Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

[Spare a thought for the plight of Brother…]

Socialist Organiser no. 233, 19 June 1985 · scan pp. 4–5 · Martin Thomas · about 1,886 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 4 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 4

Spare a thought for the plight of Brother Gostwick is Scottish reporter for the tankie-controlled Morning Star. He is also editor of the Scottish Miner, paper of the Eurocommunist-led Scottish NUM. Despite vallant efforts, he is finding it increasingly difficult to maintain his balancing act.

When Scottish church leaders called for a return to work during the strike, Gostwick dutifully bombasted them in the pages of the Morning Star only to be rapped over the knuckles by McGahey for it.

Gostwick made amends with a grovelling letter in the Eurocommunist "Focus" about how he had failed to appreciate the outstanding work done by Scottish church leaders.

But now, with the clashes between Scargill and Eurocommunists Bolton and McGahey increasingly coming into the open, Gostwick is finding the going tougher than ever.

Only a clever division of labour enabled him to survive last week's Scottish NUM conference: Gostwick provided bland and evasive coverage, while the McGahey/Bolton/ Scargill clashes were covered by Star deputy editor David Whitfield.

Scan page 5

nd the Brussels tragedy VIOLENCE The causes...

..The sources of hypocrisy MOST primitive peoples according to the Marxist anthropologist Evelyn Reed - find modern war incomprehensible.

Their societies have plenty of violence and feuds. But Australian aborigines, for example, "have no conception of the possibility of territorial conquest by armed force."

They would probably find the Brussels football violence incomprehensible, too. The fighting between fans looked primitive. But the whole system of publicity, communications and transport by which the fans were brought to Brussels is highly 'advanced'. The symbols around which they rallied -nations or cities - are highly abstract.

A primitive people might understand fighting for your family or clan or tribe - but surely not something as impersonal as a city or a nation.

It may be that aggression is a fundamental part of human nature. Probably, also, male-dominated societies accentuate the aggressive instincts among men. But on that basis different societies show a vast range of forms and amounts of violence.

Capitalism, fundamentally, has industrialised violence.

Code

The knights of the Middle Ages, who fought for the sake of fighting, did so within a code which stressed personal honour, personal loyalty, personal feuds.

Personal violence is still common today. But most of it has been squeezed into a very narrow arena: the family, where men are violent against women and adults against children.

It is impossible to know exactly how family violence today compares with previous centuries. But the evidence - for example, the fact that in feudal society rape was not considered to be a crime against a women, but one against her husband or father — suggests it is probably less.

Meanwhile impersonal violence, and in particular the violence of the ruling class, has expanded.

The old wars of dynasties — which passed, albeit destructively, over the heads of the mass of the people - have been replaced under capitalism by wars of nations. And while the kings and lords of old had to stab and beat their enemies to death, often at some personal risk, today's masters of war can just press a button to kill thousands or millions.

Under all forms of class society the rulers have inflicted violence on the ruled in the form of poverty. Today this violence, too, is high-tech. Not the crude and clumsy methods of the robber baron, but a vast and sophisticated system of international communications, trade and finance is organising the mass slaughter of millions of black Africans through starvation.

Capitalism has also made the violence of the oppressed classes more impersonal.

When the Industrial Revolution was recent enough for the close kin networks of an older society still to be living memory, Friedrich Engels wrote this about the great cities England:

*The very turmoil of the streets has something repulsive, something against which human nature rebels. The hundreds of thousands of all classes and ranks crowding past each other, are they not all human beings "And still they crowd by one another as though they had nothing in common...The brutal indifference, the unfeeling isolation of each in his private interest becomes the more repellent and offensive, the more those individuals are crowded together...

Today, on the streets of big capitalist cities, you can fall ill, be attacked, or be run over, and thousands of passers-by will simply ignore you.

This intense alienation of human beings from each other is generally worst in the most developed, most prosperous capitalist countries. Suicide from despair (rather than from, for example, ritual obligation) is a new form of violence characteristic of this alienated society - personal in a way, and yet also in the highest degree impersonal.

We escape from the acute loneliness only by becoming part of crowds. These crowds - be they football crowds or others — loosen the real but one-sided, alienated, civilisation imposed on the individual, and create the conditions for highly impersonal violence as a means of selfassertion.

Fascism uses this fact to intoxicate ruined middle-class people, individually helpless, with the prospect of becoming part of a mighty destructive force.

Revolutionary socialism, too, depends on the effect of mass mobilisation in overcoming individual consciousness of helplessness and fear. The difference is that we aim to channel the aggresssion of the massed assemblies in ways which heighten the self-determination of the individual and nourish a permanent labour movement capable of calculating coolly and liberately how to change society.

Base The impersonal, industrialised violence of the ruling classes — very far removed from basic human drives — can be removed by removing the economic basis of those classes. The alienated violence of the oppressed classes can be combatted by creating a society of cooperation rather than the rat race.

Personal violence within the family will be reduced as women and children gain in self-confidence and the stifling family unit gives way to broader and more flexible arrangements.

Capitalism has brought violence to its highest form. It has also created the preconditions for a non-violent society.

Martin Thomas (Islington) Violence at the European Cup final. THE articles by Tom Rigby and Clive Bradley on the 'Brussels Disaster' in SO 231, were good for the broad philosophical and political basis from which they attacked the hypocrisy of the Thatcher-inspired sabre rattling of Tory politicians and sports 'personalities' alike.

Yet I felt that the articles never really pinpointed the real source of such hypocrisy. Jeremy Seabrook wrote an excellent piece in The Guardian (June 3) on the root causes of the violence and the role that Thatcherite economics played in its eruption. Basically it boiled down to two main premisses, which I'd like to develop. That:

1) The more extreme areas in Britain of industrial recession and social depression often have the strongest support for local football teams. Why? Denied the traditional working class forms of self-respect (*a decent job') and solidarity (in industrial struggle), due to mass unemployment and devastated, poorly housed communities, many young workers, in particular, turn to football as the only real, tangible form of pride and selfexpression. What else is there for a young Liverpool or Millwall worker to identify with but 'the team'? (I suppose some might say Derek Hatton in Liverpool!)

Other"

In such areas, football is even more than usual an arena for displaced energy and yes, even aggression, against the 'other? side. Usually, of course, the aggression is muted - merely chanted or sung.

2) At the height of the worst recession for several years came the Falklands War, which Thatcher carefully manipulated into a major exercise in politically expedient chauvinism.

It was no accident that The Sun's vicious articulation of violent jingoism found a significant working class substantiation. The mood that Thatcher exploited, and to a degree created, has been called one of "Authoritarian Populism". In practice, the leap from a passionate defence of "The Team" to defence of "one's country" is not such a big one. Both forms of populism depend on the notion of The Enemy Abroad. For the more unsubtle minds, the dividing line between "Bash the Argies" and "Kill the Dagos" is a thin one indeed.

Futile It is not even the 'reverse side of the coin' - both states of mind are the direct consequence of a section of working class youth that have been severely economically exploited (YOP, YTS), dumped on the dole, and then, during the Falklands, subjected to emotional exploitation by the Tory Press supporting a futile war in order to further a political revival for their party.

no.233 1985 Page The riot in Brussels was a spontaneous, quasi-Falklands campaign (the island in this case was a stranded Liverpool supporter(s) being bullied by Juventus supporters), fuelled by the same xenophobia that 'won' the war.

The NF probably were involved, frontrunners like the SAS. The real problem, as Clive and Tom suggest, is to redirect such misplaced working class anger towards the real enemy. The miners' strike was inyaluable for at least this one thing — it allowed workers to feel their own strength in opposing the real Enemy Within.

As for the validity of football, and competitive sport in general: it is not simply a matter of our witnessing the degeneration of a traditional and 'honourable' form of working class culture. Football, it is true, has always been part of working class culture, linked to real regional variations in work, identity, accent and so on. But let's not get sentimental about it.

Apart from the fact of who owns and controls the game (not the players, for sure!), football has also always been a massive safety-valve for an oppressed class.

Eşcape

As for the other main reason given to support the game, that it can provide an escape route for a few working class youth skilled in the game - I don't doubt it; but then, Grammar Schools served the same funtion: escape for a tiny minority 'skilled' in the examination game.

It's hardly a reason to applaud such hopelessly inadequate, institutionalised step-ladders.

Sport 'in itself' (a dubious notion) may well serve as a "creative endeavour" , a "major means of self-expression" for youth unused to enjoying success and self-esteem (this is especially true in schools, when mainly working class kids reject the academic curriculum for sport and more practical subjects).

But can we really talk of sport in a vacuum? It is intimately linked with political reality; not simply because it functions, like capitalism, on competition 'per se', but because of the way in which governments use it in international 'politics' as a bargaining counter, and because of the way it is used internally as another mechanism for social control.

To sum up then: you can admire football for the energy and solidarity it breeds amongst working class youth if you want; but it is an illusion because such solidarity lacks purpose. When that illusion shatters, as it did in Brussels, and the real feelings of long suppressed frustration emerge in violence, then it is false to start lamenting the degeneration of the game. The reality lies in the degeneration of capitalism that, for reasons of appeasement and profit, promotes such games, then professes horror and surprise when some of its supporters reveal the violence signifying the true nature of a system that depends on physical exploitation and violent repression for its continued existence.

Dave Gore (Nottingitam)

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 233

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →