Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

The Power to Smash Aparthi

Socialist Organiser no. 233, 19 June 1985 · scan p. 6 · about 1,011 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 6 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 6

Bob Fine concludes his article on South Africa by looking at perspectives for working class politics.

The organisation and mobilisation of blacks inside South Africa has now been taking place on a significant scale since 1973, after the previous decade of defeat.

How have the various sections of the black resistance movement responded to the changes in the apartheid state's policies and to the spontaneous militancy of black workers and students? Naturally, each section has responded in line with its own political heritage.

The African National Congress has had great difficulties in adapting itself to a struggle in which the focus is not on sabotage from without nor on international sanctions, but on internal resistance. strike' ', the turning of black townships into no-go areas by the action of small bands of armed youth, a call to black soldiers and policemen to quit their jobs and the institution of 'people's committees' as alternatives to the black councils.

He hailed the two-day general strike in November as evidence of 'a very substantial shift on the part of workers toward acceptance of the view that they must be part of popular mass struggle"

In my view the ANC's analysis is not precise enough. First, the idea of 'people's power' is no more than a rhetorical device need to cover and shenure important differences which exist between the various sections of the 'people' and it says nothing about the form of state for which the ANCis fighting.

Second, this is not the first time that the South African ruling class has entered into deep crisis. 1946, 1960 and 1976 were other such occasions, and each of them in the end proved to be a springboard for the recovery of the ruling class. On this occasion there is little evidence as yet that the ruling class are anywhere near being unable to rule. be opposed to apartheid. It comprises a coalition of 645 affiliated groups and claims a membershipof over two million - though the UDF's attempt to gain a million signatures for its petition to free Mandela fell far short of its target.

it is formally a non-racial grouping and has attracted a number of leading liberal figures like Bishop Tutu to its ranks.

It has within it some fine intellectuals, like Neville Alexander who, under the name of No Sizwe wrote a fine critique of the nationalist politics of the ANC called 'One Azania, One Nation' '. What links its various threads together is, partly, a common negative opposition to what they term as 'charterism' - emphasis on the ANC's South African Freedom Charter which they tend to think of as contaminated by liberalism; and partly a common commitment to non-cooperation with or boycott of all state institutions.

This has strained their relations with most of the trade union movement, which naturally work within as well as outside official structures of negotiation.

A flavour of what separates them from the UDF can be Sained from their respective nanaung or aenneay s recent visit. The UDF acted as Kennedy's host and expects much from his support for the sanctions campaign in the States. The NF boycotted Kennedy and on a number of occasions blocked him from speaking. union movement has managed to build and consolidate among black industrial, commercial and now mining workers. It has made significant strides toward forming a united trade union movement (that could mature in the next few months).

The trade unions have also engaged much more actively than in the past in political struggles, taking a major role in the boycott of the new elections, leading and providing the muscle behind the two-day stayat-home in November, in which more than half a million workers participated - Johannesburg was entirely paralysed - and offering a working class political perspective which is nowhere else to be found.

These are the three major contending groupings as things now stand.

It is important not to confuse the jostlings for power and advantage by competing petty bourgeois groups, each laying claim to leadership, with the real class issues that face the movement.

The big underlying question in the liberation struggle is the relation between the working class and the liberation movement as a whole, between socialism and nationalism, between the fight against apartheid and the fight for socialism, between working class forms of struggle and forms of struggle which leave the working class as bystanders applauding their tatives on the united front that organised it found themselves somewhat compromised by statements about no-go zones and the like put out by some of their colleagues. Perhaps this explains why further calls on workers to stay away from work have not been notably successful.

Workers cannot be pulled in and out like puppets, and South African history has many examples to prove this. Workers also stand to lose not just their jobs but their right to reside in an area where jobs are to be found, when they strike. They want to know that the reason is good and that their organisation is good. It is too easy to declare workers backward when they fail to perform what others want of them or, alternatively, to uncomprehendingly idealise them as everready to take militant action. After the two-day stay-away all 5000 SASOL workers were sacked and sent back to their homelands (though some were subsequently re-employed).

One of the most signiticant areas of trade union development at the moment is in the gold mines. For the Economist (10/5/85) this is where the real action is.

In mid-March the NUM demanded a general 10% rise; two weeks later it declared an official dispute. 400 union members were immediately dismissed and negotiations flopped. The following night 14,000 workers, almost the entire underground force in the Vall Reefs gold mine, owned by the giant Anglo-American, failed to turn up.

The dispute spilled over into a neighbouring mine. Every striker, 17,000 in all, was sacked by Anglo and bussed back to the "homelands' . Two bombs exploded in Anglo's Johannesburg office on April 30. Since then negotiations have been resumed.

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 233

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →