CPSA: rough ride for Broad Left '84 Avoidable tragedy
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-05-15Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 12 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 12
Organıser
Bradford City fire: AT LEAST 52 people have died from last Saturday's terrible tragedy at Bradford City football ground, and (on Tuesday morning, 14th) 18 are still missing.
It was an avoidable tragedy. The football ground - which would have had to be completely renovated when Bradford City moved up into the Second Division — was a known fire hazard. What is more, the available evidence is that the club manager had been told of the dangers.
Though the club claims never to have received the warning letters from West Yorkshire's chief fire officer, it is clear that the whole of the Main Stand was known to be a monstrous firetrap long before between 50 and 70 football fans were suffocated or burned to death.
The fire spread rapidly. Many died because they ran to get out through back gates that had been locked.
The whole event demonstrates the absurdity - and the potentially criminal irresponsibility — of Chelsea's notion of electrified fences to control crowds and hooliganism. In Bradford the pitch was the main Bradford City ablaze escape route, and the consequences if there had been an electric fence scarcely bear thinking about.
The tragedy also wighlights the financial problems of Third and Fourth Division clubs.
The big clubs make money. But the Third and Fourth Division clubs gate receipts are too small to improve the grounds wholesale. They depend on networks of volunteers to raise money through lotteries and so on, be probably unsafe. Many rugby stadiums are also wooden structures without adequate emergency exists, The government should put up the money to make sure that another tragedy like Bradford does not happen. THE ANNUAL conference of the civil servants' union CPSA began on Monday May 13 with a discussion on the failed 1985 pay campaign.
Nine emergency motions were submitted censuring the executive for their handling of the campaign and their compliance with the 1984 Trade Union Act.
The executive, dominated by the Broad Left '84 group, originally agreed to consult members about industrial action on pay by the normal CPSA method of a show of hands at workplace meetings. Then as soon as an injunction was taken out against the CPSA, the executive capitulated, called off the vote halfway (when it was showing a two-to-one majority for action), and sent out ballot papers. In line with the Tory Act, the papers pointed out that strike action would break our contracts of employment.
The re-run vote showed a narrow, majority against action. The confusion created by the executive obviously influenced the vote.
Conference voted against the censure motions by 533 to 304 on a show of hands. Broad Left '84 argued that they were still opposed to the anti-union laws in theory, but in practice it is impossible to defy those laws in a union of the size and nature of CPSA.
The Broad Left '84 group has made many friends among the CPSA full-timers, and and general secretary Alistair Graham must be pleased about the way they preach pessimism in the name of 'realism?.
Elections
Things have not all gone the way of Broad Left 84, however. In the DHSS section - the most militant and leftwing section - the election results announced over the weekend made the original Broad Left much stronger on the section executive committee, while all the prominent Broad Left 84 people were throi/n off.
The national executive election results, which are likely to show right-wing majority, are due out at the end of the week.