Labour victor
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-05Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Benn campaigning in Mansfield (John Harris)
ted. This quiet revolution is still in progress, but so far, its ence. effects may be summarized by listing the decisions that have bers on he NEC. been taken: 1. Removal of policy making from the NEC.
Basic policy-making is no longer undertaken by the NEC, through its sub-committees, many of which have been wound up, but by joint committees com- committees. posed of selected NEC, PLP and trade union members, who are charged with the task of drafting these new statements, subjcet to the technical right of the NEC to change them at the last stage. 2. A shift of power from the NEC to the PLP.
The role and authority of the decision. PLP and especially the Parliamentary Committee has, as a result, been immensely strengthened, as compared to the NEC itself from real power. and is, increasingly, separately 5. Changes in party policy. financed through:
a) continuing with the allocation of all the — extra - Government (or Short) money to the to conference. PLP, some of which is used to finance research assistants, working personally for front bench spokespersons, who are not paid trade union rates, are not answerable to the NEC, or conference, and do not have security of employment;
b) continuing with the prin- omitted. ciple that trade unions directly finance some PLP spokespersons with money that does not go through the central funds of the party. 3. A shift of power from the NEC to Trade Unions for a deliberately vague. Labour Victory [TUL V).
The TULV, made up of trade union leaders, or their deputies, who are not elected by the Labour conference, have been given a more influential role in managing the party.
This has been achieved by the NEC adopting the practice of applying to the TULV for money for specific purposes, which then has to be justified, to the 1UL, case by case, rather than by using the TULV as a collec- weapons are phased out. tive fund-raiser, leaving decisions as to expenditure to the NEC itself, subject to confereither not been referred to, or 4. A downgrading of CLP mem- appear to have been replaced by 'Charters' which are more With one exception, NEC vague, illustrative and general. members elected by the Constit- 6. A purge of the Left. uency section have been re- Despite solemn assurances moved from chairmanships of all given to conference that there the main NEC committees thus would be no witch-hunt based eliminating them from their upon the opinions of party memex-officio membership of other bers, the attack upon some of the Left has been stepped up.
In addition a new campaign An Appeals and Mediation strategy committee, including Committee has been set up, with some NEC. PLP and trade union only one CLP representative on members, has been set up, from it, and its main work has been to which other NEC members are carry out this purge. excluded, which has been justi- Some of the key decisions fied by reference to a wrong made by this committee, and interpretation of a conference confirmed by the NEC, include:
La) The expulsion of one party This committee has estab- member for selling Militant in lished its own sub-committees another constituency from the still further distancing the NEC one in which he lives.
Mb) The refusal of a transfer of membership to a party member The party's policies have been who was alleged to have sold altered in a number of key res- Socialist Action. pects, some of which have gone c) The expulsion of members of another party, mainly on the a) The 'Alternative Economic evidence of a Labour councillor Strategy' has effectively been who then left the party and joinreplaced by a more general ed the Liberals. 'Jobs and Industry' campaign, d) Non-registered organisafrom which some of the clear tions being denied a listing in socialist commitments on public the conference diary, whereas ownership, economic planning all-party groups may be and exchange control have been included.
This may be contrasted with b) The commitment that the confirmation, after a recor Britain would withdraw from the ded vote on the NEC, of Frank Common Market has been Chapple's continued memberreplaced by a reference to 'an ship of the party, despite his option to withdraw', the exercis- refusal to take the Labour whip ing of which, has been left in the House of Lords, and his consistent attacks upon the c) The commitment to reduce party in his column in the Daily Britain's defence expenditure to Mall. the same percentage of the GNP This purge is, presumably, as our European allies in NATO, designed to fend off attacks from has been explicitly dropped and the media, which has run, and is in its place we have a commit- still running, a campaign desment that such a change could igned to denigrate socialist ideas not be made during the lifetime and those who hold, or advocate of the first Labour government, them. and indeed, there is a new 7. Distancing. he party from pledge actually increase struggle. expenditure on conventional A stand has been taken, by weapons as British nuclear some in the PLP, against any suggestion that non-compliance d) Other policies that had with Tory laws could ever be been in Labour Programme 1982 justified; and strong criticisms have been voiced, within the PLP, about the conduct of industrial 1 disputes, notably during the miners' strike, which appeared to distance the party from certain aspects of that momentous struggle. 8. Reorganisation to suppor these changes.
Though apparently limited to the task of dealing with the efficiency of the Party HQ and its staff, the thinking behind the 'Review of Review's committee seems to be that there must be a further reshaping of the party's organisation to support the major changes outlined above.
Conclusions and recommendations The changes described above are all of fundamental importance; represent a far bigger change in the party's constitution than occurred int he 1979-81 period; take us back to the structure that existed pre-war and post-war when the PLP and the General Secretaries of some major unions effectively ran the party and the NEC was weak and ineffective; and though some of these changes have been to conference, others have been carried out without the party, as a whole, really realising what has been happening.
It is essential that any report, on party organisation issued by the NEC to the 1985 conference should make absolutely clear what is happening, and what is now planned, so that the party may know precisely what is going on, before it makes its own decisions.
