[ties of collaboration with the ruling class on…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 6
ties of collaboration with the ruling class on their own national terrain. From revolutionaries perverted by loyalty to the Kremlin they have become just parties of reform — or primarily parties of reform. The "left turns" of the late '40s have long ago ceased. The tendency to open splits with Moscow has increased. By disorientating and obstructing those socialists who would change society the Eurocommunists now protect the interests of their own ruling class and of those in the Kremlin fearful of socialist change in other countries — just as surely as Thorez and Togliatti ever did.
So far we have agreed with Hobsbawm that there is a crisis in the labour movement. We have disagreed with his argument which, stripped of its obfuscating twists, is simply that "the profound changes in the social and economic structure since the 1950s" means that to achieve power Labour will have to abandon socialist positions. We have argued that his solutions involve in reality — and at best! — a Labour government just like the others, or and so on. What happens to a reformist party when the scope for concessions to its base drastically narrows?
The aim of the '64, '66 and "74 Labour governments, for example, was to harness both capital and labour through the state to a strategy of modernising British capital.
Wilson's half-hearted attempts to do this through the IRC collapsed into attempted reliance on one ingredient in the strategy, incomes policy, deflation and legal attack on the trade unions (In Place of Strife, 1969) — all of which alienated Labour's 1966 majorLabour Party lies not in cross class alliances but in acting in the interests of the working class. The compromise between working class and capital which gives Labour its role as broker has disintegrated under the impact of the crisis. This should be welcomed, not as with Hobsbawm, regretted.
Scan page 7
Of course reformism is a complex ideology. People do not simply react like Pavlovian dogs to changes in the economic situation and the failure of a party to deliver and in certain conditions support for Labour may be maintained at a certain level of decline. really believe, that Healy and Hattersley would preside over free collective bargaining and unilateral nuclear disarmament?
What Hobsbawm is arguing for is a continuation of the appeasement of the right and therefore a continuing paralysis. The left must not lie down with the right but continue and deepen the struggles of 1979-81 with the aim of transforming Labour into a party which can put forward socialist measures. The fact that there is a limited constituency for socialism today and that there is a strong entrenched conservatism within the working class has to be recognised. If we are really socialists, if we really want to dismantle capitalism, if we are serious poli-
----- pull-quotes -----
more likely a coalition the SDP. - and