A democratic, secular state
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 9
Bruce Robinson argues that a single democratic state in Palestine is the best framework to advocate; the collective rights of both Arabs and Jews can be safeguarded by some form of local autonomy.
The Palestinians suffer three aspects of national oppression. Firstly, they lack a territory in which to live as a nation. The areas from which many of them came in 1948 have since been settled and are now inhabited by an established Jewish population. Many Palestinians wish to return to live in those areas.
Secondly, the West Bank and Gaza Strip have since 1967 been under a military occupation by Israel, which has combined wide-ranging repression of the Palestinians with settlement of these areas by Israelis.
Finally, there is a 650,000 Arab popullation within pre-1967 Israel, who are discriminated against as second-class citizens. In the northern parts of Israel in which they are concentrated, they form a majority in some areas.
As Marxists we are concerned to find a consistent democratic solution to national oppression which allows both national groups the fullest rights compatible with not oppressing anyone else. This is both because we oppose national oppression as such and because the divisions it causes prevent the development of class unity.
sion ot pre-1948 Palestine.
The first option would lead to both arbitrary borders and to continued national conflict. Given that Israel would remain the dominant economic and military power in the area and that in this option Israel would remain a Zionist state, a West Bank/Gaza state would either have no room for independent action and be subject to Israeli domination or very quickly come into conflict with Israeli 'national interests', probably leading to war.
Over the last couple of months Socialist Organiser supporters have been re-discussing our line on Palestine.
We have always supported the Palestinians' struggle against Israeli oppression, that is not in question.
But among the Palestinians themselves, among their supporters, and among anti-Zionist Israelis, there are various different programmes for that struggle. Which programme to support?
Up to now SO has backed the mainstream Palestinian policy of replacing Israel by a reunified democratic, secular Palestine, in which Jews and Arabs (Muslim and Christian) can live as equals.
Some SO supporters argue that this 'democratic secular state' project, although desirable, has no grip on political reality, and that we should therefore advocate the creation of an independent Palestinian state alongside a mod ified Israeli-Jewish state.
We print some discussion pieces.
While it might provide an immediate solution for the Palestinians in the occupied territories, it is unlikely to lead to a long-term defusing of national conflicts.
The second option tries to solve the problem by giving both Palestinians and Israeli Jews the right to decide on which state they want to belong to. This option does not seem to deal adequately with the wish of many of the Palestinians to be able to live in the areas of pre-1948 Palestine from which they originally came. It is also not clear how the West Bank/Gaza state would be a step towards such a federal solution.
A common state — the third option -seems to me to provide the best structure for a long-term solution. Such a state would have to be based on a recognition and guarantee of the collective rights of both Arabs and Jews to maintain their separate identities. Such rights would include freedom of religion and language, control of education, etc. They couid be implemented by a form of local autonomy where communities whether Arab, Jewish or mixed — would have the power to decide freely on these