[The Palestine question mainly presents itself to working-class…]
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
The Palestine question mainly presents itself to working-class militants as follows:
a) 37 years ago a new Jewish state, Israel, was created in Palestine by immigrants from Europe, America, and the Arab countries. The core of them were refugees from European antisemitism, including survivors of the greatest racist crime in recorded history, Hitler's massacre of six million Jews.
The Jewish state is heavily dependent on outside financial support and it functions as a satellite of US imperialism, though it has autonomous interests and projects of its own.
b) Most of the Palestinian people have been displaced, and transformed into refugees and stateless persons outside Palestine. The remainder are either an oppressed minority within pre-1967 Israel, or under military rule in the West Bank and Gaza.
c) A chronic national antagonism exists between Israeli-Jewish and Arab workers in the region, and between Jewish and Arab workers in Israel and in the Israeli-occupied territories. This antagonism has crippled the working class in the entire region for many decades.
Our problem is to explain and interpret these developments and to answer the question: what programme do socialists propose as a solution to the JewishArab antagonism in Palestine and in the region?
The most widespread left-wing reaction to the Palestine problem states or assumes that the Zionist enterprise was and is a 'conspiracy, and identifies Zionism totally with imperialism. General denunciation of 'Zionism' and 'Zionists' follows, in terms which imply that the 'Zionists' have no rights in Palestine except possibly individual rights.
Class considerations therefore give way to national/communal categories. The Arab ruling classes have more than once massacred Palestinians, and willingly condemn them to be pawns on the political chessboard; but this outlook puts the Arab states on the progressive side. The whole question is seen as a mere item in the struggle between progressive and reactionary, good and bad, camps on a world scale. The problem is thus defined almost as a conflict of good and bad peoples. Against this, we assert basic Marxist working-class ideas. Class is decisive. We approach all questions of national and communal antagonisms from the viewpoint of the class struggle, and of the working-class programme for solving such conflicts by way of consistent democracy.
The Palestinian Arabs are bitterly oppressed; but a Jewish nation exists in Palestine and has a right to continue to exist there, with national rights which irreducibly include the right to self-determination on some territory of its own. We champion the Palestinian Arabs' fight against oppression and displacement on a programme not of the implicit or explicit denial of Jewish rights, but of compensation, restitution, smaller federations, e.g. in Palestine.
c) Full-scale repartition would b bloody and almost certainly untid! creating material for fresh conflicts.
For these reasons, advocacy of federation would be advantageou for Jewish-Arab working-class uni Jews -Aras not conditional on federation bein possible. It is the irreplaceable firs step to peaceful coexistence of Arab and Jews in Palestine and thus to work ing class unity.
Opposing Zionism T... Historic Zionism, 1897-1948, wa reckless and devastating in its conse quences for the Palestinian Arab people But we reject the idea that eithe historic Zionism or modern ZionisI (i.e. pro-Israel Jewish sentiment, how ever defined) can be simply described a racist. The state of Israel is a state pur suing racist policies and heavily base