Hobsbawm and SDP-Communism part 4
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
Of course the salient point about this new Popular Front is that the Alliance is not in the anti- Thatcher camp. It is not in the political sense a party of a wavering middle class. It simply represents an alternative variant of Thatcherism. The SDP is a capitalist party pure and simple. On the SDP "Campaign For Fair Votes" sit representatives of Trafalgar House, Beechams, Thorn, EMIC and Cadbury Schweppes and former Tory Cabinet Ministers, Lords Carr and Jellicoe. It is, as Owen has declared, a social market party.
On vital issues, such as the separation of the Labour Party from the unions, the SDP's. position is harder than Thatcher's and at one with the Institute of Directors. From the viewpoint of the stability of capital the failure of the '74-79 government and the emergence of the. Bennite left represented a threat to the turn and turn about system of rule by two capitalist parties. If Bennism crystallised, moved left and was carries into the unions the possibility of a government which would act against the interests of capital was opened up. Conversely, if an alternative governing party institutionally separated from the unions was to emerge, a party purely of capital which could, nevertheless, mop up the working class vote and gain some kind of support from Chapple, Duffy, Grantham and so on, then this could interact with and mesh into ruling class. plans for the labour movement — the plans which the Tories are now implementing with the goal to remould the unions, weaken their centre, the TUC, and cut them off from direct politics in the shape of their own party, and thus to create a US style political system in Britain.
In the present situation there is a decline in support for both Tory and Labour, but the SDP cannot make a decisive breakthrough both because of the impasse of class relations and because of the British voting system. Therefore, the best alternative for capital is, as the Economist pointed out, a situation where "Dr Owen could head a non-Marxist Social Democrat grouping sides) to realise Mr Tony Benn's worst fears, an SDP-moderate Labour coalition, radical but not union dominated, from. which the Bennites are forced to split away. Such a coalition remains the best hope for a realignment of the left of British politics — a realignment which is itself British politics? most urgent priority"
The Economist is well aware of what the policies of such a coalition would mean for the working class, yet their realignment ig precisely identical with Hobsbawm's Popular Front. Hobsbawm would be there arguing that the Labour Party must totally revise its programme and accept Alliance terms governing down the pace of social change to what is acceptable to the SDP and the Economist.