What rights for Jews ?
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
In May 1980 the editorial board of Workers' Action - one of the groups which founded SO in 1978 - discussed Palestine.
The discussion was summarised in minutes taken by Martin Thomas. The issues now being discussed by SO supporters were spelled out clearly. Excerpts:
John O'Mahony: Think about the concrete implications of the secular, democratic state slogan for Palestine. It has no grip on reality. It's an ambivalent slogan, fundamentally wrong because it proposes the forcible integration of two peoples. The history of Zionist oppression is terrible. But forcible integration means forcible abolition of nationality, which is hardly possible. We're for a socialist united states of the Middle East, but we also need to uphold self-determination. We don't need to question the sincerity of the Palestinians' declaration of not being hostile to Jews as such. But what is the logic of depriving the Jews of the right to their own state? It's inconceivable it will be acceptable to the Jews. Who's going to do the forcible integration? There is no force capable of making it happen. The only even conceivable method is conquest of Israel by the Palestinians and/or Arabs. A socialist revolution is more feasible than the secular democratic state.
The secular, democratic state slogan is not 'algebraic' in a real sense, just ambivalent. It actually means just Palestinian nationalism. But the national rights of the Israelis must be part of our programme. A nation has been created - by terrible means perhaps, but it exists.
Our error: to identify with the oppressed (which is correct) but to go from that to identifying with their nationalist programme (which is wrong).
Our only real answer for the Palestinians consistent with the Israelis' rights must be some sort of partition. (Though I don't know what dividing line).
We've failed to distinguish between the historic reality of Zionism and Zionism as a political entity now. There is not just Zionism as an ideology but also the vicissitudes [i.e. recent history] of the Jewish people.
The USFI approach, which has coloured our attitude mental third-worldism.
And what about the Jews in Israel who were born there? We can't visit the sins of their fathers on them. Parallels with South Africa, Northern Ireland, etc., do not hold up. Zionism is not fundamentally about exploiting Arab labour. And, if Northern Ireland were a homogeneous Protestant state, would we advocate military conquest of it?
I don't propose raising self-determination for the Israeli Jews now. But it should be part of our programme. Self-determination for the Palestinian people - does that include the right to determine what happens to the Jews? It seems to, so I'm against it.
An Israeli Jew at the Western Wall. Photo: Donald McCullin.
Israel is a racist state? Yes it is. But aren't all states racist. What's different about Israel is the hostility to and driving out of the Arabs. But the major racist crime is now a fact of history.
Is a different Israeli state possible? Yes, it is possible: e.g. withdrawal to 1967 frontiers, etc.
Bas Hardy: John's attitude would amount to left Zionism. He approaches it entirely from the Israeli angle, not at all from the Palestinian.
John ignores the evolution Greater London Labour Party Executive Former Leader, Hackney Council Fatah states it "would help Jews anywhere if they faced persecution by racists" • It also recommends rights for the Jews and, e.g. Hebrew as an official language in a secular, democratic Palestine.
The PFLP say they don't think Israel is a nation — colonialism cannot be justified just by continuing a bit longer. Israeli workers, even, gain from their settler-state status.
These positions are completely different from the caricatures presented by John. There is even considerable racism within Israel against Oriental Jews. Yes, Jews were terribly oppressed. But that cannot justify their oppression of the Palestinian nation. If Israel were even curtailed as John indicates, then there would in any case be massive emigration.
Imperialism wants a Palestinian mini-state. John's attitude is similar. And where are the Palestinian refugees to go?
Rachel Lever: The Israeli nation is not just some cultural society, but it has a big state apparatus, an expansionist logic, etc. Crimes of 30 years ago? There have been two wars and a lot of other