Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

What Went Wrong?

Socialist Organiser no. 232, 12 June 1985 · scan pp. 5–6 · about 3,156 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 5 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 5

Subscribe!

continued from p.1 There were then two possibilities. One was to up the ante - which had to be done through motions in the coun cil chamber, since it was difficult to get trade unionists to take industrial action when there were no cuts taking place. The other - which I argued for - was simply to stand firm. - The problem was not simply that the councillors were not willing to go illegal. For example, the motion we put to the Hackney council meeting was declared illegal before we actually put it to the council.

Yet all but nine of the Labour councillors voted for that motion. They had received legal writs before they went into that council meeting cautioning them about their action.

Against that background of legal threats before anything had happened, Hackney councillors still voted for a position that the borough solicitor had told them was illegal.

I think you have to judge people by what they do rather than what they say, and in this context you have to judge people by the way they vote.

There is a danger of getting into psychological arguments about why did somebody vote for that and so on. I'm not sure this is always the clearest way of working out what the best strategy is.

I'm not sure at present what particular tactics one would talk about in future campaigns. It seems to me that the major problem will be a great deal of cynicism amongst working class organisations, including trade unions, about the councils willingness to be involved in any serious campaign against the government's policies.

In Hackney, we believe that the right wing has to take responsibility for the cuts they have pushed through, and be seen to be doing this by the people of Auditor holds back from surcharging.

The absence of two tory councillors and the fact that the Tory group has not rushed forward to requisition another council meeting suggests that they want to make it impossible for the Labour Group to back Get SOCIALIST door by post.

RATES: £8.50 Name .

Address Please se To: Soci ORGANISER each r 6 months. £16 for "Most councillor:

have comes to in an extremely traditional way, albeit you have women's committee and an anti racist committee and so on.

But there is not a mood of despondency or demoralisation. Everybody is 60mmitted to continuing the fight against the cuts, be it inside the council chamber or butside.

Reselection

Reselection has to be discussed now so that next year none of the right wing councillors will be selected. Next week all the organisations involved in the Hackney campaign will be meeting to get the campaign off to a new start.

d firi down. Vindictive and gleeful speeches from the Tories indicate that they would dearly love to see Lambeth Labour councillors surcharged.

Nationally, the Tory government may or may not make such a move. On the one hand, they have succeeded in isolating Lambeth, and can take heavy punitive action and make an example of them.

I eni rt Co Hilda Kean Unless there are largescale resignations in the counCils that were rate-capped this year, you will have essentially the same councillors going into a campaign next year.

There needs to be an assessment, particularly in the local Labour Parties, of what particular tactics you employ. What am worried ahout is a basically syndicalist response to the situation, saying "Well, councils always let people down. There's no role for the councillors. Evervthing should be left to the unions" . Although I can understand why people would feel that way, I don't However, the Tories are worried about their rapidly diminishing electoral popularity and they do not know how strongly London Bridge and the trade union movernent would respond.

Once the certificates are issued the legal process of appeal would take months, and give the campaign valuable time to mobilise support on a national level.

A voluntary collapse by Lambeth would be far preferable to Jenkins and Thatcher than an open-ended situation which surcharge would initiate.

conference on June 22 is being organised by Lambeth to rally support from trade unions, community groups, Labour Parties and from left Labour councillors in other rate-capped boroughs who fought against making a rate.

Prior to that, the Lambeth Council Labour Group is meeting on Wednesday June 12. It is vital that they are lobbied and asked to stand firm agaist the anticipated letters from the District Auditor. think that is the most constructive way forward.

I think that as socialists, we have to discuss how to build up an alliance between different sections of the community, including socialist councillors, and the Labour Party, for future campaigns.

What we have managed to do in Hackney is to bring about a great deal of solidarity between different sec-l tions of the labour movement in the campaign this year.

This solidarity is not only important for the rate-capping issue, but for any campaigns we are waging against this government's policies.

Because the rate-capping campaign did not succeed in Hackney, it would seem to me a great pity to go back immediately into the traditional ways of organising that the left has done in recent Angry here in Hackney are angry rather than demoralised The collapse on rate-caping is quite significant in relation to what is happening in the Labour Party nationally.

Until the 1981 GLC elections, the left had not really taken seriously the question of local government. This has begun to change since then.

What has happened over the last couple of months and the view that Ken Livingstone has taken after the setting of the rate at the GLC, 13 tilat while on ideological issues, councillors like Ken Livingstone have taken a progressive stand, when it has come to key economic and financial questions, there has been a real absence of left strategy.

If, for example, you look at the GLC's campaign against abolition, it has not centred on a close working with the unions, nor did their campaign against ratecapping. was centred far more on propaganda aimed at the population of London in general, rather than at the labour movement bodies that are capable of organising people in trade union action.

You cannot take a socialist stand in relations to issues like women's oppression or racism without at the same time taking on board the economic factors that materially affect pople's lives.

How can the GLC on the one hand make all this propaganda about having a GLC Women's Committee and supposedly takıng notice of the interests of women in London while at the same time it draws back from the fight for adequate resources for such facilities?

That is to miseducate people about the nature of women's oppression, which is seen on the level of ideas in people's heads rather than the economic way in which women are disciminated against.

Most councillors, in the campaign against ratecapping, have not seen their role going beyond the traditional role of councillors in the council chamber, despite the left rhetoric that has been put about.

They have reinforced Kinnock's position by saying that when it comes to a crunch, when it comes to a question of illegality, that you just act in an extremely traditional way, albeit that you have women's committees and anti-racist committees and so on.

Left

What should the left be doing now? There have recently been calls for left regroupment.

I believe there is a need for the left to organise on a broad basis, with different currents on the left working together far more closely. It's important to take note of what the gains have been, not only on rate-capping but also on the miners' strike and the lessons these hold for the way the left should be organising over the coming period.

Labour Briefing, as a publication, seems to have concentrated - to my mind wrongly - too much on the internal workings of the Labour Party and on issues of reselection per se, of black sections and the constitutionality of black sections per se, rather than seeing itself as an instrument for broadening the Labour Party's appeal generally and actually campaigning for socialist policies within the working class as a whole.

The left has in recent years tended to focus on internal Labour Party issues which are seen by many non-activists as totally esoteric, rather than concentrating on the type of organisation that you actually need to carry out policies.

There is also a strong tendency for the left to regard the passing of motions by GCs as the be-all and end-all, rather than looking at how to organise on the basis of those policies within the wider community.

Any regroupment that takes place in the Labour Party left has to look at those wider issues of how you make links outside the Labour Party Paul Whetton secretary of t rank and file tee.

with the announcement of the closure of Cortonwood.

It must now be clear to everybody what the Coal Board intends to do. They consider themselves to have won a clear victory over the miners and therefore to have a mandate for mass pit closures. I think it'll probably get worse unless there is an answer from the rank and file.

Many of the miners and some of the leaders are saying that now is not the time: the lads are not ready, and all the rest of it. But if we sit back and wait until such time as the lads are ready, then the Coal Board will carry on from the more than 4 million tonnes capacity they've already taken out.

There'll be a rapid rundown, with the ultimate aim of privatisation. The new colliery near Coventry will probably be sunk with Coal Board money and then handed over to private owners.

There's only one answer to this: the members have got to to be ready, and industrial action has got to be initiated fairly soon.

The Coal Board's strategy now is to go in hard at the militant areas, but also wholescale throughout the British coalfield, including Notts, where two pits are to shut and there may be more to follow shortly.

The campaign for an amnesty has to continue. It's not just an issue for the miners, it's an issue for every trade unionist, that people are put in prison for fighting for jobs.

A firm commitment by the leadership of the Labour Party is needed now. I'm sure it would give heart to those that have lost jobs or are in jail. And it mean the Labour Party acting as the champion of the working class. That would bring a lot more support behind the Labour Party than the half-promises we've had so far.

We can't wait until the next general election. Someting has got to be done now. It's got to come both from the leadership of the TUC and the leadership of the Labour Party.

I hope the question of the scab leadership in Notts will be sorted out at the annual conference. It's a matter of strategy. Perhaps now the issue of expulsion has gone on that long that it has become a dead duck. Steps are now openly being taken for a breakaway. It may well be best to let them break away rather than to expel them.

is the former le Notts miners trike commitBob Fine analyses the crises and contradictions in the apartheid regime which lie behind the current xplosion in South Africa INTERNAL resistance against the apartheid regime in South

Scan page 6

Africa has been growing apace. There are almost daily reports of strikes, boycotts, sabotage and riot by the oppressed majority.

The state's response so far this year has been to shoot dead over three hundred blacks, to murder at least three in custody, to arrest thousands and to expel thousands more back to the so-called "homelands" . South Africa has entered a new period of intensified struggle.

Closely allied with the South African Communist Party, the African National Congress is a leading wing of the national liberation movement. It is now planning the first Consultative Conference since its Morogoro conference in 1969. Things have changed dramatically since 1969.

Then the liberation movement as a whole was at a low point. Internal resistance in South Africa had all but disappeared since 1961, the turn to armed struggle having proved to be a terrible failure. The campaign for international sanctions had made no headway against the lures of lucrative foreign investment in South Africa.

Today the situation is entirely different and far more hopeful.= Trade unions An independent trade union movement has arisen out of the ashes of the movement defeated in the 1960s. Organising black workers in the industrial and commercial heartlands of South Africa and now well entrenched within the mines, the trade union movement has become a major force for change.

Numerous community and student groups have been reborn and formed themselves into two national organisations.

The one, the United Democratic Front, is a multi-racial grouping in the tradition of the old Congress Alliance and now with the politics of the ANC, Mandela and the Freedom Charter.

The other is a black-consciousness movement called the National Forum, whose most important component is AZAPO, the Azanian People's organisation (Azania is the 'African' name for South Africa). This movement has picked up a large number of black socialists.

In addition, there are organisations like the Cape Action League, which has inherited the mantle of the old "Trotskyist' Unity Movement. Radical literature, meetings, slogans and campaigns abound in South Africa in a way that must stretch markets for primary and manufactured consumer products are more intensely competitive and difficult. An underlying balance of payments deficit caused by the import of capital goods and new technology has been offset only by banking loans. The strength of the dollar has caused the value of gold to drop. Inflation is high, lay-offs are common and unemployment (stated to be around three million for blacks) is rising.

The multinational monopolies which dominate the South African economy are putting presure on the South African state to contain the black unrest and restore profitability. In response, a state policy has evolved that combines highly significant 'reforms' with increasing authoritarianism.

In 1981 a labour law reform was initiated which extended the legal sphere of operation of black trade unions. The state intended to control and incorporate trade unions by subjecting them to an official framework, but the resultof these reforms has been thé considerable strengthening of the movement.

In 1983 the government announced its constitutional reforms. It set up a tripartite parliament, one house for whites, one for Asians and one for Coloureds. Africans were not included on the ground that Africans already had their own self-government in the Bantustans. At the same time, the government consolidated the power of the state executive and military and put off the next general election at least until 1989.

The elections for the Coloured and Asian assemblies were successfully boycotted, although enough Coloureds and Asians voted to lend the new arrangement some credibility.

The government also extended its scheme for black local councils, which include Africans. These too were boycotted and collaborating black councillors have been a major target for demonstrators during the recent unrest. Several have been killed, many have been driven to resign.

The first group of 120 black "peace officers' graduated in Soweto in May to serve under and protect the councillors. Considerable financial and patronage incentives have been put in the way of black councillors as inducements to voluteer. But the government is not finding it easy to find candidates.

More recently the Mixed Marriages and Immorality Acts, which banned marriage and sex between individuals of different 'races' have been repealed. The pass laws have been relaxed, to allow for easier movement for qualified blacks within the white urban areas, and to allow for easier access for blacks to the black urban townships.

Reforms

A right to hold freehold tenure in urban areas has been conceded to Africans. There has been a temporary halt to all forced removals of black people forced removals for about 700,000 potentially threatened South African citizenship is to be granted to Africans living in the Bantustans. The law banning representatives of one 'racial' group from interfering in the political affairs of another (which, for example, meant that Asian representatives were not permitted to discuss white affairs, etc.), has been repealed.

Reforms like these have been accompanied by terrible acts of state butchery. The worst was at Langa in March of this year when the police opened fire on a peaceful funeral procession commemorating the 25th anniversary of the 1960 massacre at Sharpeville.

According to official figures, they killed 19 blacks, but the unofficial count was around 45 dead.

An executive member of FOSATU (the Federation of South African Trade Unions), Andries Raditsela, died one hour after being released from custody, from severe head injuries. A student leader, Sipho Mutsi, died in custody shortly after. A thousand soldiers and police sealed off Kwanobuhle, a black township in the Eastern Cape on May 6 and killed three more black people. And so it continues.

In the face of conflicting pressures, the white polity itself has split apart. Although the ruling Nationalist Party under Botha has strengthened its grip on government and continues to win support in the white polls, for several years now it has been faced with opposition from a right-wing breakaway movement called the HNP, led by, a man named Treurnicht.

The HNP has been gaining support among whites disenchanted with a policy of concessions, and squeezed in a declining economy between black workers below and the monopolies above. It seems that this right-wing movement has won a considerable following within the police and the army.

It would be a mistake, in my view, to pass off the government's reforms as a mere deception covering up the unchanging reality of apartheid. So keen Clockwise from left: Crossroads sq funeral in the Eastern Cape; Gold: School students revolt, Soweto 191 Durban.

have militants in the liberation struggle been to dissociate themselves from reformism that they have sometimes been blind to the very real changes in the terrain of struggle that have been taking place.

Change One example out of many: Tribune commented: "Sharpeville 1960. Uitenhage 1985,, nothing has changed in 25 years...Progress...liberalisation ..are nothing but a sham" (29/3/85). Certainly, apartheid continues to be a brutal reality, but it is also true that black struggles over the last decade or more have brought about significant changes and opened up new opportunities for the movement.

----- pull-quotes -----

continued from p.1 government, unless the District

reinforced Kinnock's position by saying that when it

the crunch you just

diary Don't sit back WE'RE back where we began

from zones designated as 'white' and a permanent halt to

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 232

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →