Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The socialist

Socialist Organiser no. 231, 5 June 1985 · scan p. 8 · about 842 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 8

continued from page For us the early '70s militancy was an opportunity lost. It failed to find a political expression which went beyond the return of Labour reformism in the election of 1974.

Since then it has been pinioned in the corporatist structures of industrial relations reforms and weakened by the recession. We wee the direct action of the workers - no matter how limited the demands - as something to be totally supported, extended and developed. Hobsbawm simply dismisses it. Here is his view of the working class upsurge in 1972 which led to the freeing of the dockers jailed in Pentonville under the Heath government's anti-union laws, to the breaking Heath's anti-union legislation and forced the TUC to call a one-day general strike, the first decision for general strike since 1926. [The government caved in before it could happen]. In the docks dispute the fact can't be blinked that there are two groups of workers trying to do each other out of a job. The ones who win in such a situation are not necessarily those who represent what is best for the working class or the nation: they are simply the strongest." (Listener, July 27, 1972).

There are real problems, numerous problems to be solved before we can fuse industrial militancy with a wider political struggle and focus partial — industrial and other — struggles round the work of transforming the Labour Party and the fight to put it in government. Hobsbawm sees an uncloseable gap. He is blinded by the politics of Eurocommunism becuse in the end these politics require the working class to stay passive, or strictly under bureaucratic control while their self-appointed Stalinist representatives act for them. In practice, the politics of Eric Hobsbawm do not simply involve dismissing the direct struggles of workers. They demand that those struggles should be disciplined and subordinated to something else — to the bourgeois popular front in Britain and Italy and to the Russian Army-imposed bureaucratic police state in East Germany and similar states.

Hobsbawm's vision is essentially nostalgic pessimism where he laments that ..unlike the '30s the left today can neither point to an alternative society immune to the crisis (as the USSR seemed to be) nor to any concrete policies which hold much promise for overcoming it in the short term, as Keynesian or similar policies seemed to promise then." We should rather feel optimistic. We should welcome both the intractibility of today's crisis and the gaps which have opened up between the working class and both Stalinism and reformism. We should welcome the fact that this divide creates the space for a genuine socialist politics. We must develop that politics in relation to the self-uctivity of the working class, and unify and build around it and around the day-to-day class struggle in both the unions and the Labour Party. That is the difficult task ahead That task involves limiting and undermining the influence of Eric Hobsbawm and his clones and disciples in the Labour Party, those, for example, who call for unconditional support for a leader who refuses to support the miners and failed even Liverpool City Council.

We must reject not only Hobsbawm s pessimism but the politics it both dictates and feeds off. True, we have to accept that there is no existing majority for socialism.

The British working class retains its old political weaknesses. But we can win such a majority for socialism. It has to be worked for. It will never be won if we capitulate toexisting working class consciousness instead of fighting tenaciously and patiently to transform it and free it from bourgeois. Stalinist and reformist ideas.

We must reject alliances with capital and build alliances within the working class. particularly with women, with black workers, with the unemployed.

We must understand that the way to beat the Alliance is by attacking it, not by joining it.

The way to win middle strata is not by capitulating to their alleged needs but by independently and decisively pursuing working class objectives and by showing them how, in the end. their interests too are best served by socialism.

Above all, we must fight in a serious and determined way to build an extra-parliamentary dimension, subordinating elec toralism to it. This means resisting the intrusion of the sclerosed adaptationist socialism from above, represented by Hobsbawm and the Communist Party which in the end always makes its peace with capital. Its influence today can only disorientate and weaken Labour.

Let us instead inscribe on our programme the words of Engels and Marx: 'The emancipation of the working class is conquered by the working classes themselves."

Unless specifically cited, all quotes from Hobsbawm are from the following: The Forward March of Labour Halted in the book of that title, edited by M. Jacques and F. Mulhern, Verso.

Response, ibid.

Observation on the debate, ibid.

Falklands Fallout in S. Hall and M. Jacques (editors) The Politics of Thatc herism. Lawrence and Wishart, 1983.

Labour's Lost Millions, Marxism October 1983.

Labour Rump or Rebirth? Marxism March 1984.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 231

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →