The Sandinistas against Reagan
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-12Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
Moceracior Les As the rate of extinction of living species increases, modern genetic engineering techniques provide us with the means of finding out a little about some lost forms of life, as weil as allowing us to indulge in harmless fantasies about resurrecting them.
The unique information that defines a species is carried as a chemical code - long molecules of DNA. Each organism has its own unique DNA (with some exceptions) and each cell of the organism possesses a copy of this unique DNA.
Some groups of organisms with identical DNA do exist and are called clones. They arise where organisms reproduce by splitting into identical naives. Among bacteria, clones are the norm. Among the higher animals they are quite rare, being known as identical twins, trip lets, etc.
The genetic engineering technique of "cloning" uses the rapid reproduction of bacteria into clones to multiply a small amount of useful DNA. A gene which codes for a useful protein is inserted into the DNA of a bacterium and soon there are billions of bacteria with copies of the desired DNA.
Now if we could obtain as little as one complete copy of the DNA of an extinct species, we could use cloning to multiply it. Then we could analyse it easily, comparing it with existing relatives to get information about the process of evolution. Perhaps we could even recreat the species.
There are, of course, problems. DNA is quite a fragile chemical. In life, it has to be constantly maintained to repair the damage done by heat, radiation, viruses and harmful chemicals. After death, it rapidly decomposes. Scientists have therefore looked for ancient DNA in tissues that have been preserved in some way, e.g. by pickling in brine (in the case of the quagga), by drying (mummies), and by freezing (Siberian Mammoths).
The quagga was a close relafive of the zebra and was hunted to extinction by 1883. Last year, American genetic engineers extracted the DNA from the skin of a museum specimen. Only 1% of the original amoung survived, but it was cloned and then compared to the DNA of the mountain zebra. It was found to be quite closely related.
With the amount of quagga skin' available, it ought to be possible to extract in fragments the whole DNA. If this DNA could then be reassembled and inserted into a fertilised egg of a mountain zebra, it might be possible for a baby quagga to be gestated by a surrogate mother zebra.
The same could be true for the mammoth which also has a easonab close relative surviving in the elephant. However, only tiny amounts of mammoth DNA have ever been found in the frozen Siberian specimens and it woul be a truly mammoth task to reassemble a full set of DNA.
The most sensational success in this field was the recent cloning of some of an Egyptian mummy's DNA. Suante Paabo, a scientist working in Sweden, reported the extraction of DNA from the mummy of a child that died 2400 years ago. 5% had survived intact and when cloned was shown to be identical to modern human DNA.
In principle it should be possible to obtain a full copy of this mummy's DNA and perhaps even clone the mummy.
However, this has never been done with human DNA (despite a claim a few years back) and would be a pointlesse exercise since Ancient Egyptians are not extinct. Their genes survive in many of the people of modern Egypt, North Africa and elseIt might be informative, though, to compare mummy genes to those of modern peoples to trace population movements. The evolution of viruses carried by humans could also be investigated.
Using the technique on preserved humans in other parts of the world could help answer questions about the rate of evolution amongst isolated groups of people, the origins of the native Australians, the origins of the European population, etc.
Examination of modern DNA has shown for example that the sickle cell gene has arisen separately in Senegal, Benin and Nigeria while North African sickle cell anaemia originated by emigration from West Africa.
Finally, what about cloning dinosaurs, everybody's favourite extinct animal? Unfortunately, no-one has ever detected any dinosaur DNA. After some 50 million years, it all seems to have broken down.
But even if enough was found to make intact dinosaur DNA, we would still need to find a suitable egg to put it in. Unlike the quagga and the mammoth, dinosaurs have. no close relatives surviving. Their nearest relations are the birds which are substantially different. In any case, the dinosaurs' habitats have gone.
It might be a good idea to preserve the DNA from modern species in danger of extinction, in the hope of being able to resurrect them when conditions are more favourable. The present day Noah's Ark might be a collection of containers of liquid nitrogen at minus 200°C with vials of DNA in them.
Next week, I will look at what else can be learnt from ancient bio-chemicals. Gerry Byrne reviews the Panorama programme on Nicaragua, entitled 'Seeing Red' (Monday June 10).
I EXPECTED to see more bodies. TV coverage of such conflicts tends to be long on gore but short on analysis.
Atrocities were touched on. A mealy-mouthed State Department spokesman dutifully pronounced that such things happened on both sides in a civil war, and while we regret it, etc...
Rather more chillingly, an American nun, Rachel Pinal, who had worked in Nicaragua for years, reported horrific mutilations carried out by the contras on civilians while they were still alive.
Overall, though, the coverage was both sober and sobering. Nicaragua was described as one of the smallest and poorest countries in Latin America, and as having the biggest army in Central America (60,000 regulars and 30,000 militia). True, but misleading.
