through to be delegates to this year's conference. We are fed up with heterosexuals pretending that they can speak on our behalf and understand our oppression.
The model resolution reads as follows:
*This conference opposes all discrimination on the grounds of sexuality and notes that existing Labour Party policy with regard to lesbians and gays fails to meet the legitimate demands of lesbians and gays, and that a consistent and principled campaign conducted over a number of years is necessary to reverse that failure.
Conference welcomes the pro gress made by some Labour authorities and looks for an end to the institutionalised oppression oflesbians and gays. It therefore:
a. Instructs the NEC to draw up a lesbian and gay rights bill, which should specifically:
i. declare that lesbian and ga acts and relationships are not contrary policy the law, ii. prohibit discrimination by the courts against lesbians and gays in child custody and in unfair dismissal on grounds in any way connected with sexuality or lifestyle, lili. abolish criminal laws that discrimination against lesbians and gays, iv. make discrimination on grounds of sexuality an actionLabour Campaign for Gay Rights able civil offence and invalidate all discriminatory regulations and by-laws, v. prevent police harassment and discrimination against lesbians and gays, and calls on the PLP to introduce such a bill and support bills to reform the law in this direction with a three-line whip -b. Calls upon all Labour loc authorities, district and county Labour Parties to adopt practic es and policy to prevent discrimination against lesbians and gays, and in particular to:
i. adopt and enforce equal opportunities policies in regard to sexual orientation along the lines of Islington, il. end discrimination against single people and lesbians and gays in housing policies, iii. provide funds for lesbian and gay switchboards and centres, Iv. publicise the antı-discriminatory policies listed above.
c. Instructs the NEC to: i. organise a campaign of education among the membership of the party on the oppression of lesbians and gay in conjunction with the Labour Campaign for Gay Rights, ii. place adverts in the lesbian and gay media and produce leat lets using the slogan, "The Labour Party supports lesbian and gay rights — join the Labour Party'.
d. Instructs the NEC to set up a sub-committee in collaboratiot with the Labour Campaign for Gay Rights to organise the implementation of this policy"
Please modify the wording slightly, since resolutions from different CLPs count as one if the wording is identical. from Why Militant and IRSP are twins Editorial: Dialogue yes.
ventriloquism no!
Militant's record on Ireland...
.. and ours James Connolly For a federal united Ireland!
16 years of conflict 14 Sickert Court, London N1:
Scan page 6
TeLL N6H1 Every big working-class defeat strengthens the right wing of is now treated with respect by sections of the broad Labour the labour movement. When a great and heroic effort like the left, especially those who are now shifting dramatically to the miners have just made fails and is beaten back, then the faint- right. And Labour Party leader Neil Kinnock has described the hearts and defeatists say it was all that could be expected. guru of this current of opinion in the labour movement, Eric Frontal assaults and class-struggle methods are foolish - or anyway now outmoded and destructive of the multi-class Those whose trademark is their lack of courage and fatalism War veteran with 50 years in the CP, has for the last seven suddenly gain both courage and a voice as the movement tries years systematically argued for a sharp rightwards turn by the labour movement. Basing himself also on the experience of the to draw the lessons of the defeat. The hard right wing seizes Italian Communist Party - which is to the right of Roy Hatthe chance to pour scorn on social'sm and the class struggle.
They are aided, wittingly or unwittingly, by the sceptics, those and perhaps with some Tories - an 'anti-Thatcher coalition". tersley in day-to-day politics - he wants alliances with the SDF who reain nominally socialists but have had their faith in working-class socialism eaten away by the years and by disilmade rationalisations for newly-softened-up ex-hard-leftists important series of articles on Hobsbawm's politics written for Popular Front - the cross-class alliances of the '30s and '40s On June 9 1983 Labour suffered its worst electoral defeat for half a century.
Not surprisingly, it has provoked thought and debate. The most influential and wide-reaching discussion of the future of the labour movement has been generated by the writings of Eric Hobsbawm. His article, 'The Forward March of Labour Halted', was first published in 'Marxism Today' in September 1978.
