[It is necessary to make a more sensitive…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-05-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
It is necessary to make a more sensitive analysis which interrelates the indices Hobsbawm proffers and corelate them to the development of the class struggle. Indeed Hobsbawm's whole analysis of trade unionism is limited and cavalier. The alleged increase in sectionalism in the working class during the last thirty years -"there is not much doubt that sectionalism is on the increase" — bears a strong burden of his argument in 1978. But it simply dispensed with a year later. Whether sectionalism is stronger in the trade union movement today than in the past is a historical question on which I may well have been wrong.
There is nothing in his analysis about a third rough measurement of class consciousness and combativity - strike figures. There were, for example, no national strikes during. the entire 1930s. Hobsbawm says the Forward March of Labour was halted at the end of the '40s. But as Labour turned from its second to its third decade of being "halted" a wave of militancy unparalleled since 1914 shook British society. Who would have said in 1972 or 1974 to the custodians of British capital: "Don't worry, the Forward March of Labour halted twenty years ago? In the year- Thatcher came to power nearly 30 million days• were lost through strikes. We have seen a decline since then to around four million as the depression has bit: but this is still a figure not reached, on average, through the "30s and '40s.
Despite the differences in the meaning of statistics, today's position in relation to the past gives us no grounds for pessimisitic comparison.
The