One Palestine, oi
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The desolation of the Palestinians. Photo: Donald McCullin. For about seven years Socialist Organiser editor John O'Mahony has held to a minority point of view among SO supporters in that he rejected the call for a secular democratic staie in Palestine as unrealistic, and argued that socialists should advocate a solution to the conflict of Arabs and Jews in Palestine on the basis of two states. Here he outlines his views. We have'to support the Palestinians, as the oppressed, against Israel as the oppressor. However, what is our alternative to the existing situation of oppression?
The idea of a secular democratic state as a solution to the Jewish-Arab conflict is a good and attractive one in the abstract, but it is impossible to realise. These are distinct nations which have related to each other with bitter communal-national hostility or unrestrained war for 50 or more years (from the 1936 Syria-Palestine general strike and earlier).
The Jews occupy a distinct national territory (most of the area within the pre-1967 borders of Israel).
The secular democratic state as we have understood it involved the smashing and destruction of the Israeli state, an end to the Law of Return (which gives Jews everywhere in the world a right to Israeli citizenship), the return of the Palestinians to all the territory of Israel. All this was expected to enfold and merge the two peoples into a democratic secular state.
for us of the idea of a secular democratic state lay in its alleged ability to do justice to everyone concerned. The Jews would cease to be 'Zionists'. . The Palestinians could return and either repossess or be compensated. The Jews would have equal rights to what they have created in the last 40 years.
It is plainly nonsense.
Nothing short of the complete, inevitably very bloody conquest of the Jews, and driving them out or slaughtering them, would be required to enforce it.
At the end of such a process, the last thing you would get would be the intermingling of the two peoples in one secular democratic state.
The idea of the secular democratic state is a mental construction incapable of realisation in our benevolent version of it. Since the PLO was re-