The response and Hobsbawm's replies developed into a book of the same title published in 1981. The debate, initially stimulated by the failure of the Labour government's social contract, has intensified with the success of Thatcherism, with a further series of articles, most notably in 'Marxism Today', the "Guardian' ', and 'New Socialist".
While the discussion has increasingly focussed on the way forward for the Labour Party, the political positions proferred by Hobsbawm are only intelligible in terms of his lifelong membership of the Communist Party. Yet in the past years Hobsbawm's views have become increasingly influential amongst sections of the Labour Party, including sections of the left. At the 1982 Labour Party Conference, Neil Kinnock under pressure from the left pleaded Hobsbawm in his defence as "the most sagacious living Marxist"
The response from Labour's hard left has been all too often healthy but largely unthought through and unargued. Tony Benn commented......... **The truth is, -whe (Hobsbawm] is a member of a party, the Communist Party, that puts up candidates against the Labour Party. He's covering a shift from the left to the right... all this analysis of a fundamental change which means that everything is different is designed to demoralise and This — characteristically — is instinctively correct. Hobsbawm's intention is specif. ically to demoralise and defeat the Bennite left. His attacks are aimed at those he denounces as "sectarian radicals"
Hobsbawm's objective is to isolate Bennism in the interests of firstly, the stable reconstruction of Labour's internal coalition as represented by Kinnock, Healey and Hattersley, and secondly, the creation of a wider coalition with the SDP-Liberal Party Alliance.
But it is not enough to say that. We need a closer examination. Hobsbawm's analysis is one-sided and incorrect. His solutions to Labour's crisis would -e disastrous and terminal. It is therefore essential that we look at his ideas and arguments in detail. The fullest understanding is necessary if we are to proscribe effective antidotes.
Muddle
This is a difficult task as Hobsbawm's arguments are at times muddled and contradictory. To some degree this is a function of his method and politics. To some extent it is unavoidable in a discussion stretching over four years taking on board new events, issues and emphases.
The Hobsbawm of 1978 is less pessimistic than the Hobsbawm of 1984. His specific prescriptions only appear as the discussion advances. Nonetheless, his case consists of a central assertion and a central solution. His fundamental argument is that the crisis. of the labour movement represents a decline in class consciousness resulting from changes in the class structure and growing affluence.
Spot the ball.... Photo: Marxism Today alliances we need to forge against the Tories.
lusionment with Stalinism.
And so the nostalgic yearning of some old Pers for the **The manual working class core of traditional socialist Labour parties is today contracting not expanding. It has been transformed to some extent, divided by the decades when its standard of living reached levels undreamed of even by the well paid in 1939. It can no longer be assumed that all workers are on the way to recognising that their class situation must align them behind a socialist workers' party although there are still many millions who believe this" The erosion of the solidaristic nexus linking workers with the institutions of the labour movement can be seen from Hobsbawm's indices of class consciousness. A decline in the Labour vote - its political expression - at successive elections is complemented by a decline in attachment to trade unionism - its most elementary index. "Union density is now (1978) only a little higher than in 1948...Britain the home of mass trade unionism has clearly fallen behind some other countries. there is not much doubt that sectionalism is on the increase...
Sometime in the late forties/early fifties, the Forward March of Labour was halted. By 1979 it had indubitably turned into a Socialist Organiser by John Mcllroy.
