How to unite Arab and Jewish workers
Socialist Organiser1985 1985-07-03Read it in the scan (PDF), scan page 8 →
Read from the scan by machine and not corrected: expect misread words, and now and then a caption or a line from a neighbouring story. For anything you quote, read the scan.
Scan page 8
everywhere, whether in Britain, Northern Ireland, or Palestine; and the Palestinian Jews are chauvinistic and exclusive. We support those in Israel and the West Bank/Gaza who fight for JewishArab equality. But the ending of Jewish chauvinism and exclusiveness is not and cannot be, for us, a precondition for accepting that the Jews have rights in Palestine.
The Jews have the right to a certain portion of the territory of Palestine by virtue of the fact that they are there, and most of the Jews now there were born there. Their rights there cannot be made conditional on how they conduct themselves in that territory, any more than the vile racist immigration laws of Britain — which we fight and oppose, as some Israeli socialists fight and oppose the chauvinism of the Israeli Jews -nullify Britain's right to exist. (Or any more than the openly chauvinist line of the Palestinian Arabs' leaders up to the late 1960s could nullify the Palestinian Arabs' national rights).
Self-determination
We recognise the right to self-determination of the Israeli Jews; we support those in Israel who fight chauvinism and exclusiveness and advocate equal citizenship of Arabs and Jews; we advocate an independent Palestinian-Arab state on the best terms possible which are compatible with Israeli-Jewish national rights. All these elements must be combined into one coherent working-class socialist viewpoint. ible. National identity, and still less national oppression and conflict, cannot be conjured away; two hostile nations cannot be amalgamated into a single unit.
Where there is national oppression, the demand to 'forget national differences' is usually a cover for the oppressor. A unitary Palestine - in the foreseeable future - would mean a state in which the Palestinian Arabs were oppressed by the Israeli Jews, if there were no outside intervention.
In fact the practical meaning and implications now of the Arab-nationalist slogan, 'democratic secular Palestine' are: full conquest of the Israeli Jews by the Arab states. It is not a proposal for a democratic solution, but the cutting edge of Arab propaganda in a drive for Arab conquest which would turn the Jews from oppressors into the oppressed.
À "democratic, secular Palestine' is not an answer to the national question, but something desirable which might be possible in the distant future after the national question has (by some other means) been solved - indeed, after national identities and prejudices had begun to wither away. As a proposed solution to the Palestinians' oppression, either it tells them that they must themselves shed national prejudice, and then also convince their oppressors to do likewise — or it is an encoded term for full suppression of the Israeli Jews by the Arab states.
West Bank/Gaza
3... Immediately, we demand an independent Palestinian state in the West Bank and Gaza, in line with the ri ght of self-determination of the people of those territories.
Mini-state
4... A Palestinian mini-state in the West Bank and Gaza could alleviate the situation, but the national conflict of Palestinian Arabs and Israeli Jews would certainly continue. A solution to that conflict demands a more far-reaching programme. - Considered as a national territory for 4½ million Palestinians, these areas — essentially fringe districts of the Israeli state — are very limited in size and resources. They could not provide an adequate Palestinian homeland.
Right of secession
5...Meanwhile some 600,000 to 700,000 Arabs would remain under Israeli rule.
The Israeli Arabs consider — rightly - that they are part of the PalestinianArab nation, that they have rights in the areas where they live (and have long lived), and that the territory of Israel cannot be considered the exclusive property of the Israeli Jews. The situation of the Israeli Arabs is thus not a separate 'minority question' , but an integral part of the Palestinian-Arab/ Israeli-Jewish conflict.
We support the right of secession to the Palestinian-Arab state of the mainlyArab areas within present-day Israel (western and central Galilee, Little Triangle).
Over one million Palestinians live in Jordan, forming half or more of the population there. They live under the rule of a monarchy artificially created by British imperialism, and propped up militarily and financially in succession by Britain and by the US and oil-rich Arab states. We support the overthrow of the monarchy in Jordan, and federation or merger between a Palestinian mini-state and a democratic Jordan.
Federation 6... If it can be achieved, a federal relationship (in the circumstances, necessarily a loose one) between the PalestinianArab state and a modified Israel (or over a broader area, including agreements to defend the rights of the Arab minority and of Arab labour in Israel, will be preferable to Arab secession from Israel and full-scale repartition.
a) The two nations are at present heavily intermeshed (Arabs living in Israel, West Bank and Gaza people working in Israel, etc.) Full intermeshing is not possible in the short term, given the national hostilities. However, we should seek to minimise the separating on racist institutions. It was not and i not a racist conspiracy, but rather a pro duct of many circumstances. To try t *ban Zionists' is to try to outlaw th reflex nationalism of the mass of Jewis people, and it is thus in effect anti Jewish.
In terms of political argument, how ever, we counterpose internationalisn to Israeli-Jewish nationalism, and demo cracy to Jewish sectarianism and Jewisl supremacy in Israel (or any modifier Israel). Within Israel (or any modifier Israel) we argue for full individual right: and national minority rights for the Arabs; for an end to the ban on Aral labour in major industries; for an end tr Israel's alliance with US imperialisn and its role as a major military supplie! to South Africa, Central American dicta torships, etc; for the full separation o religion trom the state; for the dismant ling of the specifically 'Zionist' features of the state (in particular, the set-up whereby quasi-state organisations, the Jewish Agency and the Jewish Nationa Fund, provide funds and services to Jews only); for the creation of a labour movement independent of the state and the employers.
We demand compensation from Israel and the US to fund the resettlement of the Palestinian-Arab refugees in the Palestinian-Arab state.
The repossession of all Palestine by the Palestinian Arabs is now impossible without suppressing the Jews; and the Israeli Jews' national rights cannot depend on them ceasing to be 'Zionists' or agreeing to an unqualified right of resettlement in all of Palestine for Arabs. However, among the Israelis we would argue for immigration laws which would allow individual Palestinian Arabs to move in and out freely or to go and live there. Israeli-Jewish agreement to easy entry for Arabs would be an essential contribution to national reconciliation and working class unity.
We explain to Israeli Jews that no nation that oppresses another can itself be free or secure, and that they can achieve peace, freedom and security only by a democratic attitude towards the Arab peoples — just as we explain to the Palestinian Arabs that any solution that would oppress the Israeli Jews would be regressive and reactionary.
Arab states
8... While the Arab states have been victims of predatory attacks by Israel, they themselves are bourgeois or bourgeois-feudal states with expansionist and predatory ambitions. They have cruelly oppressed and more than once massacred the Palestinian Arabs. While in some circumstances we side with the Arab states against Israeli attack, we do not support the destruction of Israel by the military forces of the Arab states.