Socialist Organiser

Paper of the Socialist Campaign for a Labour Victory, the Socialist Organiser Alliance and the fused WSL, 1978 to 1986

Rigging the NHS figures

Socialist Organiser no. 234, 3 July 1985 · scan pp. 7–8 · about 1,313 words

Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 7 →

Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.

Scan page 7

Lady started to undermine the le scheme's pretentions to tlity'. aced with increasing probof "indiscipline' (that is, mal resistance by trainees) le A employers are likely to uit still more selectively, leaving more young people e catered for under Mode ind annulling the governt's intention to move irds an increasingly ployer-led' scheme. further effect of creeping pulsion might be that, in r to defuse trainee resise, the MSC would make it er for young people to swop -mes, leading to the appear: of 'sink' schemes and a still. se public image. nder normal circumstances, government would naturally to its allies in the upper elons of the TUC and Labour ly to help it over these diffiies. And indeed, Kinnock ved that he was ready to nteer his services when he nissed 200,000 school stuts who took action against compulsion on April 25 as ties* Problems fortunately, it seems that 1 in this quarter problems be developing.

number of groupings, inding beyond the revolu ary left to include a broad strum ot professionals elved with the scheme, are inning to establish themes. These include the ifield-based Labour Movet National Inquiry into th Unemployment and ning, and the Londonid Action on Youth Rights Opportunities. REITS mal Equality in Youth Train Schemes) has recently ught out an effective exposI race discrimination in YTS nes, using data collected in Coventry.

If any of these break through to a other union leaders will start to find themselves in the same sort of embarrassing situation now occupied by some of those high up in NATHE, the college lecturers' union. It is their misfortune to have to sit as TUC reps on the various Manpower Services Commission committees which are planning the activities do wider public, extension of YTS to when, as of Whit NATHE's annual has voted to oppose scheme in its present 'Signs To sum up, the signs for those who have consistently opposed YTS from the beginning are moderately encouraging. two years weekend, conference the whole form.

George Norman Fowler's 'The Health Service in England' leaflet is supposed to 'help you see how the NHS is developing and improving'. In fact it consists of an unrepresentative selection of statistics from The Health Service in England; Annual Report 1984' (HMSO) which are often of dubious validity.

450,000 copies of this leaflet have been distributed throughout the English NHS (although not it seems in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland). It ostensibly originates from the Department of Health and Social Security, but its crude propagandist tone identifies it more closely with the Conservative Party Central Office.

Mislead

The leaflet is deliberately misleading in a number of ways. It compares health statistics for two years only, 1978 and 1983. No reason is given to explain why 1978 — the year before the Tories returned to power - is chosen in a supposedly non-party document.

Choosing two years only doesn't allow people to see how changes may be a part of a long term trend. For example perinatal mortality - still births and deaths in the first week of life -has been falling steadily since the mid-1950s, so a fall between 1978 and 1983 is not surprising.

Furthermore the years to be compared are arbitrarily altered if it gives a better picture. The leaflet says that waiting lists are down, 'reduced from 750,000 in 1979 to 690,000 in 1984. This compared March 1979 - the peak of the waiting lists following the 1979 industrial action -to March 1984.

If March 1978 had been chosen instead, a 15% increase in waiting lists would have been seen. Furthermore there have been changes in the definitions of waiting lists to reduce the numbers. People waiting for day surgery are now excluded from the figures.

Figures

Fowler tries this strategy again with staffing level figures.

NHS staffing level statistics are given in Whole Time Equivalents' - i.e. part-time employees are counted according to the fraction of the full-time week she or he works. In 1980 the full working week of nurses was reduced from 40 to 37½ hours per week, so increasing the whole time equivalent work force by 7% overnight without a single extra hour being worked. Of course this is not mentioned when trimphant statistics are given about improved staffing levels.

The Royal College of Nursing report from 1983 says that 'Nurses want the public to know that standards of care are already threatened, that staffing levels on wards hover just above danger level and that out in the community increased numbers of patients are overburdening community care and making good nursing practice practically impossible."

A third way of cooking the books is by presenting only one side of a gain/loss situation. For example the leaflet says that 11,000 new beds were opened between 1980 and 1984 (many of them planned before the 1979 election). However, overall there has been a net loss of 12,900 available beds between these times.

NHS spending is compared only to the Retail Price Index level of inflation. But prices in the NHS have risen in advance of general inflation, and when considering the health service, spending must be considered relative to need.

With the proportion of the population over 70 increasing and with technological advance, need for resources increases. The debacle of the cervical cancer screening service reveals one vast area of unmet need.

Thatcher has consistently claimed that "The NHS is safe with us' . But are even health service statistics safe in her hands?

A similar book-cooking exercise has taken place with unemployment statistics, with changes in definition excluding many from the figures in an attempt to make the rise in unemployment look less disastrous. The recent figures supposedly revealing an increase in employment were given in such a way to disguise the fact that an increase only occurred in part-time "pin money" jobs and that the decrease in full-time employment has continued.

Don't believe number they say.

Lies

It is important for people working in the health services to combat Fowler's lies. Radical Statistics Health Group have produced a booklet 'Unsafe in their Hands' from which many of the above details originate.

It is available for 50p from Radical Statistics Health Group, c/o British Society for Social Responsibility in Science, 9 Poland Street, London W1V 3DG. If you are really hard up it can be obtained free from the Cardiff Socialist Organiser group, c/o 22 Norwood Court, Roath, Cardiff.

Scan page 8

At the Socialist Organiser AGM on June 22-23, we discussed Palestine.

Until now SO has supported the slogan of 'a democratic, secular Palestine' . Some SO supporters still say we should call for a single state Palestine, embracing Jews and Arab: others argue we should propose an independent Palestinian-Arab state alongside a modified Israeli-Jewish state. We published some discussion articles last week.

The AGM felt that we weren't ye ready to take a decision, and so reso ved to continue the discussion.

This week we publish a draft statement of the 'two states' position by John O'Mahony and Martin Thomas. Further contributions to the debate are welcomed, and will appear over the coming weeks.out.

b) Economically, a larger unit is pr ferable. The present economic isolatic of Israel from the surrounding countri is economically irrational and political leads to dependence on the US, etc. Ger erally, the division of the Middle Ea into several, mainly small, nation-stati boosts nationalist and commun narrowness, economic underdevelo ment, and imperialist manipulatio A West Bank/Gaza state, or even West Bank/Gaza state united wil Jordan, would be extremely weak ea nomically and thus would be forced in dependence on states like Israel (tł main employer of West Bank/Gaz labour) or Saudi Arabia (the paymaste of the present Jordanian state).

Though our programme is a sociali federation of the Middle East, wit self-determination for national mino ities (Israeli Jews, Kurds, etc.), thi should not contradict proposals fo

← Contents of Socialist Organiser no. 234

Something wrong on this page? Tell us →