[This must not be a matter of left…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
This must not be a matter of left phraseology or mere token gestures. If the hard left — the people around CLPD, London Labour Briefing, the Campaign Group of MPs. Socialist Organiser, Socialist Action and others — are to make an impact, then they will have to come together on the basis of sustained work in the trade unions as well as the Labour Party. Socialist change will not be handed down to the working class from on high. It will be carried through by the workers themselves. A workers' government will in part he produced by and in turn safeguarded by the direct self-activity of the working class. And the working class will go beyond it.
This view is quite foreign to Eric Hobsbawm, a lifelong and committed Stalinist, albeit now of the Eurocommunist persuasion. In an article in New Left Review he salutes the "German Socialist Republic and the fact that this came into existence through the Red Army rather than through the efforts of the German movement would have been perfectly acceptable to the German Communists. For that Republic which can only be criticised if we also acknowledge its remarkable achievements in very difficult circumstances is indeed the child of the KPD...Yet who ever doubted that the great body of upright, brave, loyal, devoted, able and efficient functionaries and executives who returned from exile and from the concentration camps to do their duty as Communists would do a competent job?" (Confronting Defeat: The German Communist Party).
Enthusiasm for the police states, in which there is not a trace of socialism, and disdain for working class self-activity - socialism's irreplaceable precursor — go hand in hand. Hobsbawm's dismissal of the militancy of the early '70s which brought workers into conflict with legislation and the courts and which led to the removal of the Heath government — struggles which have been described by an equally distinguished historian, Royden Harrison, as the most vigorous this century — are dismissed by Hobsbawm as economistic, sectional and selfish. This should not surprise us. For those who advocate governing down the pace of social change to the needs of capital, those who embrace 'socialism from above', the self-activity of the workers is not a major opportunity and still less the sine qua non of socialism, but major problem.
Continued
----- pull-quotes -----
defeat is not ms from the