retreat and by June 1983 a disorderly rout. Labour's lost millions signal a crisis so deep that for Hobsbawm "critics are right in pointing out that the views expressed about Labour's future prospects by me and others in Marxism Today are in a way an up to date version of the Popular Front." For Hobsbawm, the Popular Front is not some necessary but unsavoury expedient. It is part of a coherent strategy. He does not "even see the broad anti-Thatcherite front which is surely quite essential today as a mere defence against encroaching reaction. It is that, certainly, but the history of the antifascist struggles show that those purely defensive struggles were the foundation of major advances of the left not least in Britain. Thatcherism Thatcherism is such a serious threat, Fobsbawm believes, as to deserve the same kind of response as Fascism in the '30s. (Thatcherism moved over the Falklands in 1 hesitate, but only just, to say a semi-Fascist Hobsbawm, as the "most sagacious of living Marxists" The respected historian Eric Hobsbawm, a Spanish Civil Hobsbawm's writings are important, and serve as readylike Ken Livingstone. This week we print the first of an means are put forward for constructing this "broad anti-Thateherite front" right now, though it does dictate a maintenance of the status que in the Labour Party and he insists that giving this 'front' organisational embodiment is a second worst outcome to Labour's presently constituted coalition winning in 1988. "Essentially an accommodation may well have to be found with the SDP/Liberal Alliance. If, at the next election, Thatcherism is everywhere opposed by two or more candidates competing for each other's votes, the Tories can look forward to being in power well into the 1990s. Some way of uniting the majority of the British people which is opposed to Thatcherism must be found"
Despite his assurances, the brunt of his argument is that accommodation with the Alliance is the way forward and that his analysis, and the agenda of practical Parliamentary politics, dictate that "the issue of electoral unity will have to be faced"
So much for the main thrust of Hobsbawm's argument! Let us look at its detail.
There is little new in E ment about the alleged se ing class attitudes to unio Party. It is in essence thi trotted out to explain L quarter of a century ago in and to argue, then as now dilution of Labour polic changed situation. "As ec fliet grows less violent witl standards, voters may m matic assessment of whe interests lie", Tony Crosle in 1959. In 1974 pseph Butler and Stokes, were away " ...the betterment c economic conditions is important of the social tr weakened the inclination terms of class." - Now i the worst and most prol this century the Communi chorus.
As rehashed by Hobs ancient myth of the Gar which a pauperised pro socially and geographical munities; their only consol Blackpool, football, and They packed the union brai the Labour Party wards a basis of "the Labour Par right or wrong" . But the they were corrupted by Vol vision sets and two we Hobsbawm's noble sas haggard, brylcreemed foot their time, peering worrie team photographs. Like th half affluent successors to ate has turned Jack the Lad —Of course any attempt : behaviour in terms of si deprivation is unsustaina union commitment does ne flow with economic improv ioration. If it did the pr argument would be hard p we had to wait until 1945 or 1931 for the first majorit ment: or why the Labour 1931. Winning 289 seats
Scan page 7
art1 the party's retreat has taken developing economic crisis.
It was as long ago as 1961 that Mark Abrams produced a detailed refutation of the idea that economic trends were directly reproduced in voting and that affluence produced a switch to the Tories. It is two decades since Goldthorpe and his colleagues claimed that over 80% of their most affluent and satisfied workers still intended to vote Labour, and Runciman argued that even as absolute living standards reached "levels undreamed of in 1939"* relative deprivation could produce radical discontents.
It is fifteen years since John Westergaard pointed out that even if we accepted the dissolution of solidaristic bonds within the working class, the new instrumentality, 'the rediscovery of the cash nexus' together with the manufacture of new wants could create an explosive situation for capitalism (a point reaffirmed by the militancy of the early "70s). He argued that the existence of isolated working class communities in the past may well have fostered narrow horizons and a limited consciousness of community rather than a broader — class — consciousness. ment a porentially greater power. Moreover, the drop in membership that has occurred has occurred through workers losing their jobs, not, as happened to a degree in the '20s and '30s, through those with jobs leaving the unions.
Yet Hobsbawm asserts that "Britain, the home of mass trade unionism, has clearly fallen behind some other countries" • The examples he gives, Denmark, Sweden and Belgium, are not useful comparisons. In relation to its real competitors, the USA, Germany, Japan, Britain remains a powerfully unionised economy.
Moreover, while he is correct to draw attention to its political weaknesses, Hobsbawm has nothing to say about the distinctive achievements of British trade in the TUC. These are the strengths of British trade unionism which have constituted such a powerful and enduring barrier to repeated attempts to reorganise British capital.
It was only in the '40s, '50s and "60s, not in the '20s and '30s, that the edifice of workplace unionism — surely a vital expression of working class self activity and combativity for all its flaws and limitations — was
----- pull-quotes -----
direction No specific organisational 15 1