Dog-eat-dog society
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 5
The deaths of over forty people in Brussels, at the European Cup final between Liverpool and Juventus, provoked horror and outrage throughout The stadium was inadequate, it was badly organis: ed, the police were inept and heavy-handed, and fascists helped to stir it up: still, the fact remains that a number of fans acted brutally and mindlessly The Tories seize on such events to boost their drive for more police powers. Tom Rigby and Clive Bradley argue an alternative socialist view.
An English philosopher once commented that "the life of man is solitary, mean, nasty, brutish and short." With scenes like those in Belgium last week, it is difficult to doubt it. Something compels people to the most mindless, pointless acts of brutality.
By nature, so the argument goes, we are all selfish, heartless, greedy. Some people, for particular reasons, are worse than others. But the nasty; vicious streak is there in all of us. That' 's what drives us to beat the hell out of eachother. That's what drives us, in the final analysis, to war.
Human nature?
Hooliganism, then, is the price we pay for being, in essence, anti-social, only compelled to live together by states, governments, and 'law and order'.
It is a depressing view. But it is false. Alongside the violence and brutality, there are tremenEurope. dous, heroic moments of ity: acts of working class ity, heralding a different society.
Brussels
Thousands of worke rs in countless working class struggles have proved ready to die so that thei r comsolidarsolidarkind of rades, and future generations, might have a better world to live in.
This society — class societybreeds national hatred, chauvinism, racism; it is a society created and founded upon horrific, monstrous, institutionalised violence, held together by violence. The law of profit, the domination of our lives by money and governments who force, offering real solutions, a real alternative. If the labour movement makes itself strong, fights militantly and politically for its interests and the interests of the oppressed, fascist groups will remain isolated and weak.
That means also that the labour movement must show that it is stronger than the fascists — it must physically oppose them and drive them off the streets. If the labour movement acts, as the decisive and most powerful force in society, it can weld the masses of working class youth tempted by fascism into a movement for socialist change. worship it, dog-eat-dog eat dogs.
And for who enjoy from the brutalises us. In a society, dogs will the most part, those mindless violence are most brutalised, the Top and above: victims of the Heysel stadium tragedy are carried away most dehumanised our society.
Most football violence is small scale, individual acts of thuggery. More recently there has developed a cult of gangs gang warfare, in miniature, being a model of the whole organisation of society. It is mindless - though even then there is an element of incoherent revolt, particularly in confrontations with the police — but it is rooted, not in human nature, but in class society.
Rotting
Society is rotting: the Tories are right about that. But it is their society, their rotten, miserable, stinking system. It can be ameliorated. We can fight for policies to help lift people from the gutter. But the solution is to change society; and transforming the dehumanised violence of dispossessed working class youth into coherent, political struggle against capitalism would be a tremendous force towards creating a new society, based not on hatred and misery, but on human solidarity. matches. It is not senseless, pointless violence for its own sake: it is necessary, political violence by a class or a community against a ruthless political enemy. -Thatcher wants to win other victories too. The flip-side of chauvinism and gang warfare is the notion that we are all, collec. ively, as a nation, guilty fot what happened in Belgium. "It has brought shame, Thatcher said, "on Britain and on football" — adding that the miners' strike paved the way.
The suggestion that we are all responsible for the deaths in Belgium — or that all the British people who were there are responsible — is idiotic.
If we are all 'guilty", we should also all 'pull together' to do something about it. We should all accept the short sharp shock - not only that, we should want it, plead for it, as a national penance.
To assuage our guilt we must put up with undemocratic laws, heavier policing, the rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer. It is sick.
Thatcher's Thatcher's proposals to 'solve' the problem - banning alcohol, most obviously, would mean more power to the police. Of course, as evidence in Scotland suggests, restricting alcohol does have some effect on reducing football violence. But it needs strong policing, and draconian restrictions on people who do only want a nice time, to enforce it.
If working class people themselves establish forms of control - from restricting alcohol to collective disciplining of thugs - that is one thing. But Thatcher wants to punish us in order to strengthen the hand of the police in strikes, on demonstrations. That is why she is so eager to equate football rioting with the miners' strike.
In any case, it is rank hypocrisy. Drink is only part of the problem — an extra factor, not a root cause. The average Tory drinks far more than the average working class youth - because the average Tory has got more moneyAnd the Tory Party is funded by big breweries. They make profits out of the stuff.