The recommendations given below were drafted to help secure that victory. 1. Campaigning around real struggles.
To win the next election the party must be seen to be giving whole-hearted support to all those who are in struggle against the government, and that all party campaigns should centre around those struggles, as well as during all by-eleccation. 2. The NEC and conference must run the party.
The central direction of the party, its policy and administration, must, under its own constitution, remain with the NEC which is elected by, and accoun table to, Conference, since Conference is the only link that the membership have with political decision-making. 3. The PLP must be integrated into the Party.
The PLP must be brought closer to the party, the NEC and Conference:
a) by integrating PLP standing orders into the party constitution;
b) by channelling all PLP finances through the NEC, including all government funds (which would then be used by tne NEC for PLP work); and all trade union funds (leaving the unions with the right to earmark their own money, if they wished to do so, for certain purposes including the support of the PLP).
c) by providing greater iccountability of the Parliamen tary Committee, and the Cabinet (when Labour is in office) to conference, perhaps through annual election by the same Electoral College as now/elects the Leader and Deputy Leader. 4. The need for socialist policies o win.
Policy-making has a major role to play in the present deepening crisis, where the government has the initiative.
Labour must be able to respond with a considered socialist alternative that has been discussed, agreed and put to conference for decision as soon as possible.
The 1983 policies, far from being too radical, are likely to prove quite inadequate to deal with the situation that the next Labour government will inherit, which will be so critical that we shall almost certainly be forced to consider the development of stronger policies to deal with it.
We therefore intend to submit another paper to the NEC which will concentrate on future policy. 6. A socialist dialogue instead of a purge.
The Labour Party is the principal political instrument working people in Britain, having been established by the trade unions for that purpose, and having consciously adopted socialism as its objective.
Here, and world-wide, the socialist debate is rich in variety and experience of successes and failures and we must be able to learn from both, and then build our own brand of socialism, based upon social morality and a deep commitment to democracy and human rights.
There are a number of different schools of socialist thought in this country, many organised around their own newspapers or magazines, and attracting a following of a few hundred or a few thousands.
None of these groups are capable either of taking over, or of replacing the Labour Party, and their contribution should be seen as a part of the on-going discussion about socialism.
Nor is there any evidence to suggest that any of them are actually planning the overthrow of democracy in Britain, or are engaged in the preparation of violence.
Most of them are made up of decent and serious people who work hard for the labour movement and whose arguments deserve serious consideration.
If such people, or organisations, put up candidates against the Labour Party then they are ineligible to join us, but that should be the sole criterion by which they are judged to be eligible to join the party.
Any policy by the NEC of seeking out, and then expelling left' - whatever that may be -is a mistake because:
a) it suggests to our opponents — quite falsely - that the party is deeply penetrated by a whole lot of violent revolutionaries whose secret objective is to destroy Britain's democratic institutions — which we all know to be rubbish.
b) it diverts the party, locally and nationally, from its central task of defeating the Tories and the SDP.
c) it gives the impression that we are frightened of socialist ideas, but are unable to answer them and prefer eliminate them by organisational means. 7. Extending affiliations o he par y.
The NEC should recognise that a whole new range of political Issues, and organisations, have emerged since the party was founded in 1918.
More recently, the women's movement, the ethnic communities, the peace movement and a mass of other special interest groups have come into existence, as evidenced by the long list of registered groups within the party itself and by the campaigns for greater rights for women and blacks within the party.
Many of the most active people in these new movements and organisations are socialists or Labour supporters, much as they are in the trade unions.
The issues and policies that the party takes up are designed to meet the needs of many of these groups, including, of course, women and the ethnic community and we should seriously consider opening up affiliation to allow those that wish to do so to join, on the same basis as the unions and the socialist societies did in the past.
This would broaden the range of party membership, help us to escape the - largely legitimate - charge that the party is dominated by white males, and help to make us the instrument for all working people in this generation, as we were in the past.
There is, therefore, a strong case for establishing GOnmittee to examine this possibility, to report to the NEC in time for the 1986 conference.
If these proposals were acceptable there would be, later, major constitutional conference, like the 1918 conference, to which all appropriate and acceptable, movements and groups would be invited, with a view to their affiliation to the party, on the same basis as the trade unions and socialist societies are now affiliated. 8. Organising for victory.
All the organisational changes that the party now makes should be geared to support this alternative view of our future -We believe that this would also offer the best possible prospect of winning the next election, by showing ourselves to be sensitive to the new situation, the new issues and the new organisational structures which are emerging in the politics of Britain in the eighties and nineties leading on to the next century.
The time has come for the Labour Party to look to the future, dare to have a vision of 'socialism in our time', and have the courage to re-shape itself so that it can discharge, for this generation, the historic task that the founders of the movement dreamed of so many years ago. CONCLUSION The National Executive is invited:
a) to note this and;
b) to refer it to the appropriate committees, and c) to consider it again when they report back to the NY B ERIC HEFFER MAY DAY 1985
Scan page 10
Socialist Organiser no. 231. June 5 1985. Page 10
----- pull-quotes -----
BENE Labour and in the 1983 Manifesto, have