Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Hobsbawm's argui-change in workis and the Labour same…]

Socialist Organiser no. 228, 15 May 1985 · scan p. 7 · about 910 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Hobsbawm's argui-change in workis and the Labour same argument bour's defeat a the 1959 election for a consequent es to meet the nomic class conthe rise in living ike a less. autoe their political nd was telling us logical pundits, still hammering the electorate's y far the most nds which have o see politics in i the midst of nged recessions it Party joins the bawm it is the den of Eden in etariat lived in y isolated comtions were beer, ish and chips. ch meetings and id voted on the / and the union 1 came the fall: ros, videos, teleks in Majorca. ages are the allers old before lly from the old sir too-clever-byMiners march through Mansfield. Photo: John Harris (IFL)

won only 52 mn 1931. Its total poll dropped from 8.36 million in 1919 to 6.6 million in 1931.

At the heart of the inter-war depression Hobsbawm's 'traditional working class' was offered a Labour Party regrouped and purged of the "McDonald factor" and the working class responded by giving the Tories a resounding vote of confidence in the 1935 election. They were returned with 10.5 million votes and 387 seats (420 if the National Liberals are included) to Labour's 8.3 million votes and 154 seats.

KIM NUM ADMAN TEMAN TO SOM OBER XTORTRACT AI COYLE CRY • EPULSIVE 1951 election, when Labour got than the Tories but less seats.

At least a decade and a half after Labour's Forward March was halted and more than half a decade after the agonised 1959 post mortem more workers were voting Labour than during the heroic '20s and '30s, the heart of the Forward March. Affluence, psychedelia and mini skirts proved just as potent for Labour as rationing. Vera Lynn and demob suits. As the real impact of prosperity was felt in the you've never had it so good' days of the late '50s and early '60s, Labour's vote declined only Whatever the content of cultural development of the affluent years they hold the potential for bringing the working class closer together. Yet, as time goes by, and as the dole queues approach four million, the distinguished academic, Hobsbawm, like the distinguished pianist, Dooley Wilson in Casablanca, is still playing the same old song.

Yet if he were to look closer he might detect a slightly different picture. The decline in the Labour vote is not progressive and sequential. In fact, it has largely occurred in three specific periods: the early '50s; the late '60s and early "70s; and after 1979.

This should lead us to strongly question whether it is due. as he argues, to social or economic changes. Or whether it has been caused by an intensification of the political attack on the working class which has been inadequately answered and therefore relatively successful. These three periods were all striking periods of strong ruling class offensive.

Similar points may be made about Hobsbawm's second index of class consciousness - trade union membership. Hobsbawm has very little to say about this index of class consciousness during the golden age of the '20s and '30s. As an academic historian he knows that by this criteria, too, class consciousness was in severe decline during that period.

By 1933 trade union density was around 23%, about 50% of the 1920 figure. It is in Hobsbawm's period of retreat that trade union membership takes off, increasing from around 44% of the workforce in the early '50s to a record 55% by 1979. Moreover, whilst the unions have lost more than two million members since 1979 and there can be no grounds for complacency, what strikes us is not only the extension of trade unionism in the '60s and '70s to new areas which in other countries had been its nemesis, but the relative resilience of trade unionism in the depression of the '80s.

Today alter four years of mass unemployment and a decade of rising unemployment, fifty per cent of the workforce are still in the unions. Not only does this compare well with the 45% of the workforce unionised for most of the post-war period. That trade union density has dropped so slowly from its peak during the recent jobs holocaust illustrates the commitment of its membership as well as the strength of its organisational arrangements and the breadth of its coverage.

A range of workers hold union cards today who would never have been considered organisable in the '20s and '30s -workers whose organisation gives the moveconstructed.

Hobsbawm shows no interest in it. This draws our attention to the crudeness of his measurements of class consciousness. They are used in a fixed and strangely ahistorical fashion, so that he takes no account of shifts in consciousness and self-activity and the changing forms and expressions they take.

In one period, blocked on the trade union front, workers may move to seeing the Labour Party as the expression of their aspirations. In 1927, for example, it was difficult after the defeat of the General Strike and anti-union legislation for many workers to exhibit Hobsbawm's elementary class consciousness through being in a union. In the twenty odd years of the long boom workers turned away from participation in the Labour Party to building workplace organisation as the preferable means of achieving reforms. In 1950 there were only a fraction of the half a million shop stewards that existed in 1980. Today's depression has seen a limited but discernable turn back organisationally to the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 228

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →