Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Trotskyists in the Nazi camps

Socialist Organiser no. 228, 15 May 1985 · scan p. 8 · about 854 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

ON APRIL 11 1945 the Nazi concentration camp at Buchenwald was li berated by an armed uprising of the prisoners.

Two days later the US troops arrived They disarmed the prisoners, banned all political meetings, and let a large number of the prisoners die of hunger.

Among the prisoners the Ernst Federn: seven years in the Nazi concentration camps strongest political force was the official Communist Parties, the Stalinists. Taking their cue from the USSR's chauvinist war propaganda, they were markedly antiGerman.

At the time of the collapse of the Nazi occupation of France, the French CP paper had had the headline 'A Chacun son Boche' - roughly, "Everyone get a Boche?.

The French CPers in Buchenwald were not so extreme in their chauvinism; but even so their attitudes antagonised many of the German CPers in the camp.

A Buchenwald "People's Front Committee' had the slogan, Long live the German People's Republic': but, according to one of the Trotskyists in the camp:

"Some old German communists came to find [us] and said: the time is come, you must come out publicly, and they asked for a preliminary text discuss er text bv comrades which came out for a German Soviet Republic had a big impact among the Marcel Beaufrere: organised propaganda among German troops German communist comrades"

And so the Buchenwald Trotskyists' manifesto was written, on April 20.

Like all the Trotskyist documents of that period, it centred its hopes on the revolutionary potential of the German working class.

There were indeed strikes, Colin protests, and attempts to form workers' councils in Germany immediately after the war. But they were put down by the US, British and French occupying troops -and, rather more ruthlessy, by the USSR in their sector - helped by the servile policies of the German CP and Social-Democratic Party The Buchenwald manifesto was written by four Trotskyists, two Austrian, _one Belgian, and one French.

Ernst Federn, an Austrian, had been in Nazi concentration camps for 7 years, first in Dachau and then in Buchenwald.

Karl Fischer had been a comrade of Federn's in Austria. He had been jailed in Vienna in 1935, but amnestied in 1938. He then escaped to France, where he was arrested in June 1944.

Unlike most Trotskyists, Fischer regarded the USSR as "state-capitalist' , rather than a post-capitalist economy ruled by a bureaucratic caste; on this point the manifesto represents a sort of compromise between his views and Abraham Leon: author of Marxist classic on the Jewish Question those of the other three.

Florent Galloy was a Belgian miner who had worked closely with Abraham Leon, the Belgian Trotskyist leader who. wrote the classic Marxist study of The Jewish Question' . Leon was arrested in June 1944 and'died in Auschwitz; Galloy was arrested in July 1944.

Marcel Beaufrere had been in Buchenwald since January 1944, together with a number of younger comrades from his Trotskyist group in Brest, France, who had been conducting revolutionary propaganda among the German troops.

The Trotskyists in Buchenwald were cautious about organising openly because they faced threats not only from the Nazis but also from the Stalinists among the prisoners. Beaufrere, for example, was recognised on his arrival in the camp by the French Stalinists, who swore to kill him.

Fischer, who returned to Austria after the war, was arrested there, deported to the USSR, and sentenced to 15 years of forced labour in Siberia for 'anti-Soviet activity'. '. He was released in 1955.

Despite the terrible odds against them, the Trotskyists Buchenwald prisoners celebrate kept their principles and their faith in the working class. Not only their manitesto, but also their actions, show that.

In the last days of the Buchenwald camp, the SS summoned all the Jewish priseir liberation oners. A mass killing was obviously planned. But the Trotskyists organised the political' prisoners to give their badges — red triangles -to Jews to replace their yellow stars and thus allow them to evade the SS.

Another incident was recorded by Michel Pablo, writing in 1958 (*The Fourth International, a History of its Ideas and its Struggles'):

*This year (1958) there died in Belgium, in the most complete anonymity, comKarl Fischer: 8 years in USUA labour camp after the War rade Gallois [Galloy], a mine worker who was deported duting the date Bute me is, ring the war to Buchenwald laughing, displayed to the assembled deportees, themselves prostrated and scarcely able to stand on their feet, a mass of human beings who were only skeletons, stinking and covered with vermin.

"They were Jews whom the SS were getting ready to gas, except in case - they stated - some charitable soul' would take it on himself to clean them up one by one.

*Nobody in the calip, Christian or otherwise, stirred comrade Gallois, who stepped to undertake the work, save humbly out of the ranks and offered to accomplish the task, on condition that the SS would respect their promise and spare the lives of these Jews. And for weeks on end comrade Gallois steadily carried out his mission"

[Information from Critique Communiste, November 1978, and Spartakist, May 1985.J

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 228

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →