Destroy Israel, equality for Jews
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-06-19Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 10 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 10
WHAT WENT WRONG?
Hilda Kean Mick O'Sullivan Monday 1st July 7.30 Red Rose Club 5 minutes Finsbury P: Come to Labour Party Youn Socialists summer camp! A week of sun, sport, relaxation and far more political debate than YS conference. It's at the Bracelands camp site in the Forest of Dean from July 27 to August 3. The cost is around E30. if you are i-te-asted in coming, phome Jame on To or 01-609 7459 crimes since. The crimes continue.
But John is contradictory. The Jews are supposed to be so backward that they will quit and go to New York rather than live together with the Palestinians. And at the same time the Israelis are presented as innocents, while the Palestinians are presented as likely to cut the Israelis' throats and drive them into the sea.
If the Israelis want to emigrate because they can no longer oppress the Palestinians, that 1s up to them. Bruce Robinson: Is the secular democratic state feasible? Well, is John's proposed reformed Israeli state, e.g. within 1948 frontiers, feasible? And how would repartition help the struggle for socialism? It would increase tensions and conflicts.
The secular, democratic state is not, l think, utopian — it is an algebraic slogan for the national conflicts in Palestine. John seems to confuse the rights of the Jews in the area and their right to a state. And much of what he says about the changes in the nature of Zionism is a myth. Logically, John's position wind lead to arguing the PLO should gir, up their struggle.
London Bridge Committee London Bridge Committee London Bridge Committee. Socialist Organiser.
129 SEVEN SISTERS This is an excerpt from an editorial in the paper Workers' Fight, October 20 1973. It contains two political commitments - to the destruction of the Israeli state by external force, and to full rights for ihe Jewish population who inhabit it. Its author, John O'Mahony, now argues that these two commitments are incompatible, rendering writing such as this politically incoherent.
A DECISIVE and crushing defeat for Israel will be [good] news for revolutionary workers throughout the world, and for enemies of imperialism everywhere.
We say this knowing that the working class rules in neither Israel nor in any personal Capacity Arab country, and that on that level there is nothing to choose between them.
Yet the world's working class, including the Israeli working class though it doesn't yet know it, has an interest in the defeat of Israel and in the victory of the Arabs.
Israel is a pro-imperialist policeman in the Middle East, a bayonet permanently pointed at the throat of the Arabs and their desire to free themselves from imperialist rule.
Israel is also a racist state.
The 'pampered child of imperialism' in the Middle East, the Zionist State of Israel, has by its very existence been the main force militating against the growth of independent working class consciousness in both the Arab and Jewish Middle East peoples. Only the defeat of Israel and the destruction of the Zionist state opens a way through the road block which Israel is for the Arab, and Jewish, masses of the area.
The open support of the British press for Israel has as its centrepiece defence of the "right of Israel to exist" . That, for once, takes us to the heart of the question.
We are firmly opposed to the existence of Israel: we say it has no right to exist.
We are opposed to Israel's existence because its existence is inseparable from the oppression of the Palestinians, who have been driven from their homeland because, according to the way the Zionist state is constructed, they are racially unsuitable. Whilst the Palestinians are prepared to participate in a multi-racial state, the Zionist state is racially exclusive and must be destroyed before such a multi-racial state can be built.
The Jewish community has, of course, a right to reach an agreement with the Arabs, and the demand for the defeat of Israel is not at all the demand to expel or drive out her population. The only solution is to create a secular democratic state in which the Palestinians have full right to return to their homeland with compensation and full equality with Palestinian Jews.
But the existing exclusive zionist state can only exist at the expense of the Arabs, in alliance with and under licence from their imperialist masters: such a state can never be even a normal capitalist state, because it is based on "religion' and race' and deprives the Palestinians of the right to live in their own country, while every Jew in the world...is automatically a citizen of Israel...
----- pull-quotes -----
don't come with us to LPY! summer camp?
Why councis claverd in to rate Capping