Ubviously you can't compare the size of armed forces when one side has the United States behind them.
Assertions
Panorama attempted to sort out the truth concerning Reagan's assertions about Nicaragua. Contrary to his claims, and on the other side those of misty-eyed revolutionaries, the Sandinista government does not pretend to be Marxist or communist.
Its foreign minister described their policy as deeply nationalist, anti-imperialist, and committed to the wellbeing of the Nicaraguan poor. He compared them to other Third World countries favouring economic growth.
Anti-imperialism here is understood as opposition to foreign, mainly US, intervention, not class struggle against international capital.
I see no reason to doubt the government's concern for the well-being of the Nicaraguan poor, or their disavowal of class-based politics.
So how do the Sandinistas fare judged by their own lights?
The one interview done with a member of the masses was extremely brief and entirely negative. No, she didn't meddle in politics. No, she had noticed no changes in her own life. The revolution had brought her nothing.
Hardly the stuff from which to draw conclusions either way.
Crisis
The Nicaraguan economy is in crisis. Properly speaking, it only came into existence six years ago. Before that there was little more than Somoza's private bank balances. There is runaway inflation, rationing, and a flourishing black market.
There has been a huge influx of people from off the land into shanties around Managua.
But what civil war especially one in which the opposition is backed by the US - has not produced these symptoms of economic disContras - armed by the US location?
The programme was short on details of how the regime has alleviated, or might have contributed to, the crisis.
We got a tantalising glimpse of a riot in Managua which began which began, we are told, as a protest against rising prices and restrictions on trade unions, and turned against government troops.
After Somoza's overthrow his lands were redistributed to peasant cooperatives. The government embarked on a massive literacy, education and health programme. But 60% of the economy remains in private hands.
Austerity
That national capital can continue to exploit unhindered suggests that the brunt of the austerity measures falls on the workers and peasants.
But it is only guesswork. We are not shown to what the degree the Sandinista organs of popular power can effectively express the interests of the masses, or to what extent independent alterna tives are developing.
True to the traditions of bourgeois liberal journalism, Panorama was more concerned with the fate of the pro-US paper 'La Prensa' and with the ex-National Guard contras than with the workers and peasants who fought Somoza.
-The censorship may not be so overt, but we're still waiting for the truth about the Falklands War.
Penalty
One of the first acts of the government was the abolition of the death penalty. There are few people who take up arms against a state who can expect to be treated as lightly by the state as the Nicaraguan contras.
The programme made clear that Reagan has done everything in his power to overthrow the government of Nicaragua short of all-out war Garrison The programme showed a US base in Honduras with a permanent garrison of 1,000 US troops which regularly plays host to 10,000 more on 'exercises'.
It is not necessary to take The US anti-slavery campaigner William Lloyd Garrison wrote the following in the first editorial of his paper, "The Liberator', in January 1830.
Garrison and his paper championed the blacks for 35 years, until 1865, when, following the Union's victory in the Civil War, slavery was at last abolished.
Assenting to the 'self-eviden truth' maintained in the American Declaration of Independence, 'that all men are created equal and endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights — among which are lite, liberty and the pursuit of happiness', I shall strenuously contend for the immediate enfranchisement of our slave popu: lation.
In Parkstreet Church, on the Fourth of July 1829, in an address on slavery, I unreflectinly assented to the popular but pernicious doctrine of gradual abolition. I seize this opportunity to make a full and unequivocal recantation, and thus publickthe Sandinista government as a model in order to oppose the US war. It is slanderous to say that Nicaragua is less democratic than its neighbours or indeed than the bulk of the 'Free World' . But it is daft, on the basis of populist rhetoric, to give the Sandinista government, unasked-tor, the leadership of the world revolution. ly to ask pardon of my God, of my country, and of my brethren the poor slaves, for having uttered a sentiment so full of timidity, injustice and absurdity...
I am aware that many object to the severity of my language; but is there not cause for severity? I will be harsh as truth, as uncomprising as justice. On this subject, I do not wish to think, or speak, or write, with moderation.
No! no! Tell a man whose house is on fire, to give a moderate alarm; tell him to moderately rescue his wife from the hands of the ravisher; tell the mother to gradually extricate her babe from the fire into which it has fallen; — but urge me not to use moderation in a cause like the present.
I am in earnest -I will not equivocate — I will not excuse -I will not retreat a single inch - and I will be heard. The apathy of the people is enough to make every statue leap from its pedestal, and to hasten the resurrection of the dead.
Scan page 11
BASINGSTOKE. Contact: Alan
----- pull-quotes -----
Songs of liberty and rebellion