Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Merging oppressor oppressed

Socialist Organiser no. 233, 19 June 1985 · scan p. 9 · about 872 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 9 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 9

organised in the late 1960s and the old 'drive the Jews into the sea' leader Shukairy gave way to Yasser Arafat, the secular democratic state slogan has served fundamentally as just an Arab propaganda weapon in a conflict which could not conceivably, by the victory of the Arabs who supposedly fought for it, lead to the creation of a secular democratic state in Palestine.

A roughly equivalent project would be to amalgamate the German and French nations on the territory occupied by one of them. The difference is in the intense level of fear, grievance, and mutual animosity that exists between Jews and Arabs compared with French and Germans.

In reality, there are only two alternatives in the situation:

1. Drive out the Jews (that accept that that is what military conquest - 'smashing the Zionist state' - would mean). Abandon any commitment to defend the rights of the Palestinian Jews. Or:

2. Create two states.

"Drive out the Jews' - most of them born in Palestine from parents. the core of whom were refugees from racist persecution - has no place in our programme or world outlook. It is the programme of rampant Arab chauvinism.

That leaves the two states solution.

It would serve no purpose for us to try to define precisely where the borders would lie, or what precise relationships the two states would have with each other, and with Jordan, the Lebanese communities, etc. (If it could be achieved, some form of federation of Israel, the Palestinian Arab state, Jordan and the component parts of Lebanon would seem to be the best framework within which to solve such problems as economic viability, overlapping and intermingled populations, etc.)

The point of principle here is that there is no way other than the creation of two states in Palestine to express the idea that the Palestinian Jews have the right to stay in Palestine, and at the same time to express and define the demand for the restoration of the national ghts of the Palestinian Arabs. Full Arab restoration to all of Palestine is now impossible short of driving the Jews out.

This is a basic outline of my position, so I have not attempted to elaborate on any of the points made or to anticipate objections. Some Socialist Organiser supporters who previously advocated a democratic secular Palestine have been convinced in the recent discussion that this formula is not an answer to the national conflict in Palestine, but rather a description of something desirable which might be possible after the national conflict has been resolved. Martin Thomas argues this Generally no situation of serious national oppression can be resolved by proposing to amalgamate oppressor and oppressed nations on the basis of individual equal rights. To propose this in Palestine is to produce a democraticsounding formula which actually can only be a gloss for Israeli-Jewish subjugation of the Palestinian Arabs (in a Greater Israel) or Arab subjugation of the Israeli Jews (in an Arab Palestine).

Or else it is advice to the Palestinians to become super-internationalists, and then to wait until the Israeli Jews are also super-internationalists and they can live in harmony.

Paradoxically, the 'democratic secular Palestine' slogan actually denies the Palestinians' national rights as much as the Israeli Jews'. The slogan tells the Palestinian Arabs either to wait until the Arab states subjugate the Israeli Jews or to wait until the Israeli Jews become internationalists.

But Marxists should propose objectives for struggle for the Palestinians UN Partition Plan Jewish state, 1947 Territories seized by in 1948 and 1949 Territories seized in June 1967 Mediterranean Port Said SIN'A CAIRO uez EGYP River Nile which they can win without having to rely on dubious external saviours or a miraculous change of heart by their oppressors. That, to my mind, is a crucial argument for a 'two states' position (whether simply "two states' , or coupled with a proposal for federation of those two states, is a secondary matter).

The Palestinians can fight for their own state in part of Palestine, perhaps also linked to a revolutionised Jordan; they can fight for Israeli withdrawal from the West Bank and Gaza, and for national minority rights (including the right to secession) for the Arabs in Israel.

They can - in principle-force such concessions from Israel. They do not have to emancipate themselves in advance from all national prejudice for such a solution to be possible.

The Palestinians could get a democratic secular Palestine — a real democratic Palestine, a real merging of the two nations - only by themselves first becoming pure-minded internationalists, and then the Israeli Jews freely agreeing to give a democratic Palestine to them.

Far from being a solution to the national question, the democratic secular Palestine is something which might be possible after the national question has (by some other means) been solved. You could almost say about it what Marx said about the labour money' demand popular with socialists of his day: it can be realised only under conditions where no-one would any longer particularly want to raise it. -BEIRUT LEBANON amascus Sidon ASYRIA Haifa Gaza Jerusalem Jore an Strait

----- pull-quotes -----

PAL jablud Tel Aviv Amman

Gulf of Suez Gulf of Aqaba) SAUDI ARABIA

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 233

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →