Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Discussing football violence: The people's game?

Socialist Organiser no. 232, 12 June 1985 · scan p. 2 · about 1,068 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 2 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 2

DURING the last week there have been horrendous stories coming from Sri Lanka about massacres. While the government of Sri Lanka has done its best to try to suppress this news, it has nevertheless leaked out and demonstrates that much of what we've been saying about the dangers facing Tamil people in Sri Lanka has been completely justified.

Last week's article on football violence provoked quite. a response from SO readers. Alan Fraser continues the discussion.

TOM Rigby's and Clive Bradley's article on the Brussels disaster and football violence identifies the root causes -i.e. patriarchal capitalist society.

But it is not enough just to denounce the system that perpetuates the violence. We have to extend, discuss and develop our views on sport.

From my experience as a socialist who participates actively in sport, I think the demand that we should ban competitive sport is totally unrealistic.

Socialists who argue this may well be correct when they say that certain sports encourage rat-race behaviour and violent attitudes. But nevertheless millions of working-class people are involved in sport, either as spectators or by participation.

Most working-class people look to sport as a means to free themselves from the daily grind of our society -mundane jobs and unemployment. It seems to me that socialists who talk about banning sport, perhaps because of their social background, are completely failing to recognise that sport, and football in particular, are not only rooted in the working class but also have a complex culture despite its weaknesses.

It is true that under capitalism the emphasis is on winning and proving yourself and your team superior. However, I think socialists make a mistake when they think that competition in sport is the property of capitalism.

For example, when I played street football on the streets of Glasgow, it was important to win, but it was just as important to be highly skilful and athletic. There was no compulsion to win at all costs.

Skill

The games we played were thoroughly enjoyable, and usually lasted for four to five hours. Most of us felt then that developing our skill and athleticism was an exciting and invigorating experience.

I think the reasons for that are pretty clear. Street football was ours. It was us who made the rules. It was us who decided who should play -and that usually meant everybody..

There was no referee, no hierarchy, no organisation dictating to us. We felt that these games were ours, and on those long summer nights our parents would find it impossible to prise us away from our beloved game.

Sometimes we would stop for a brief rest to juggle with the ball and to show off to each other some new-found skill. There was an enormous amount of inventiveness and creativity. No-one told us how. We just did it.

Although there was competition, there was also a tremendous feeling of achievement, unity and social cooperation, The example street Chauvinism on the terraces football shows that perhaps it is not the competition that is decisive, but the way in which the competition is controlled and who controls it.

On the night of the Brussels disaster, Terry Venables, manager of Spanish league champions • Barcelona, proclaimed on TV: "I can't understand why they commit these acts of violence. It's their game. It belongs to the Terry, who incidentally also heads the consortium that owns Queens Park Rangers, could not have been more wrong.

Profit

Football is not the people's game, it's the directors' game. And that's a big part of the problem.

The structures, organisation and values of sport are not controlled by the people who play or watch, but by Hamn Kenny Dalglish businessmen such as Robert Maxwell, who use their position as football directors to gain power, prestige, and in some cases pront.

The football club is now a commodity in the hands of a few businessmen. Ordinary working-class people are completely excluded from taking part or having any say in how their team or sport is run.

The controlling bodies are hierarchical and have no connection or involvement with the community.

Socialists have to take the politics of sport, toth nationally and internationally, more seriously. The hypocrisy and double standards come not only from Thatcher ana the Tories but also from the so-called working-class kids who pull themselves away from the gutter.

Scottish captain Graham Souness, commented on the Brussels violence: should be locked up for ten. years. They are not but animals"

Of course, butter would not melt in his mouth.

The night before, playing for Scotland against Iceland, he maimed an Icelandic player, who was carried off injured and is now unable to play for a few months. Graham sees nothing wrong with putting the boot in from time to time. It is all part of the game. Some times you have to give stick, and other times you have to take it.

Winning

That type of violence on a football field is OK. Why? Because your boss tells you that the game is about winning, and sometimes you have to take people out to do so.

Rather different from street football for a bottle of lemonade which, if we ever won, was shared by all who played anyway.

At present the Labour Party has no policy on sport - who controls it, who funds it, what facilities should be available. Gary Whannel in his highly readable and interesting book, Blowing the Whistle: The Politics of Sport? argues for a basic socialist policy which might contain four elements:

1.An egalitarian intention. Genuine sport for all with positive discrimination to counter existing structures and attitudes.

2. Adequate facilities and funding to make sport for all possible.

3. Social ownership of stadiums, sport centres, recreation land, and the subsidiary leisure industry.

4. Democratic control of sports facilities at all levels of sports organisation.

Sport, despite what many socialists say, does have its positive sides.

The London Marathon and similar events are a clear example. They smashed that you have to be a winner. They smashed the myth that only strong athletic men and an elite few run marathons. Many women who until a few years ago were not allowed to run long distances have competed and finished in mara+ thons without any problems.

We need a socialist alternative that will make sport fun, encourage social cooperation, and give the game back to the

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 232

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →