To be continued Next week: the liberation movement, the black trade unions, and political strategies
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 7
of reform and repression, the state is attempting, none too successtully so tar, a programme of restructuring aimed at restoring conditions of profitability. The Financial Times recently summed up some acnents of the economic nroblem
Manoeuvre
This is roughly how the problems looks to the ruling South African capitalist class. The solution which it seeks follows the familiar road of monetarism
Scan page 8
Socialist Organiser no.232 June 12 1985 Page 8 In the late 1960s and early '70s, Vietnam's Some socialists, while supporting the Vietnamese struggle, did warn that the Communist Party leading that struggle was a Stalinist party, which in 1945-6 had massacred the Vietnamese Trotskyists. Most activists, carried away by the heroism of the Vietnamese, dismissed this argument as sectarian.
Vietnam today, unfortunately, is a bitter mockery of their enthusiasm. In this interview with SO, two members of the Vietnamese Trotskyist Group in France describe the Stalinist regime The fete included debates on New Caledonia, on campaigning against racism in France, and on the British miners' strike Every year in large fields out- LCR support the Kanaks in their side Paris, the French Trotskyist fight for independence. The organisation Lutte Ouvriere difference is that LO insists on (Workers' Fight) holds a three- criticising the Kanak Liberation day fete. It is a carnival of Front as nationalist rather than music, food, drink and revolu- socialist, while the LCR stresses tionary politics. the possibility of the Front In between the restaurant 'growing over' from nationalism tents, drinks tents, jazz and rock to socialism. bands and children's games, A big argument both in the socialists from different coun- forums and in individual discustries sell their literature, hold sions was LO's line on the meetings, discuss and argue. British miners' strike.
This year the fete was organ: LO vehemently denounced the ised jointly by Lutte Ouvriere LCR's (and Socialist Action's) with the Ligue Communiste attempts to dissolve themselves Revolutionnaire (LCR), the politically into "Scargillism" . So French sister-group to Socialist far, so good. But LO's own attiAction'. It attracted its biggest tude to the strike was strange. attendance to date - about They denounced Arthur Scar40,000 people and filled gill for not trying to spread the a bigger area than in the struggle. But, we replied, the past. fact is that he did try to spread The general situation in it. Yes — LO said - he called France is not good: the miser- for other workers to support the able record of the Socialist-led miners, but he had no real policy government has demoralised to develop a general strike. workers and created fertile soil LO's opinion, it turned out, is for the that socialists should have advoNational a vote as big as the Communist the creation of democratic strike Party's. But there is obviously a committees and organising minority which - given tenacity strikers to go out to all the facand hard work - can be won to tories, depots and offices to revolutionary ideas. argue for a general strike. MayDozens of discussion 'forums' be that could have sparked off a took place over the three days. general strike; in any case, Some of the best-attended through controlling their own debated current differences struggle workers would learn between LO and the LCR. the best lessons from the LO is an impressive organisa- struggle. tion. Most of their work is organ- It seemed improbable to me, ised around individual factories, and I suspect LO's vision is where they produce regular distorted by the great differbulletins. The bulletins take up ences between the French and day-to-day issues in the work- British labour movements. place, as well as big political Obviously this 'debate will conissues. tinue.
Sometimes, however, they Socialist Organiser had a stall, seem sectarian in their attitude selling papers and magazines, to other movements. For exam- and discussing with as many ple, very much in evidence at people as we could. Particularly the fete was the badge useful were discussions with "Don't touch my friend" - of Vietnamese Trotskyists (we did SOS-Racisme, a movement set an interview which will be pubup to counter the National Front lished this week); with veteran and a recent wave of racist kill- Trotskyist Edmund Samaraings. koddy from the Sri Lankan The movement could become Revolutionary Workers' Party; something like the Anti-Nazi and with an Italian group, League in Britain, though as yet called the Revolutionary Socialit has not had the same impact ist League (LSR), which was among youth. Like the ANL, too, linked with Nahuel Moreno's its politics are unclear - its PST in Argentina but broke sponsors include members of with them over Moreno's Argenthe right wing parties, though tine-chauvinist line on the Falkthe main force in it is the Social- lands/Malvinas war. ist Party. The size of the fete is an indiThe LCR has jumped right cation of the comparative into SOS-Racisme, endorsing it strength of the revolutionary left lock, stock and barrel. LO is in France — largely the result of rather stand-off-ish. the experience of the great Another difference is about general strike of 1968. New Caledonia. Both LO and of Saigon, 1975 THE economic situation is disastrous. The CP has nationalised everything, even the small traders.
We are for the nationalisation of big properties, but not of everything — because when you nationalis jou have tn he able o provide the means to operate better than under private ownership. The result is that people don't want to work. Since 1983-4 they've introduce piecework.
In the late "70s food production declined drastically. Now they say things are better. But there is still terrible poverty in the south.
The American comrades [the Socialist Workers' Party - US] rejoice that everything has been nationalised, and they say that's socialism. But it's not.
The working class is controlled by the party. There is no liberty. The trade unions don't really exist.
Privileged
The CP bases itself on the working class, separating out a privileged layer in order to form a bureaucracy. For example, the child of a worker, or a party member, can get into university with a score of 10 in the exam, whereas others need 15. But the working class does not have the right to express itself freely.
To get a good job you have to be in the party. For the party functionaries, functional privileges become economic and material privileges.
They have higher salaries, special shops (which are expanding), trips abroad, free holidays, cars, chauffeurs — all that makes them a social category different from the masses.
The situation is still not like in Eastern Europe. In Vietnam the imperialism was central to world politics.
and how it developed. opposition is still not dangerous.
The CP uses soft methods towards the masses, but violence against opposition. During the resistance to the Americans, 95% of the population supported the CP. Today, if there were free elections, the CP would not even get 30%.
Everyone is discontented. People say that the CP was good during the war, but it is no good for the reconstruction.
The CP operates a dictatorship by manipulating and controlling people, not by terror. In Ho Chi Minh City, in each district there is a party member responsible for security checks on everyone living in the district, with agents reporting to him. The police can come into your house at any hour of the The opposition of the population has not yet crystallised. The Trotskyists in Vietnam have not been imprisoned - though the CP knows them - but they can do nothing.
But this situation cannot last long. It is said that there were some strikes five years ago, very quickly put down. But eventually the opposition will emerge.
The CP is a Stalinist party in its programme and its ideology. Before it came to power it put forward a nationalist policy and organised the NLF to win all the sections of the petty bourgeoisie.
After the victory, there was a 180° turn. The CP abandoned its alliance with the bourgeoisie in a brutal manner. The NLF was treated as nothing at all. The northern CP took control, immediately.
The petty bourgeoisie felt FRANCE conquered Vietnam in the 1860s (the south) anc the 1880s (the north). In the 1920s a movement for independence began. It was led by bourgeois nationalists, by Ho Chi Minh's Communist Party, and - from 1931 - by influential Trotskyist parties.
One group, 'October' , Put out a daily paper in 1939. The other, 'La Lutte' , led by Ta Thu Thau, published a joint paper with the CP in 1933-37. Breaking this alliance as the CP turned to popular front politics, the Trotskyists gained control of the paper and, in 1939, resoundingly defeated the Stalinists in the Cochinchina (south Vietnam) Colonial Council elections. The candidates of La Lutte' got over 80% tricked and turned against the CP. Even leaders of the NLF and members of the southern CP were discontented. -The north is more tightly controlled. But the south feels as if it has been conquered by the north.
At first, after the victory, it was the collaborators who were leaving Vietnam. Now there are even members of the CP getting out.
Saigon
When they entered Saigon, there was no mobilisati in of the masses. There were people's councils, but they were organisof the vote.
From September 1939, fter ce repression by the French administration drove both Stalinists and Trotskyists underground, and then, in 1940, Japanese troops occupied Indochina.
In 1945 Japanese power collapsed. The Vietminh, a front organisation of the CP, was the strongest force in Vietnam. Ho Chi Minh drafted a Declaration of Independence based on the US declaration of 1776, and welcomed British and French troops into Vietnam.
The Trotskyists reappeared with the slogans: 'Down with imperialism! People's Committees everywhere! Arming of the people! Land to the
Scan page 9
Organiser no.232
----- pull-quotes -----
National Front, which now ses cated not mass picketing, but