Overthrow bureaucrats
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
NIXON,HITLEF ASSASSINS In ten days at the end of 1972, the US dropped a greater tonnage of bombs on North Vietnam than was dropped throughout the world by all the Allies in the whole of World War 2 ed by the army. Then there were elections - but they were fake elections. The CP are Stalinists - they fear the masses.
Now there is enormous corruption. If you've got money, you can get out. Everything can be bought.
During the war, people had respect for the members of the party - they fought bravely, with self-sacrifice. Today, no -you see people entering the party in search of privileges.
Vietnam has been isolated economically by the US. Pierre Rousset [a French Trotskyist] explains the bad situation as due only to material conditions. In fact there is much more to it.
Almost half the state budget peasants! Toward the workers and peasants' government!' For the Stalinists, this was a threat. In late 1945 and early 1946, the CP, so moderate towards French imperialism, turned on the Trotskyists and massacred them. Ta Thu Thau was shot in February 1946.
But in late 1946 friction between the Vietminh and the French turned into open war. The CP in France supported colonlalism through its ministers in the government (until May 1947); but the Vietnamese CP began to fight. By 1954 it had the French on the run. The USSR stepped in and sponsored a deal at Geneva which gave independence to the north while the south had a neo-colonial regime, now under US sponsorship. is given to military spending. They maintain an army of one million - 250,000 in Cambodia, 100,000 on the Chinese border, 50 or 60,000 on the Cambodian border, and a number in Laos.
Expansion
The Vietnamese CP has a policy of expansion. It wants to establish an Indochinese federation under its rule, to play the role which the USSR plays in Eastern Europe.
Pol Pot's party in Cambodia had had differences with the Vietnamese CP for a long time. But the VCP did deals with Pol Pot. Then a border conflict beThe struggle against imperlalism restarted in the south from 1960, escalating into full: scale war from 1965. In May 1975 the US withdrew, defeat ed. At the peak they had had half a million troops in Vietnam.
Some Vietnamese Trotskyists remained after the massacre of 1945-6. The Vietnamese Trotskyist Group, which gave us the interview above, is based around comrades wh left Vietnam in the early 1950 and have since been active in France. They are affiliated to the United Secretariat of the Fourth International, but critical of the USFI's soft attitude to the Vietnamese Stalinists and its consequent lack of interest in developing Vietnamese Trotskyism. came a pretext to invade Cambodia, basing themselves on a minority wing of the Cambodian CP round Heng Samrin.
At first they benefited from the ultra-reactionary policy of Pol Pot. The Cambodians welcomed them with open arms, as they were welcomed in South Vietnam. The VCP thought it would be a very quick operation. But now attitudes are changing even among the Cambodian leaders. Cambodians are traditionally suspicious of Vietnamese - very sensitive about their nationalism.
Behind it all the invasion of Cambodia had a political motive. Vietnam wants to be the leader in the region.
Ta Thu Thau: Trotskyist les killed by Stalinists in 1946.
In 1936 our comrades put forward the slogan of an Indochinese Socialist Federation, and the Stalinists were very hostile to it. That was before their victory. Now they have the victory, they want to deal with the matter in an administrative fashion. In contrast, our aim is to mobilise the masses for a clearly proclaimed objective.
Agriculture is organised in two sectors in the north - state farms and cooperatives - and three in the south - state farms, cooperatives, private plots. The state farms are the major sector. The CP says today that they went too quickly in collectivising agriculture after 1975. There is no movement for full-scale decollectivisation as in Poland, but it is not impossible that they will follow the example of China, giving much more scope to the free market.
Vietnam is now economically in hock to the USSR, but there are conflicts. The Russian technicians are very unpopular in Vietnam, even among the members of the CP. In contrast, the Cuban technicians are very popular — people see them as having come to help, while the Russians come to exploit.
Maoist ideas are still strong in the CP. The cadres were educated as Maoists. There is no real opposition inside the CP, but different tendencies are visible in the leadership.
There is a tendency, represented by Vo Nguyen Giap [the main military leader of the anti-imperialist war], which criticises the party for being ton Maoist, ultra-left, too rapid in its economic measures. The opposite pole, more old-style Stalinist, is represented by the head of state, Truong Chinh. Le Duan, the general secretary of the party, occupies a middle position. Extracts from a document of the Vietnamese Trotskyists published in 1976.
The Vietnamese workers' state has been born bureaucratically deformed, and it has no internal possibilities of preventing the evolution towards bureaucratic degeneration.
The sincerity and the revolutionary ardour of Ho Chi Minh, of Tito, and of Mao, are not in question; only their integration into the world of Stalinism brought them to install mechanisms which must inevitably transform the leading layer into a privileged and omnipotent bureaucratic caste...
The fact that the VCP has successfully led a revolutionary struggle does not contradict this affirmation.
Like bourgeois democracies or fascist regimes, the workers' bureaucracies of Stalinist origin are not identical, even if they are genetically similar. To believe that a bureaucratic caste can only be cowardly and capitulatory is a narrow view, and besides contradicted by the attitude of the CP USSR during the Second World War when it was fighting for its survival...
Should we lose all hope? How to understand that a people which has given the world such a lesson of courage, of revolutionary ardour and of original initiatives, can be satisfied with a regime thai gives it no free speech?
China and Yugoslavia are there to show us that in a country where the peasantry constitutes the overwhelming majority of the population, if the revolutionary party ignore the problem of bureaucratisation, the working class is incapable of opposing the degeneration of the victorious party.
Its leadership, despite its record of prisons, torture and exile, transforms itself into a privileged and uncontrolled caste.
It has the power and it will not abandon it. Its prestige due to the victory and the gains of the revolution, and the immense exhaustion of the Vietnamese people, will give it quiet for several years.
But after that? Young peop le will come into political life who consider independence and the collectivisation of the means of production as an established fact. The aura of old combattants will not be able to mask the reality of the privileges and the mediocrity of intellectual life.
It will no longer be possible to black out news and to prevent the penetration of new ideas (new for Vietnam):
• the right for several workers' parties to coexist, • right of tendency in the Communist Party, • independence of the trade • democratic administration of the state by a pyramid of councils starting from rank and file level, • freedom of the press, • suppression of the privileges of the members of the party and the state apparatus...
Vietnam will not develop a socialist democracy without the ruling layer, its bureaucratic structures and its party being overthrown by force. This is what the Trotskyist movement has always called a political revolution.
Ho Chi Minh
Scan page 10
Organiser no 232 June